Witchwood Weave is an interesting card, but I think it lacks general synergy; there might be a case where you want the heal rather than the damage even in an all odd-cost deck. Perhaps you could make it a Choose One card to resolve this?
Witch Fire is simple but nice. I think it would be beneficial to reword it as "deal 6 damage" rather than "deal 3 more damage" since that's not the standard wording in Hearthstone. Other than that, it's fine! Huzzah for fireballs in odd-cost decks!
Orderly Lorekeeper is my favorite of the bunch! It's a strong, interesting design.
If you want to, could you please review my cards? :3
The Dividing Conquerors is really strong, but I think it works if you keep it as a Battlecry. Making this a Shaman-only card does it a lot of good, and there's even synergy with Hagatha the Witch! Overall, it seems balanced, and I quite enjoy the idea!
Even the Odds is a fun card, but I don't think it'll be particularly useful. It's cheap but only really gets value if you're blessed by RNGesus. I think Even the Odds has an interesting design and it would definitely see play, but I still prefer The Dividing Conquerors.
Baku's Lunatic is solid but almost feels like powercreep on Blackwald Pixie. It's balanced perfectly for its effect and stats, but I'm not as intrigued by it as your other cards.
I can review them once again, if you wish, but I feel that I won't evaluate them correctly. So, you know, keep bumping.
1) 2) If you remember my old post, I told you there, that people will most likely prefer the mage spell over the others. The flavour is great, it feels like a Renounce Darkness and you could potentially replace your spells with stronger even-Cost ones in your odd deck, but I'm sticking with the dragon.
3) Fencing Coach + Blackwald Pixie. The design is nice, the card is fair, but I'm not really excited about it. I imagine how you make a control DK gul'dan deck (and I don't mean a Baku one), you can always play the Clockwork Automaton + HP for 6 damage and 12 health, play the lunatic (if you drew all even cost cards from your deck) and inflict 6 damage more. This is a 10 mana 2 card combo, which can bring you a lot of health, but the 12 damage burst isn't impressive. So your card will be out-shined by more impactful ones.
Keep bumping your post, in order to hear out other's opinions. I'm just passing by:
To Battle! at 10 mana seems reasonable, but the current effect is still pretty strong imho. It's an unhealthy mix of Sprint and Varian Wrynn. I can seriously imagine a Spiteful deck just because of this spell (and Dinosize). Dunno, I like the flavour, but I'm fearing its power.
[edit] And if it wasn't clear enough - Grand Archivist would be bonkers there.
About the dwarf - I think, that I'm kinda having mixed thoughts just because of the dudes. Can you change the "odd-Cost" part to an "even-Cost"? If you do this, then the first version will be the one I would chose - not because of the obvious even synergy, but because how this card could be used in aggro decks as well, as a cheap taunt (a neutral Druid of the Swarm with 1 more Attack and w/o the tag), which protects your minions in mirror matches.
Thanks for feedback! I shall submit this one by modified.
The first one replaces Wrath if you aren't allowed to have even-Cost cards, but is not completely useless otherwise (like if you get it randomly). The second one is a replacement for Fireball in odd Mage decks. Note that it's two separate damage sources. Although the two 3 damage pings will hit the same target, they will hit separately and sequentially. This means it will trigger on-damage effects twice, but can also one-shot Divine Shield minions. Is it a little too powerful? I can make it only target minions if so. The last one is meant to slightly alleviate restrictions for odd Mage. You can't get even minions, but it can still help. It's also good if you want to discover a spell, but don't want a Secret. Is this even allowed, though? I could always change it to only trigger if you only have odd-Cost cards.
Witchwood Weave: It's a nice, flexible card that helps Odd Druid but it's outshadowed by Lesser Jasper Spellstone, so it's kinda pointless. The healing is a bit weaker than Flash Heal and a bit weaker than Barkskin, so I don't see that being of use either...I like the alliteration tho. :P
Witch Fire: That seems a bit too potent and bursty in terms of damage. Granted that Odd Mage really lacks direct damage spells (in Standard), so it might help it there, but the effect seems too frightening for my taste. Limiting it to minions would help.
Orderly Storekeeper: I really like this one. Because there's LOTS of good Mage spells (e.g. Polymorph, Frostbolt, Fireball, Meteor, Primordial Glyph, Blizzard, Pyroblast) this will be certainly useful in Odd Mage, which lacks those vital spells. It also curves nicely next turn with an Even number of Mana Crystals. I think you should go with this one, but you should probably buff this to a 3/2 or 2/3 because Ethereal Conjuerer loses 2 stat points from the vanilla 5 mana body (5/6), so this should lose 2 stat points too.
If you want to, could you please review my cards? :3
I'm not really a fan of the dragon. It's both really powerful, and it would also disrupt the the even-Cost mechanic by turning even-Cost cards into odd-Cost ones.
I like Even the Odds a lot. Mainly because it's a pun, but also it's a good Mage vibe along the lines of Cabalist's Tome. It seems a little underpowered, though. You probably won't have a lot of targets for this at any one time. Maybe you could combo it with something that adds a bunch of odd-Cost tokens to your hand or something? Not sure how to buff it, but I feel like it needs one.
I'm also not a big fan of Baku's Lunatic. Maybe if it just gave you one free use of your Hero Power, but making it 0 for the whole turn seems too powerful for a non-Legendary. Especially as a neutral card, it's the kind of thing that would limit design space.
it would also disrupt the the even-Cost mechanic by turning even-Cost cards into odd-Cost ones.
Mhm, sometimes I hate Blizzard's inconsistent logic when designing cards. Skulking Geist doesn't destroy spells in your hand, if they got a mana reduction. But Oaken Summons interacts with high-Cost minions, that got the Barnabus the Stomper's mana reduction, how Prince Keleseth buffs the minions in your deck and, when you recruit one of them, you get the buffed stats, but this doesn't apply to Varian Wrynn and The Mistcaller*.
So there is a question - How will the coding function in Cogito's card?
Note*
Inb4 does anyone know, if this has been changed? There was so many interactions and patches since I started playing, so I can't follow old ones anymore.
I haven't been on here actively Oddly enough...and Even then...eh, haven't done this in a while, but I'mma try this again cause why not? My skills are a bit rusty, so these cards are probably too OP or weak. >.< Either way, your thoughts?
Your ideas are always great. I like the shaman dragon, but maybe restrict to either minions or spells otherwise its too OP. PS you're not a moderator anymore?
Hey, I'm not sure anybody saw my post asking for a review, but here's my card idea again. I've already submitted it to the Submission Topic but I want to make sure its balanced.
If you want to, could you please review my cards? :3
The Dividing Conquerors is really strong, but I think it works if you keep it as a Battlecry. Making this a Shaman-only card does it a lot of good, and there's even synergy with Hagatha the Witch! Overall, it seems balanced, and I quite enjoy the idea!
Even the Odds is a fun card, but I don't think it'll be particularly useful. It's cheap but only really gets value if you're blessed by RNGesus. I think Even the Odds has an interesting design and it would definitely see play, but I still prefer The Dividing Conquerors.
Baku's Lunatic is solid but almost feels like powercreep on Blackwald Pixie. It's balanced perfectly for its effect and stats, but I'm not as intrigued by it as your other cards.
Thanks for the feedback!
Ivar Bloodfang is a nice and simple card with great Worgen flavour and utilization of Rush and Windfury, with the latter keyword being barely used (almost as scarce as Enrage). so it's nice to see it being used. However, it doesn't seem like Legendary material. I think it can just as easily be on a Rare card.
I haven't been on here actively Oddly enough...and Even then...eh, haven't done this in a while, but I'mma try this again cause why not? My skills are a bit rusty, so these cards are probably too OP or weak. >.< Either way, your thoughts?
Your ideas are always great. I like the shaman dragon, but maybe restrict to either minions or spells otherwise its too OP. PS you're not a moderator anymore?
Thanks for the feedback and the compliments! <3 I think The Dividing Conquerors is currently balanced because it a) makes your deck odd and b) the only even-Costed Shaman draw card in standard is Ice Fishing (Siltfin Spiritwalker and Ancestral Knowledge are the only ones in Wild), and most of those cards aren't exactly that powerful.
No, I'm not a mod anymore. I quit after some personal stuff happened. :P
I think The Dividing Conquerors is currently balanced because it a) makes your deck odd and b) the only even-Costed Shaman draw card in standard is Ice Fishing (Siltfin Spiritwalker and Ancestral Knowledge are the only ones in Wild), and most of those cards aren't exactly that powerful.
I think you mean, it makes your deck even... okay, I'll single myself out.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click the image to go to my custom Time Traveler class.
Thanks, I was really going for a Worgen style like we'd seen before in the game! I probably should have put it on a rare card, but I just wanted to see Ivar Bloodfang in the game. I appreciate the feedback!
Hey, I'm not sure anybody saw my post asking for a review, but here's my card idea again. I've already submitted it to the Submission Topic but I want to make sure its balanced.
I understand you used MTG art, but Worgens are werewolves/dogs, that is a leonin/cat
Behold, foolish interlopers! I am commanding this mortal to spread the will of the Scourge throughout the interwebs, encouraging you to seek out me, Archlich Kel'Thuzad! Now coming to you as the tenth class of Hearthstone!
I am a finalist in this Class Creation Competition, so if you could give it a look I would be greatly appreciative <3
Witchwood Weave is an interesting card, but I think it lacks general synergy; there might be a case where you want the heal rather than the damage even in an all odd-cost deck. Perhaps you could make it a Choose One card to resolve this?
Witch Fire is simple but nice. I think it would be beneficial to reword it as "deal 6 damage" rather than "deal 3 more damage" since that's not the standard wording in Hearthstone. Other than that, it's fine! Huzzah for fireballs in odd-cost decks!
Orderly Lorekeeper is my favorite of the bunch! It's a strong, interesting design.
www.loganapple.com
www.loganapple.com
I can review them once again, if you wish, but I feel that I won't evaluate them correctly. So, you know, keep bumping.
1) 2) If you remember my old post, I told you there, that people will most likely prefer the mage spell over the others. The flavour is great, it feels like a Renounce Darkness and you could potentially replace your spells with stronger even-Cost ones in your odd deck, but I'm sticking with the dragon.
3) Fencing Coach + Blackwald Pixie. The design is nice, the card is fair, but I'm not really excited about it. I imagine how you make a control DK gul'dan deck (and I don't mean a Baku one), you can always play the Clockwork Automaton + HP for 6 damage and 12 health, play the lunatic (if you drew all even cost cards from your deck) and inflict 6 damage more. This is a 10 mana 2 card combo, which can bring you a lot of health, but the 12 damage burst isn't impressive. So your card will be out-shined by more impactful ones.
In conclusion, I'd go with Even the Odds.
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
Inb4 does anyone know, if this has been changed? There was so many interactions and patches since I started playing, so I can't follow old ones anymore.
keleseth no more
Hey, I'm not sure anybody saw my post asking for a review, but here's my card idea again. I've already submitted it to the Submission Topic but I want to make sure its balanced.
Click the image to go to my custom Time Traveler class.
Thanks, I was really going for a Worgen style like we'd seen before in the game! I probably should have put it on a rare card, but I just wanted to see Ivar Bloodfang in the game. I appreciate the feedback!
www.loganapple.com
Ah ok I understand. I personally look at every card from Wild perspective, lol .... Sorry to read about your "personal stuff"
Forgot to submit my card on time lol rip me >_>
Behold, foolish interlopers! I am commanding this mortal to spread the will of the Scourge throughout the interwebs, encouraging you to seek out me, Archlich Kel'Thuzad! Now coming to you as the tenth class of Hearthstone!
I am a finalist in this Class Creation Competition, so if you could give it a look I would be greatly appreciative <3
Final Poll is now up!
You can find me here! Good luck everyone!