Hearthpwn

Here's an idea I had awhile ago that I think fits:

This can't attack if you have no weapon, which is a pretty significant downside. It's not unplayable in Rogue, because you can always get a weapon with your hero power, but that works out to 1 mana per attack, pretty much. Also, I made this before Rush was a thing. I could maybe change it to that.

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

The main problem I see here is what counts as a "significant" detriment because that can be VERY subjective. I feel like a lot of cards this time around will be eligible or not entirely based on what mods say.

Quote from TheGentleman99 >>

Is the submission thread out yet? I know its been longer than 24 hours but I can't seem to find it. Also, is there a way to be informed whenever a discussion/sub,mission thread goes up?

Quote from Phoenixfeather >>

 

Quote from GameTheory345 >>

Yo mod bois:

 Hey now. Don't go around assuming our genders. Jkjk. Ignore me as I try to pretend I'm edgier than I really am. 

Unlike Linkblade91, I assume a differing stratergy.

1. Make a card a few days before the discussion topic comes out and as soon as the previous winner decides on a prompt
2. Sit around until someone prods me to submit it
3. Submit it
4. Receive 0 upvotes
5. Repeat

Much cheaper AOE than Fan of Knives for Rogue, but without the card draw and requiring a combo .

Quote from thepowrofcheese >>

 

Quote from ffinderous >>

Sorry for reply late! It's killing me that working on Saturday. And thanks for your feedback!

@CheeseETC

Defence Stance is a good way to gain more armor, however I guess weapon for warrior is more important, and this one is kind slow... I don't know how to make a choice between Fifty Shade of Purple and Cannon Fodder, they are both cool ideas with good balanced. Maybe the hunter card is better cause we could use it in a quest deck. The warlock card is a little weak in build, because warlock has so many ways to clear the battle field.

@Kovachut

Thunderstorm is kind of weird which not like a shaman class card. I guess the second part should be '... Overload (1) for each card in your opponent's hand.' Act of Friendship is too complex... though it seems balanced. I like Rock Barrage the most. It gives warrior another way to end the game with a fair cost.

 

And Bump my idea for the last time... I decide to submit the hunter card, but I don't know which version looks better... Should I make it 2 damage? Or make it could choose the enemy minion only? Please help me to make the choice. Thanks again.

 

 

I like the idea of it only targeting enemy minions, to punish them for attacking you. But I'm not sure how an arrow attack translates into damage whenever that minion attacks instead of immediate damage.

Anyway, I'm dropping my Reverse Grip idea and have one more card that I'm likely to submit. It's an arguably better Wanted!, but is that too similar to the existing card?

Quote from thepowrofcheese >>

Here's my card again, now with art. It becomes a copy of the card to the right. If there's no other card next to it, it's a 1 Mana 'do nothing' spell. 

Quote from Vision136 >>

I had a few ideas to start with. Thoughts on any of these? Interesting enough? Flavorful enough? Balanced enough? Tell me what you think.

Here are my ideas so far:

I can't believe you typed out like every 1-Cost spell.

When you attack with this bow equipped, targeting a friendly Dragon will be legal. Doing so will not damage it or you, but will instead give it +2/+2. You will, of course, still lose durability. This card is meant to be versatile in that you can just use it to attack, or you can use it to buff up your Dragons for better trades/longer survivability.

With echo, you can do a variable amount of damage to kill one or more targets and/or use it to up the size of your deck. The wording on adding Ocean Depths to your deck seems inconsistent across the cards McF4rtson made, but I took the wording of this from Saltspring Wand.

Quote from Zukuu >>

 

Quote from nurgling13 >>

 

 Is the Beast Buddy just a Vanilla 2/4 Beast? I think it would make more sense if it was the other way around (i.e., the Beast Buddy summons the Drake Buddy) based on the art. Then it would be like the Dragon is coming to the aid of the cat. The way you have it right now might work better mechanically, though.

 

It really works either way and i agree that the art makes a little more sense the other way, but it needs to be a Dragon for this week's restriction and I feel this "Dragon minion in Hunter that summons a beast" feels unique and more interesting. And yeah, the idea is that the other comes when his friend is attacked.

As for Energy Caster, I think the effect of "attacking your friendly minion" is unnecessary here. It doesn't add any flavor or makes sense mechanical wise, but maybe that can be improved by using a different art / name. You should also rewrite it to "You can attack a friendly Dragon to give it +2/+2 instead." 

Quote from Zukuu >>

Quote from Kovachut >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Thx for the reply. Yeah, I'm not familiar with the lore that much, so it's no surprise that you will constantly see some mistakes from me. I was just trying to find a good art and I was browsing through wiki. Would it be better to just make a name of my own?