Hearthpwn

Quote from ffinderous >>

Two new ideas! Though I've already submited...

Quote from SvagoCorp >>

Finally have something worth submitting. Which do you like the most?

My favorite is the first one, but I think the second one has that meme factor that might gather me some more votes.

Quote from ffinderous >>

Two new ideas! Though I've already submited...

Quote from SvagoCorp >>

Finally have something worth submitting. Which do you like the most?

My favorite is the first one, but I think the second one has that meme factor that might gather me some more votes.

Quote from SilentSecond >>

     Counter to mechanic                 Minion helping mechanic          Delayed Cast this again

Lore and art wise makes sense ;o chromie in heroes of the storm can bring you back to a position. Rarity,stats, tribe and set are the same as the other big dragons ;o.  Effect is in the 4 lines rule, text seems clear(might be shorten), no target issues as it is literally just undoing a previous cast(example defile kills a minion and summons another by hitting something, if it falls on the 50% the summoned minion vanishes, resummons the killed minion and heals everything back, only thing not undone is the card wasted and mana cost ;o).

Wording wise if i put recasted spells or a similar vein it would cause issues with you playing the same spell twice while its intended only to prevent recurssive spells from creating havoc on the timeline ;o! Finally every time its casted again has that 50%, to undo only the one before that not all of them.(Chromie can't teleport that far back because someone blocking her, also  she doesnt know where the effect coming from half the time( aka reference to deaths of chromie scenario)).

It doesn't have an infinite loop, in fact it helps prevent infinit loops ;o! So i just fixed all of your issues >;O at the cost of making your cards maybe  useless >;O!  You might consider the card interacting with "cast this again" premature as only 3 cards have it but if we recall Grand Tournment  most card were unplayable but just before it rotated out, Thanks to Raza the Chained, just took almost 2 years and few months of fun in standart, samething for Aviana Kun combos ;c. Or the whole discard mechanic or dk hunter, they still lack enough support to work. Finally i got the dreadfull point in the end ;o.

 

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from LordofBots >>

I see a lot of creative ideas, hope I've time to review them before they go submission thread. Here is my ideas for this week;

 For the Cursed Shield my initial idea was 3 mana, then I thought it would be too weak, and obviously it requires a divine shield minion to activate again. The only problem would be Deathspeaker requires some update like immune to fatal damage.

For the Spreading Rage I wanted to say hello to Spreading Plague, hope I didn't mess up with Horde Warrior. Why I made it as warrior card? Because it sounds right to me >.< . I know warriors have Brawl, but its kinda cooler for me.

I have 1-2 more card ideas, but before I want to hear your reviews about them ^.^

I really like Spreading Rage's flavor connection with Spreading Plague, though if you can find a way to specify that the Horde Warrior's can't attack heroes on the base card without making the card look too wordy, you really should do that. I first thought they could attack heroes which would be absurdly broken as it would allow easy OTKs. With it not being able to attack heroes, I think the card is pretty balanced as it's very similar to a Dragonfire Potion (or Felfire Potion) like that. The synergy with Commanding Shout is really nice as well.

Cursed Shield is pretty cool and pairs nicely with the Divine Shield theme in KotFT. That said, there's the problem you mentioned with Deathspeaker.

Quote from Don_Dingle >>

Quote from LordofBots >>

I see a lot of creative ideas, hope I've time to review them before they go submission thread. Here is my ideas for this week;

 For the Cursed Shield my initial idea was 3 mana, then I thought it would be too weak, and obviously it requires a divine shield minion to activate again. The only problem would be Deathspeaker requires some update like immune to fatal damage.

For the Spreading Rage I wanted to say hello to Spreading Plague, hope I didn't mess up with Horde Warrior. Why I made it as warrior card? Because it sounds right to me >.< . I know warriors have Brawl, but its kinda cooler for me.

I have 1-2 more card ideas, but before I want to hear your reviews about them ^.^

 

 Cursed Shield: It's an interesting concept, but it's not supposed to go off more than twice right? If so, I don't think it takes advantage of this week's theme very well.

Spreading Rage: It would be balanced, only if the Horde Warriors couldn't attack face. If that's too wordy, maybe you could make the charge minions 1/1 with Poisonous? You might have to change the class if you did that though.

 

Here's an idea of mine that looks silly but is actually quite useful. 

• In Aggro Rogue, if you run Stonetusk Boar or Southsea Deckhand, you can play this for lethal with Cold Blood and Tinker's Sharpsword Oil. Just be prepared to Sap any taunt minions.
• In Wild, if you discount your hand with Emperor Thaurissan, you can play this card, conceal your minions, and play Valeera the Hollow to prevent taking damage.
• In Mill Rogue, you can fill your deck with cheap cycle minions and use this card to draw out your opponents minions to thin their deck. After playing this, just Vanish.
• Against Big Priest, you can pull out their big minions, then kill them all with Plague Scientist plus Unstable Ghoul or Wild Pyromancer.
• Counters Quest Mage and many other combo decks.

In fact, I'm starting to think that this card is OP at 2 mana.

I'm still considering alternate names for it, something along the lines of "Do or Die", "Our Finest Hour", "Heroic Raid", "Reckless Assault", "Last Stand", or "Final Endeavor."

Quote from SvagoCorp >>

Finally have something worth submitting. Which do you like the most?

My favorite is the first one, but I think the second one has that meme factor that might gather me some more votes.

@ShadowOfSense working overtime to add all of these reviews. There's a disappointing number of them that don't even use "cast this again"; stop trying to go Rogue, people! :/

@nurgling13

1. I like Curious Vision, but in Wild its chances of creating a streak plummet hard. Those chances will only decrease with time.
2. Chain Lightning is a fine card, but a large percentage of the submissions are damage-related. It might get lost among the others.
3. Echoing Vision is cool, especially later in the game when you're fishing for higher-cost cards.

I would go with Curious Vision or Echoing Vision, personally.

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Quote from linkblade91 >>

@nurgling13

1. I like Curious Vision, but in Wild its chances of creating a streak plummet hard. Those chances will only decrease with time.
2. Chain Lightning is a fine card, but a large percentage of the submissions are damage-related. It might get lost among the others.
3. Echoing Vision is cool, especially later in the game when you're fishing for higher-cost cards.

I would go with Curious Vision or Echoing Vision, personally.

Does Blizzard really even balance around Wild, though? I feel like there are probably other cards that are good in Standard but not as good in Wild, although I can't think of any off the top of my head. There are definitely cards that are way better in Wild than Standard, though.

I already submitted mine just a moment ago, but I wanted last-minute input on one thing if anyone would be so kind.

I heard someone saying earlier in the thread that no card ever uses the word "played" to refer to a spell. It's always "cast". However, in this context I want to differentiate between things like Servant of Yogg-Saron or Yogg-Saron, Hope's End himself, and say that spells the minions cast do not work. I also don't want to say cast twice in a row: "Discover a non-Legendary spell that you cast this game. Cast it."

Is it acceptable in this case to use "played"? More than anything I think it sounds more professional this way.

Quote from AxletheBeast >>

I already submitted mine just a moment ago, but I wanted last-minute input on one thing if anyone would be so kind.

I heard someone saying earlier in the thread that no card ever uses the word "played" to refer to a spell. It's always "cast". However, in this context I want to differentiate between things like Servant of Yogg-Saron or Yogg-Saron, Hope's End himself, and say that spells the minions cast do not work. I also don't want to say cast twice in a row: "Discover a non-Legendary spell that you cast this game. Cast it."

Is it acceptable in this case to use "played"? More than anything I think it sounds more professional this way.

Hi all :) Great design challenge. I didn't know where to start, so I decided to make one proposition for every class. Let me know which is your favourite one, with some feebdack on mechanics and balance.

#CastorT I think you mean Frozen Blockage with the Mage card. Anyway, some of these are pretty unique, compared to what's out there already. With that in mind, my favorites are Pack Revenge and Elite Selection. Deathrattle Hunter could use some love, and Elite Selection is very flavorful: "You need more healing? Too bad! *whomp!*"

Does someone maybe have any insight regarding the balance of the card below? It obviously does nothing for a basic Wicked Dagger (well, it destroys it, so that's something lol), but you can get in some quick and effective burst damage on pretty much any 3+ Durability weapon. Of course, the Durability loss is negated with Runeforge Haunter. Do you think that that combo would be consistent enough to be OP, like with an Assassin's Blade? And without it, is the Durability loss too great to make this worth playing?