Hi, just my 2c on a couple of druid cards: Is Goru the Mightree really Tier 1, with Token/Treant Druid being outclassed by Spell Druid? Also Untapped Potential is probably no longer Tier 2, Quest Druid doesn't see play any more since losing Wardruid Loti and Flobbidinous Floop Oh and the Priest Galakrond seems to have quite some success lately, maybe deserves an upgrade from Tier 4?
yeah I never saw Goru the Mightree after the outland it is tier two card at best only fits to certain archetype it was never tier one card anyway.
Untapped Potential is also like Goru the Mightree it requires certain archetype to work so in order to make it work team 5 supposed to print cards for it.
I think Both Druid cards belongs to tier 3 they can go up to tier 2 if they get support
As I said before Akama is not tier 1 but it is not either tier 4 it is in between tier 2 and tier 3 because it has good stats it doesn't have many drawbacks.
Akama is a good card to fill 3 drop slot but not necessary I would place it to tier 2.
Shadowjeweler Hanar is easily tier 1 lol and it is extremely annoying for opponent especially when you chose secrets to protect hanar.
Astromancer Solarian tier 1 it is solid drop for mage except spell mage archetype.
Evocation This is solid tier two the reason is too much rng it sometimes doesn't generate the answer you seek also useless at early game. You can see that in the winrates most people use this too seek answer but doesn't give one. but it doesn't mean very bad card it is still usefull sometimes.
Natalie Seline This is worst than flick I don't play priest but this comes to my hand too often 8 mana is a little bit expensive for a removal and most of the time hp gain will just provide regular stats like 8 mana 8/8, 8/7 etc. if this would be taunt it would be solid tier one tho
I didn't play the rest yet. I don't have opinion on them
All expected tiers in! It is a ongoing debate how quickly it is safe to put them into their permanent tiers. Feedback appreciated!
bandermosh and shuma tier 1-2 ?? is there something good about them that I don't know about ? Also why waxedred is tier 4-5 it is used in somedecks spreads like plague.
Baku the Mooneater Definetally have much more interaction with lots of class and strongest deck uses odd archetype now
Lord Godfrey even cubelock get nerf this card will be a solid option for every slow warlock deck
Countess Ashmore Currently it doesn't see too much game but she has a really powerful ability she has 2 years to work
Beside those Trio There are cards which will see play so often
Genn Greymane- with even cards this provides good curve but it doesn't support too much class.
Tess Greymane- Definetally a good card it is not less than N'zoth or Yog it has great potential but requires more support not like cards that consumes too much mana such as Pick Pocket.
Chameleos- This card can be played in every slow Priest deck.
Prince Liam It doesn't support every deck obviously but when you play this you get rid of unwanted one drops from your deck at late game but this card is not some card to build deck around it must occur naturally.
Rest are questionable crafts for me they can work in very specific deck in very specific meta so until they became necessary I would not craft any of them.
Lots of updates to the guide. The nerfs have quite an inpact, and the complicated part is working out which cards are GAINING from the nerfs (the Warlock cards were in high tiers already.)
Why did you put Kazakus same tier with Edwin? Deck has lower winrate but Edwin is staple in Miracle rogue. At the other hand there is no current deck archetype to benefit from Kazakus. I think Kazakus is tier 3. Ofc in standart
So i've been playing hearthstone just a few weeks ago... And i've been wondering what cards i can disenchant. Can anyone help me? :)
As a f2p player I eliminated 2 classes after I catch up with all other classes I will start to build them again. right now 4 of the remaining 7 classes are complete I can build any deck with them 2 out of 3 is about to be completed only Druid is missing many important cards.
I think most of the tier 1 cards actually not really tier one tho this list have a good make up for starters.
Currently there is only one tier 1 class card at standart classic and it is Edwin
Prophet Velen, Antonidas and Jaraxxus is used for very stational decks but Edwin fits nearly all rogue decks.
Also I think Cairne or Leeroy is not tier one especially the Cairne
Edwin, Patches, Keleseth are huge power up for deck.
Please read the disclaimer in the op. If you "think" a card is not worth a tier 1 spot, get some statistics or decklists to support your claim, and we might change it! Cairne Bloodhoof is tier 1 because his win- and playrates are good, and he is a classic neutral, and thus a safe craft. Archmage Antonidas and not tier 1...
Those statistics doesn't indicate how good card is bro they are barely show us the success of the decks which those cards are included.in order to decide which cards are tier one with statistics some randomly collected data is not enough, you need hundreds of experiments to decide that.
But if you think you can clearly see priority between a tier one card such as Keleseth to the cairne or leeroy.
yeah I never saw Goru the Mightree after the outland it is tier two card at best only fits to certain archetype it was never
yeah I never saw Goru the Mightree after the outland it is tier two card at best only fits to certain archetype it was never tier one card anyway.
Untapped Potential is also like Goru the Mightree it requires certain archetype to work so in order to make it work team 5 supposed to print cards for it.
I think Both Druid cards belongs to tier 3 they can go up to tier 2 if they get support
As I said before Akama is not tier 1 but it is not either tier 4 it is in between tier 2 and tier 3 because it has good stats it doesn't have many drawbacks.
Akama is a good card to fill 3 drop slot but not necessary I would place it to tier 2.
Shadowjeweler Hanar is easily tier 1 lol and it is extremely annoying for opponent especially when you chose secrets to protect hanar.
Astromancer Solarian tier 1 it is solid drop for mage except spell mage archetype.
Evocation This is solid tier two the reason is too much rng it sometimes doesn't generate the answer you seek also useless at early game. You can see that in the winrates most people use this too seek answer but doesn't give one. but it doesn't mean very bad card it is still usefull sometimes.
Natalie Seline This is worst than flick I don't play priest but this comes to my hand too often 8 mana is a little bit expensive for a removal and most of the time hp gain will just provide regular stats like 8 mana 8/8, 8/7 etc. if this would be taunt it would be solid tier one tho
I didn't play the rest yet. I don't have opinion on them
bandermosh and shuma tier 1-2 ?? is there something good about them that I don't know about ? Also why waxedred is tier 4-5 it is used in somedecks spreads like plague.
Don't fkn dust Jaraxxus.
This is the first time I completely satisfied with crafting tier list Well done SlydE
For me the solid crafts are
Baku the Mooneater Definetally have much more interaction with lots of class and strongest deck uses odd archetype now
Lord Godfrey even cubelock get nerf this card will be a solid option for every slow warlock deck
Countess Ashmore Currently it doesn't see too much game but she has a really powerful ability she has 2 years to work
Beside those Trio There are cards which will see play so often
Genn Greymane- with even cards this provides good curve but it doesn't support too much class.
Tess Greymane- Definetally a good card it is not less than N'zoth or Yog it has great potential but requires more support not like cards that consumes too much mana such as Pick Pocket.
Chameleos- This card can be played in every slow Priest deck.
Prince Liam It doesn't support every deck obviously but when you play this you get rid of unwanted one drops from your deck at late game but this card is not some card to build deck around it must occur naturally.
Rest are questionable crafts for me they can work in very specific deck in very specific meta so until they became necessary I would not craft any of them.
I think most of the tier 1 cards actually not really tier one tho this list have a good make up for starters.
Currently there is only one tier 1 class card at standart classic and it is Edwin
Prophet Velen, Antonidas and Jaraxxus is used for very stational decks but Edwin fits nearly all rogue decks.
Also I think Cairne or Leeroy is not tier one especially the Cairne
Edwin, Patches, Keleseth are huge power up for deck.