Hearthpwn

I decided to make a tier list of the WOG cards now that everything is released, but one that really means something, as a tier list is often very personnal. So i used the polls the community answered for every card, and created 5 tiers from the 5 options : Meta-defining is Tier 1, Very good is Tier 2, Playable is tier 3, Bad is Tier 4 and Dust is Tier 5. I choose the highest percentage of vote in a category to put them into a tier. I also divided Tier 2, 3 and 4 into 2 sub-tiers, the tiers + and - . For example, a tier 2 card that has its second highest number of vote in "Meta-defining" will be tier 2+, and a tier 2 card that has its second highest number of vote in "Playable" will be tier 2-

I also classed the cards in the differents tiers by percentage of votes. In the + tiers, the card with the smallest percentage are the best (because a lot of other votes were made in the upper tier) while in - tiers, the cards with the highest percentage are the best.

Some card's percentage are not in the correct order, because i moved some cards to reflect better some rankings that don't work with this technique.

In Ittalic, next to the cards, are my personnal comments.

Tier 1  These cards will define the Meta

C'Thun 77.1%

Am'gam Rager 71.2% I don't even see why it isn't 100%. Ultimate counter to Magma Rager ! Finally this cancer is gone

Master of Evolution   59.9%                                                    

Evolve 54.5%  I think this is the most broken card of the expansion - The value for 1 mana is insane.

Doomcaller 54.1% Very surprised about this one. I think it is overhyped.

N'Zoth the Corruptor 53.6%

Fandral Staghelm 52.8% A bit overhyped i think. Will not likely stay on the board, and combo it right away is good but not OP.

Eternal Sentinel 48.1% This one has 47% votes "very good". I think it's more suited tier 2, but stats are stats.

Tier 2+ These cards will see competitive play in several decks.

(The first 5 cards (*) are not in percentage order, but they are very close to Tier 1 so i put them in order of the most tier 1 votes)

Twin Emperor Vek'lor *45.2% This card should definitly be tier 1. If C'thun becomes viable, this card is simply OP

Flamewreathed Faceless *44.1% This card is broken in arena, and will see play in constructed due to the BGH nerf.

Faceless Summoner *51.6%

Hallazeal the Ascended *41.7%

Shadowcaster *47.3 % I'm not sure this one is THAT good, but everyone seems hyped about it.

Deathwing, Dragonlord 36.6% For me it's not good, but it's pretty hard to assess this one. 

Blade of C'Thun 40.4% I don't think C'Thun Rogue will be a thing because of the lack of heals, but if the meta is slow, this card is obviously good. 

Steward of Darkshire 41.2 % I think it has the potential to define the new cancer in standard. Hope it's tier 3 :)

C'Thun's Chosen 54.4%

Disciple of C'Thun 56.2% This card will be an auto include in every single C'Thun deck. I call it.

Thing from Below 59.9%

Dark Arakkoa 60.1% The main reason why C'Thun druid would be a thing, with innervate. 

Ancient Shieldbearer 60.8% The main reason why C'Thun warrior would be a thing.

Twilight Darkmender 62.2% The main reason why ... well you got it.

Tier 2- These cards will certainly be played, but in lower tier deck or will have a smaller impact in general

Ragnaros, Lightlord *49.5% This one has almost as much vote in T1 than T3, so i put him here.

Call of the Wild *42.8 % Same thing.

Blood Warriors *35% Again

Mark of Y'Shaarj *38.7 Again, although this one is overrated i think, now that we know beast druid hasn't got much.

 Undercity Huckster 68.5%

Twilight Elder 66.5%

 Darkshire Alchemist 66%

Klaxxi Amber-Weaver 65.5%

Cult Sorcerer 62.5% Will be played even in Non-C'Thun decks i think.

Mire Keeper 62%

Ravaging Ghoul 61.8%

Journey Below 61.5%

Infested Wolf 61.4% Certainly the best 4-drop possible for hunters. The spiders are beast, so a huge set up for Houdmaster, Ram wangler and Princess Huhuran (for the deathrattle effect)

Fiery Bat 57.4% Leper Gnome substitute for hunters.

Selfless Hero 57% I already fear the type of deck this card implies...

Blood To Ichor 56.6% Very solid card that has the potential to be played in a lot of different warriors.

Shadow Strike 55.3% Extremely powerfull rogue spell that will certainly be an auto-include. I would move it to tier 2+.

Princess Huhuran 54.2% Just for the fact it's the first playable hunter lengendary, she deserves a spot in tier 1.

Bloodsail Cultist 53.3%

Hooded Acolyte 52.2% I can already see this card with Wild Pyromancer and Circle of Healing. Scary.

Xaril, Poisoned Mind 50.4%

Cyclopian Horror 50.1% I don't like this card but i can see its value, so why not.

Bloodhoof Brave 48.3% Will be staple in control warrior, maybe grim (if it survives the standard)

Beckoner of Evil 47%

Bladed Cultist 44.9% I don't see why it's good honestly.

Shatter  44.1% I rather see it as a tier 3 card.

N'Zoth's First Mate / Hammer of Twilight 44%

A Light in the Darkness 43.5% Not really impressed...

Cho'gall 39.9%

Tier 3+ Good but niche cards. Will maybe be played in very specific decks.

Embrace the Shadow 36.8%

Forbidden Shaping 38.4%

Forbidden Ritual 39.1%

Vilefin Inquisitor 39.2% I think the votes are mostly for the art... Because it's only good in aggro murloc, which is bad.

Twilight Geomancer 39.5%

Blackwater Pirate 41.8%

Psych-o-Tron 42.6%

Feral Rage 42.7% I think it's beter than it seems... the versatility is very good.

Forbidden Ancient 43.7%

Darkshire Councilman 46.2%

Malkorok 46.6% I think this is seriously underrated. Should be at least tier 2-

Forbidden Healing 46.8%

Stormcrack 48.1%

Twilight Summoner / Infest 48.2%

Southsea Squidface 48.3%

Possessed Villager 49.5% I would play it just for the art.

Bilefin Tidehunter 49.8%

Addled Grizzly 50%

Crazed Worshipper 50.3%

Forlorn Stalker 50.4% I think it has potential thanks to Infested Wolf.

Twisted Worgen 50.7% I'm really surprised, expecting it way lower.

Twilight Flamecaller 50.9%

Usher of Souls 51.7%

Cabalist's Tome 52.5% I think everyone underrated this card before the stream. Might be tier 2.

Rallying Blade 52.9% Might be really good.

Hogger, Doom of Elwynn 58.1%

Tentacle of N'Zoth 59.7%

Bog Creeper 60.2%

Tier 3- Balanced cards, but will certainly be too weak for constructed. Might see play in fun decks.

Squirming Tentacle 61.3% Little brother of Evil Heckler in the Powercreep familly (R.I.P. Silverback Patriarch)

Skeram Cultist 59.4% Seems to be the worst cultist.

Nerubian Prophet 54.5% I can see it played in Evolve Shaman.

On the Hunt 51.6%

Cult Apothecary 50.3% I can only see it played in Warlock with Shadowflame.

Midnight Drake 49.6%

Primal Fusion 48.8%

Zealous Initiate 48.2%

Mukla, Tyrant of the Vale 47.6% I think it's better than it seems. Might see play in rogue or Mage (Yogg ?)

Faceless Shambler 47%

Soggoth the Slitherer 46.5%

Scaled Nightmare 45.4%

Y'Shaarj, Rage Unbound / Spreading Madness 44% Seeing the mighty old gold at the same spot of this card makes me sad.

Herald Volazj 42.7% A bad Priest legendary... what a surprise !

Giant Sand Worm 42.6% Control Hunter.... I have faith in you this time...

Divine Strength 42.3% Migth be good in eboladin...          ... don't even try !

Spawn of N'Zoth 42%

Carrion Grub 40.9% I actually think it is playable in midrange hunter in a fast meta. Perfect Houndmaster Target.

Ancient Harbinger 40.5%

Thistle Tea 40.4%

Corrupted Healbot 39.6%

Demented Frostcaller 36.7% It has the potential to be insane. I will definitly try it.

Anomalus 35.9%

Tier 4+ Bad cards, but could be played in fun decks, or are just boring vanilla minions for arena.

Blood of The Ancient One 35% Actually, its effect is nearly a downside... this card is total crap, it won't even be fun to play.

Forbidden Flame 35.1% On the other hand, i find this one very underrated. Could find a place in a value/Yogg mage.

Servant of Yogg-Saron 40% A pure fun card.

Eldritch Horror 45.4%

Stand Against Darkness 45.8% Could maybe be played with Steward of Darkshire, but i doubt it will be worth.

Shadow Word: Horror 47% If the meta is super aggro, this might see some play. Right now it sucks.

 Polluted Hoarder 52.8% I will play this card in my N'Zoth Hunter. Challenge accepted.

Corrupted Seer *35.5% This guy has even stats between Tier 3, 4 and 5 so i put him here.

Aberrant Berserker * 35% Same

Tier 4- Bad cards. Will not see play at all, except for some troll decks.

Infested Tauren 51.5% This goes into my N'Zoth Hunter too. And yes, I will reach legend with it.

Power Word: Tentacles 49.7% This will only be played in trolls decks with every single card with tentacles in the game. Damn, i want to do it now...

Darkshire Librarian 47.1% No, Blizzard... Fist of Jaraxxus will never be a thing, sorry.

Faceless Behemoth 42% The Old God of the poors.

Evolved Kobold 40.2% I don't even have a funny thing to say... I don't see one spell that would justify these stats *Keeper of the Grove cries in a corner*

Validated Doomsayer 39.7% You want to make me believe it's playable after printing Flamewreathed Faceless ?!?

Grotesque Dragonhawk 38.7% Because everyone knows +4/+4 on an already shit minion is worth 6 mana.

DOOM! 35.9% Why playing Twisting Nether when you can play the same card for 2 more mana and a downside ? 

Tier 5 These are the cards you will get from your Old Gods packs.

Duskboar 39.8% Magma Rager is nearly jealous....

Wisps of the Old Gods 45.7% I guess 5 wisps wasn't enough, that's why dark wispers was never played. Filling your board is far better.

Nat, the Darkfisher 54.6% One day, this card will mill your C'Thun. It needs to exist for that precise reason. 

Tentacles for Arms 62.5% A redditor said he would give 10.000$ to charity if this card would see competitive play. You know, a tier list, it's kinda personal... a tier 5 card is not necesserally THAT bad...

The Boogeymonster 77% Every expansion has its Hemet. It's to make sure than when YOU open a pack, you get this while your friends are getting N'Zoth the Corruptor.

Unranked cards.

Some card are unranked due to a too large fluctuation in the votes.

Yogg-Saron, Hope's End For obvious reasons.

Shifter Zerus Very Unique, need to see in game.

Renounce Darkness Impossible to know how strong it will be.

Darkspeaker The poll is broken, i don't have the stats. If it was me, i would rate it tier 3- (potentialy good in evolve Shaman)

Interesting facts

• To the surprise of few, C'Thun is the best card of the set, while The Boogeymonster is the worst.
• The best class legendary is Fandral Staghelm while the worst is Anomalus. They are all at least tier 3 (Playable)
• There are 88 playable cards (tier 1, 2 and 3+) out of 137, and 4 undecided.
• Shaman is the Winner. 3 cards in tier 1 (only one with druid), and every card at least Tier 3
• Warlock is the Looser. Every card tier 3 or below, and the only Tier 2  (Cho'gall) is at the very end of the list.
• Every cultist is at least T3+ (except Skeram Cultist but no one cares). This really seems a viable archetype.
• 4.5% of Hearthpwn users voted The Boogeymonster as a Meta-defining card.

Nice list bro!

I truly think Twin Emperor Vek'lor is the most broken card of the expansion. A total of 20 stats for 7 mana is ridiculous. And just wait to face a C'Thun evolve Shaman to play this into evolve resulting a Tirion + a Ragnaros.

Squirming Tentacle isn't true powercreep like Evil Heckler is over Booty Bay Bodyguard, because Silverback Patriarch has Beast tag.

e.g. Silverback into Mark of Y'Shaarj = 5 mana Fen Creeper + 0 mana draw

You did an insane amount of work for that list. Thanks bro!

Well, there are always arguments about powercreep (Booty Bay is better with joust! wow!), but in general it will always be stricly better. And honestly, i don't care about powercreep, that was just for the joke ^^

C'thun is so overrated I can't wait to crush those decks with aggro/midrange decks just the fact you play low value minions for like 5 turns means you will always be behind on board.

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

C'thun is so overrated I can't wait to crush those decks with aggro/midrange decks just the fact you play low value minions for like 5 turns means you will always be behind on board.

Nice list. would rate. Conclusive evidence that Warlock has failed and Shaman is the winner of WoG.

Quote from Agithore_the_Corrupted >>

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

C'thun is so overrated I can't wait to crush those decks with aggro/midrange decks just the fact you play low value minions for like 5 turns means you will always be behind on board.

 How are cards like Beckoner of Evil, Twilight Elder or Disciple of C'Thun or even C'Thun's Chosen low value?

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

C'thun is so overrated I can't wait to crush those decks with aggro/midrange decks just the fact you play low value minions for like 5 turns means you will always be behind on board.

Quote from Jolman42 >>

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

C'thun is so overrated I can't wait to crush those decks with aggro/midrange decks just the fact you play low value minions for like 5 turns means you will always be behind on board.

 Well, I think that the Twins emperor and some class cultist are enough to make C'Thun viable. I don't even imagine the tempo swing of this new dr 7 dropped on turn 7.

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

Quote from Jolman42 >>

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

C'thun is so overrated I can't wait to crush those decks with aggro/midrange decks just the fact you play low value minions for like 5 turns means you will always be behind on board.

 Well, I think that the Twins emperor and some class cultist are enough to make C'Thun viable. I don't even imagine the tempo swing of this new dr 7 dropped on turn 7.

 yeah Bog crepeer trades with your "dr 7" perfectly. and hogger too.

Quote from Jolman42 >>

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

Quote from Jolman42 >>

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

C'thun is so overrated I can't wait to crush those decks with aggro/midrange decks just the fact you play low value minions for like 5 turns means you will always be behind on board.

 Well, I think that the Twins emperor and some class cultist are enough to make C'Thun viable. I don't even imagine the tempo swing of this new dr 7 dropped on turn 7.

 yeah Bog crepeer trades with your "dr 7" perfectly. and hogger too.

But would you really play these cards in an aggro/midrange decks ? I doubt so ^^ 

Quote from penguinj2 >>

I'm a little confused with duskboar being tier 5. This could be very good in a beast hunter that runs tundra rhino, I would give it tier 4+ at least.

Wow, really nice work here, can't believe Am'gam Rager is not above C'Thun but oh well

Quote from Jolman42 >>

Well, there are always arguments about powercreep (Booty Bay is better with joust! wow!), but in general it will always be stricly better. And honestly, i don't care about powercreep, that was just for the joke ^^

Quote from Jolman42 >>

 

 

Tier 1  These cards will define the Meta

C'Thun 77.1% Really overrated will spawn a few decks, won't be very successful as people think they will be

 

Doomcaller 54.1% Very surprised about this one. I think it is overhyped., I think the same, overrated as hell plus is a card in an overrated archtype overateception.

Fandral Staghelm 52.8% A bit overhyped i think. Will not likely stay on the board, and combo it right away is good but not OP. I think this card is really strong and you can just put it in any deck that has manay choose one effects

Tier 2+ These cards will see competitive play in several decks.

Twin Emperor Vek'lor *45.2% This card should definitly be tier 1. If C'thun becomes viable, this card is simply OP

Overrated not OP as people think it's a high value card inseed but bigger minions like ragnaros or just a 7/7 trades evenly with the card it's definetly not dr. boom level.

Flamewreathed Faceless *44.1% This card is broken in arena, and will see play in constructed due to the BGH nerf.

one of the cards that kills your emperors for example

Shadowcaster *47.3 % I'm not sure this one is THAT good, but everyone seems hyped about it.

it has potential to be absolutely broken.

---

Deathwing, Dragonlord 36.6% For me it's not good, but it's pretty hard to assess this one. 

overrated

Blade of C'Thun 40.4% I don't think C'Thun Rogue will be a thing because of the lack of heals, but if the meta is slow, this card is obviously good. 

The effect is kinda ok.. but it's way too slow too fair.

Steward of Darkshire 41.2 % I think it has the potential to define the new cancer in standard. Hope it's tier 3 :)

hope it's tier 1, probably will be too, it's the best paladin card in the expansion and paladin don't have many 3 drops in general and there is no Muster for Battletoo

C'Thun's Chosen 54.4%

One of the better cultist, but I think this is one of few who are good.. in a token meta the stats aren't that good since he dies to a token + a 1 drop. definetly not shredder level

Disciple of C'Thun 56.2% This card will be an auto include in every single C'Thun deck. I call it.

Best neutral C'thun cultist but seems like the other neutrals are kinda lame.

Dark Arakkoa 60.1% The main reason why C'Thun druid would be a thing, with innervate. 

Good cultist trades well with other popular 6 drops, main reason to run druid C'thun deck.

 

Tier 2- These cards will certainly be played, but in lower tier deck or will have a smaller impact in general

Ragnaros, Lightlord *49.5% This one has almost as much vote in T1 than T3, so i put him here.

deserves tier 1

Call of the Wild *42.8 % Same thing.

deserves tier 1

Blood Warriors *35% Again

This isn't as strong as people think it's really situational and it's a win more effect.

Mark of Y'Shaarj *38.7 Again, although this one is overrated i think, now that we know beast druid hasn't got much.

I think it's underrated look at BRM,TGT and LOE you will find really good beasts to put in your beast druid deck.

---

Twilight Elder 66.5%

Spider Tank,Spider Tank does whatever Spider Tank does.

 Klaxxi Amber-Weaver 65.5%

most of the time you won't be able to play a 4/10 at turn 4 unless you had exactly 2 early minions with +2/+2.. off curve it's less impressive.

Cult Sorcerer 62.5% Will be played even in Non-C'Thun decks i think.

This is a +1 attack Kobold Geomancer is this good enough? I guess since you miss out of mad scientist you want to run another powerful 2 drop the choice is between this and Fallen Hero

Ravaging Ghoul 61.8%

The card is REALLY good since the aggro decks will still have a lot of tokens and patron warrior seems to survive still.

Journey Below 61.5%

discover cards are really powerful it's 1 mana less museum curator but it's a 1 mana spell.. on rogue.. COMBO ENABLER + a strong effect.. underhyped, besides deathrattle rogue will really like this card.

Selfless Hero 57% I already fear the type of deck this card implies...

What's wrong with aggro? much more interesting than C'thun decks for sure.

Bloodsail Cultist 53.3%

Just for having the pirate tag without penality it's already powerful the effect is really strong aswell.

Hooded Acolyte 52.2% I can already see this card with Wild Pyromancer and Circle of Healing. Scary.

it's not scary lol. cleric is much more scary than this it's a vanilla 3/6 till you play C'thun.

Xaril, Poisoned Mind 50.4%

Hard to estimate ATM but are the toxins that strong that you pay 2 mana for this effect? dunno.

Beckoner of Evil 47%

River CrocoliskCard Name

N'Zoth's First Mate / Hammer of Twilight 44% 

Both powerful and impactful cards underhyped

 

Tier 3+ Good but niche cards. Will maybe be played in very specific decks.

Forbidden Shaping 38.4%

Forbidden Ritual 39.1%

Underhyped card this is effect is really strong specially since implosion dissapoints sometimes this isn't an rng effect.. zoo likes this a lot.

Vilefin Inquisitor 39.2% I think the votes are mostly for the art... Because it's only good in aggro murloc, which is bad.

Actually the change in hero power doesn't make it more aggressive only more synergistist-> value->midrange.

Twilight Geomancer 39.5%

How good is a 1/4 taunt for 2 though? might see play if you want additional early game taunts in your deck, if face hunter is popular this is a spedd bumb for them.

Darkshire Councilman 46.2%

underhyped, zoo card can snowball pretty hard for a 3 drop.

Southsea Squidface 48.3%

good effect, pirate deathrattle underrated.

Possessed Villager 49.5% I would play it just for the art.

Better than argent squire in zoo. deserves better than this.

Bilefin Tidehunter 49.8%

cheap 1/1 taunt + a 2/1 body I think it's better than it seems.

Twisted Worgen 50.7% I'm really surprised, expecting it way lower.

Aggro card.. yes aggro exists.

Cabalist's Tome 52.5% I think everyone underrated this card before the stream. Might be tier 2.

The stream decks aren't refined, as seen in emperor thaurisan 5 turns on board, -frodan couldn't remove, enemy didn't win immediattely.

Hogger, Doom of Elwynn 58.1%

One of the 2 good neutral 7 drops in the expansion, best in patron warrior, on other decks it's ok, underrated card.

Bog Creeper 60.2%

One of the 2 good neutral 7 drops in the expansion, will surprise some players who just see C'thun, or minions with cool effects as viable, but this taunt is quite good. some classes currently don't have any turn 7 paly this can fill the void.

Tier 3- Balanced cards, but will certainly be too weak for constructed. Might see play in fun decks.

On the Hunt 51.6%

the 1/1 is a beast which matters a lot. specially as new beast cards are revealed... webspinner replacement.

Giant Sand Worm 42.6% Control Hunter.... I have faith in you this time...

I don't, this card is super slow.

Divine Strength 42.3% Migth be good in eboladin...          ... don't even try !

Again this fear of aggro.. sigh.. also good in midrange for favorable trades. silence got nerfed, so this is better than it seems.

Tier 4+ Bad cards, but could be played in fun decks, or are just boring vanilla minions for arena.

Corrupted Seer *35.5% This guy has even stats between Tier 3, 4 and 5 so i put him here.

Tier 4- Bad cards. Will not see play at all, except for some troll decks.

Darkshire Librarian 47.1% No, Blizzard... Fist of Jaraxxus will never be a thing, sorry.

never? nah if some broken effects work with the discard mechanic it's quite good.. do you know yu-gi-oh?t here is that dark world archtype.. I don't know if it's strong in there but I think it's quite effective, the point is.. that with enough support the archtype will be good.. we need a minion that when it'ss discarded it's summoned instead.

Faceless Behemoth 42% The Old God of the poors.

affects RNG effects in a good way Evolve buff

Evolved Kobold 40.2% I don't even have a funny thing to say... I don't see one spell that would justify these stats *Keeper of the Grove cries in a corner*

if it was any better OTK decks could be insane, this is meant for a burst combo or a big AOE turn.

Grotesque Dragonhawk 38.7% Because everyone knows +4/+4 on an already shit minion is worth 6 mana.

OTK warrior

Tier 5 These are the cards you will get from your Old Gods packs.

The Boogeymonster 77% Every expansion has its Hemet. It's to make sure than when YOU open a pack, you get this while your friends are getting N'Zoth the Corruptor.

feelsbadman

Unranked cards.

Some card are unranked due to a too large fluctuation in the votes.

Yogg-Saron, Hope's End For obvious reasons.

If you are looking for a crazy card this is the best for you, it's also probably gonna draw you cards, play a ton of secrets and clear the enemy board, or both boards.. can also kill you, but mostly won't.

could se competitive play actually.

 

Interesting facts

• To the surprise of few, C'Thun is the best card of the set, while The Boogeymonster is the worst. (this is the community opinion)
• There are 88 playable cards (tier 1, 2 and 3+) out of 137, and 4 undecided. I don't get it.. the set contains 134 cards
• Warlock is the Looser. Every card tier 3 or below, and the only Tier 2 Warlock will be fine, you will see. 
• Every cultist is at least T3+ (except Skeram Cultist but no one cares). This really seems a viable archetype. it's the community opinion!
• 4.5% of Hearthpwn users voted The Boogeymonster as a Meta-defining card. Those who did are the high legend players

 

 

 

 

Selfless Hero 57% I already fear the type of deck this card implies...

What's wrong with aggro? much more interesting than C'thun decks for sure.

I don't fear aggro, i just hate divine favor decks - which this card implies. Aggro paladin is by far one of the most annoying deck to play agaisnt as a control deck.

 

Hooded Acolyte 52.2% I can already see this card with Wild Pyromancer and Circle of Healing. Scary.

it's not scary lol. cleric is much more scary than this it's a vanilla 3/6 till you play C'thun.

It's not scary value or power-wise, but i already imagine this combo with the C'Thun gradually growing with his little animation, and that's kinda scary (fun remark of course, i don't even think C'Thun priest would be that great)

Vilefin Inquisitor 39.2% I think the votes are mostly for the art... Because it's only good in aggro murloc, which is bad.

Actually the change in hero power doesn't make it more aggressive only more synergistist-> value->midrange.

Yep, i agree, didn't think of it that way. I don't think its is really worth the spot tho, as a midrange murloc deck isn't that great since you loose Murk-Eye (in standard)

Twisted Worgen 50.7% I'm really surprised, expecting it way lower.

Aggro card.. yes aggro exists.

Even in aggro i think it's bad. I dont want to play 1 more mana on a worgen inflitrator jsut for 1 attack.

Cabalist's Tome 52.5% I think everyone underrated this card before the stream. Might be tier 2.

The stream decks aren't refined, as seen in emperor thaurisan 5 turns on board, -frodan couldn't remove, enemy didn't win immediattely.

Sure, but we still saw that this card provide great value. I'm sure this card will be played in Value mage, if it exists.

 

Giant Sand Worm 42.6% Control Hunter.... I have faith in you this time...

I don't, this card is super slow.

I don't have faith thanks to this card, i just hope it will viable this time (bad choice of word in the OP)

Divine Strength 42.3% Migth be good in eboladin...          ... don't even try !

Again this fear of aggro.. sigh.. also good in midrange for favorable trades. silence got nerfed, so this is better than it seems

I just hate eboladin, like I said with the sefless hero. Everyone has a most hated deck ^^

 

Darkshire Librarian 47.1% No, Blizzard... Fist of Jaraxxus will never be a thing, sorry.

never? nah if some broken effects work with the discard mechanic it's quite good.. do you know yu-gi-oh?t here is that dark world archtype.. I don't know if it's strong in there but I think it's quite effective, the point is.. that with enough support the archtype will be good.. we need a minion that when it'ss discarded it's summoned instead.

Of course this might work, some example showed it (paladin secrets were considered trash before TGT), that was just a joke.

Faceless Behemoth 42% The Old God of the poors.

affects RNG effects in a good way Evolve buff

Yep, I also think they made this card to give a cheap 10 mana option if a new player get Ancient Harbringer from a pack.

 

Grotesque Dragonhawk 38.7% Because everyone knows +4/+4 on an already shit minion is worth 6 mana.

OTK warrior

I thought of it, just for the joke. But i feel Raging Worgen is still better in an otk warrior, you just loose 1 attack for a 4 mana benefit.

 

 

Interesting facts

• To the surprise of few, C'Thun is the best card of the set, while The Boogeymonster is the worst. (this is the community opinion)  And it's a community tier list, so it's true :)
• There are 88 playable cards (tier 1, 2 and 3+) out of 137, and 4 undecided. I don't get it.. the set contains 134 cards         My bad on this point
• Warlock is the Looser. Every card tier 3 or below, and the only Tier 2 Warlock will be fine, you will see.                                     I know, but in term of strict card quality, according to the community it's the looser. I rather think the loosers are rogue and priest.

 

 I put my opinion on all the ratings/cards my comments are in bold .

I also erased the things I agree with or don't care enough to comment about.

amgar rager? what trickery is this? why can this card define meta? it can define the dust meta though.