My class did quite well on Phase I, but my results on Phase II are pretty meh.
Sometimes I feel discussion doesn't serve for much, because I didn't receive any serious critics about my Basic set.
I think the Basic set is inherently harder to sell to people. We're being asked to rein in the flashiness, and you can't use any special Keywords and the like. Compared to the power level and excitement-factor of expansion sets, Basic is not very tantalizing.
Maybe people should design the classic set before the basic one. It would allow then to try interesting things and create a more unique identity for their class. Plus, they get to play with the keywords one phase earlier.
0 upvotes... I think that Basic set is definitely the hardest part of this competition, but maybe being just at the bottom of second page isn't good too. Anyways, I really don't know if I do something wrong or writing the post so quick to make it before the time limit made it "not impressive" or even unable to read because of some lesser or bigger mistakes
You shouldn't use your class specific keyword for basic set. That's probably your biggest mistake. Of course its not your fault if you don't have much experience in class creating.
You shouldn't use your class specific keyword for basic set. That's probably your biggest mistake. Of course its not your fault if you don't have much experience in class creating.
This is my first custom class, thanks for the advice. I didn't have any idea for 2 missing cards, so I made Wreak Havoc and Violent Blow with my keyword, although I know that I could have done it better (especially the first one)
You shouldn't use your class specific keyword for basic set. That's probably your biggest mistake. Of course its not your fault if you don't have much experience in class creating.
This is my first custom class, thanks for the advice. I didn't have any idea for 2 missing cards, so I made Wreak Havoc and Violent Blow with my keyword, although I know that I could have done it better (especially the first one)
It's not just only that you shouldn't use the keyword in your Basic cards, you are going to be disqualified if you do. So remember that for your next competition.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click here to visit my Timestream Tracking Finalist Year of the Dragon in collaboration with Demonxz95
Also there's a bug in the voting system where the upvote button still appears as normal for submission you have already upvoted. Missing upvotes are likely due to people who forgot they already upvoted you and tried to upvote again...therefore unknowingly withdrawing their votes.
Yes, I had that issue. I hope I hadn't remove any of my votes, because I won't have acces to computer for some time, and cannot check that. So if anybody of people mentioned below don't have my vote get me know AS FAST AS POSSIBLE:
Im a bit sad i only got 0 upvotes.. i waited a whole year for this competition. Do you have tips for next time?
I personally think it's due to your hero power. It somewhat fails the Sir Finley Mrrgglton test in the sense that half of the hero powers effect can only be utilized by your class. Same thing if your class was playing a deck that didn't use positioning, or had a random deck from a tavern brawl. the movement part would of the hero power would become a bit tedious when it bassically does nothing.
Yes, I had that issue. I hope I hadn't remove any of my votes, because I won't have acces to computer for some time, and cannot check that. So if anybody of people mentioned below don't have my vote get me know AS FAST AS POSSIBLE:
@Demonxz95
@Wailor
@Pircival
@NoahMcGrath
@NiRast
@The guy who made researcher
I don't know how to check who voted my post. Anyways, it probably doesn't matter, I won't make it with just a couple votes.
You know that number next to the up-vote arrow that tells you how many votes you have? Click it and see a list of who voted you and when they voted you.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click the image to go to my custom Time Traveler class.
You know that number next to the up-vote arrow that tells you how many votes you have? Click it and see a list of who voted you and when they voted you.
Okay, thanks ^^
@MurderyUnicorn, I have your upvote, so don't worry.
Im a bit sad i only got 0 upvotes.. i waited a whole year for this competition. Do you have tips for next time?
Your class got a decent amount of vote in Phase I, so I think people obviously liked your class idea and Hero Power. I personally think that it is because your Basic cards are disconnected to the flavor of the class. Only 3 of the Basic cards have the Travelling theme of the class. The new flavor seem more like a bunch of Monk cards you reskinned to fit into the class.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click here to visit my Timestream Tracking Finalist Year of the Dragon in collaboration with Demonxz95
Im a bit sad i only got 0 upvotes.. i waited a whole year for this competition. Do you have tips for next time?
Oh no, McF4rtson is first again xd
Maybe people should design the classic set before the basic one. It would allow then to try interesting things and create a more unique identity for their class. Plus, they get to play with the keywords one phase earlier.
Results are usually different when you get to the phases with polls. I wouldn't say this is indicative of anything just yet.
Click the image to go to my custom Time Traveler class.
(No salt)
0 upvotes... I think that Basic set is definitely the hardest part of this competition, but maybe being just at the bottom of second page isn't good too. Anyways, I really don't know if I do something wrong or writing the post so quick to make it before the time limit made it "not impressive" or even unable to read because of some lesser or bigger mistakes
I'm more salty that someone took back their upvote from my post than that i only have 3.
@Noah_McGrath
Hadn't that happened already to you last phase? Maybe that's the same guy xD?
@MrNightmare
You shouldn't use your class specific keyword for basic set. That's probably your biggest mistake. Of course its not your fault if you don't have much experience in class creating.
This is my first custom class, thanks for the advice. I didn't have any idea for 2 missing cards, so I made Wreak Havoc and Violent Blow with my keyword, although I know that I could have done it better (especially the first one)
It's not just only that you shouldn't use the keyword in your Basic cards, you are going to be disqualified if you do. So remember that for your next competition.
Click here to visit my Timestream Tracking Finalist Year of the Dragon in collaboration with Demonxz95
Class Creation Finalist: The Astromancer
Best cards vote by community:
It did happen last phase too. If i make it to phase 3 i'll write down everyone who upvotes me to see who this prankster is.
Day 3 rakings:
Also there's a bug in the voting system where the upvote button still appears as normal for submission you have already upvoted. Missing upvotes are likely due to people who forgot they already upvoted you and tried to upvote again...therefore unknowingly withdrawing their votes.
Custom cards :
CLASSES : Alchemist (CCC#5 | Phase V) | Chef (CCC#4)
EXPANSIONS : Year of the Scorpion (Year Comp)
Yes, I had that issue. I hope I hadn't remove any of my votes, because I won't have acces to computer for some time, and cannot check that. So if anybody of people mentioned below don't have my vote get me know AS FAST AS POSSIBLE:
@Demonxz95
@Wailor
@Pircival
@NoahMcGrath
@NiRast
@The guy who made researcher
I personally think it's due to your hero power. It somewhat fails the Sir Finley Mrrgglton test in the sense that half of the hero powers effect can only be utilized by your class. Same thing if your class was playing a deck that didn't use positioning, or had a random deck from a tavern brawl. the movement part would of the hero power would become a bit tedious when it bassically does nothing.
So I guess the tip is to always do the Sir Finley Mrrgglton test!
Check out my Custom Classes (Scribe, Alchemist, and Battlemage)!
When does the up-vote part of Phase 2 end, and Phase 3 start? I know it's sometimes today, but on what timezone?
I don't know how to check who voted my post. Anyways, it probably doesn't matter, I won't make it with just a couple votes.
You know that number next to the up-vote arrow that tells you how many votes you have? Click it and see a list of who voted you and when they voted you.
Click the image to go to my custom Time Traveler class.
Usually around 5pm est, give or take a few minutes because it isn’t automated. So about 5.25 hours from now.
Currently working on the Tinker! K&C and WW / JUG and KotFT / Classic / Basic / Introduction
My Previous Classes: Apothecary (unfinished) / Chronomancer / Death Knight (old)
My Previous Expansions: Hallow's End
Okay, thanks ^^
@MurderyUnicorn, I have your upvote, so don't worry.
Your class got a decent amount of vote in Phase I, so I think people obviously liked your class idea and Hero Power. I personally think that it is because your Basic cards are disconnected to the flavor of the class. Only 3 of the Basic cards have the Travelling theme of the class. The new flavor seem more like a bunch of Monk cards you reskinned to fit into the class.
Click here to visit my Timestream Tracking Finalist Year of the Dragon in collaboration with Demonxz95
Class Creation Finalist: The Astromancer
Best cards vote by community: