It is just a good murloc card. Nobody, except you, calling for such nerf :P Now Murloc Shaman is a viable Tier2 deck (in Wild) and can compete with other Tier decks.
If you fiddle with the tabs, you can figure out which cards are under-performing - Unleash the Hounds and Dreadscale are the only "losing" cards in the deck. I'd probably replace them with another Secret for Mad Scientist (he's got one of the highest played win-rates in the deck), and a second Candleshot. Dr. Boom seems under-rated in the format - he's quite a good finisher in slower aggro decks, like DR Hunter, and his played win-rate is nearly 60%. The single copy of Master's Call also seems odd, given that the deck only runs a single copy of Tracking - the latter spell has a played win-rate about 4% better than MC, so it might be worthwhile to simply swap in a second copy.
I think those 60% in 500 games probably on low ranks.
I tested exact list and it cannot have such high winrate against Priest (Big) and Paladin (Odd).
WINS: vs Murloc Shaman vs Reno Warlock vs Darkest Hour vs Big Priest vs Odd Warrior vs Token Aggro Druid
LOSES: vs Odd Pala vs Token Aggro Druid vs Kingsbane Rogue vs Even Shaman
My suggestion to improve: 1) As we can see, this deck is weak against combo. Because it is slow and can't interrupt opponent plan. Nothing can't be done about it. We are too slow. 2) Also it is weak against aggro deck, because it is have no good mass removal. And can't fight for board, so aggro snowball you easily. But we can improve our deck against it and not lose key idea of a deck. Cards that are good against aggro: aoe secrets rexxar dk Dreadscale Zilliax unleash the hounds etc.
I dont like animal companion, Barnes, maybe other cards.
Ok, thanks! :) I have almost every card, so i'll test it on a legend rank ladder and later share my results.
First 10 games:
WINS: vs Darkest Hour Warlock (he had no combo ever) vs Mill N'Zoth Rogue (he didn't draw N'Zoth) vs Heal Zoo Warlock (i draw Rexxar DK) vs Token Aggro Druid (i draw Rexxar DK)
LOSES: vs Anyfin Paladin (turn 10 Anyfin gg) vs Big Priest vs Big Priest vs Reno Dragon Priest (game was super close) vs Kingsbane Pirate Rogue vs Even Shaman (almost win, but that good person get Army of the Dead from Lich King and roll for 2 Sea Giants, 1 faceless and 1 witch, nice)
0
Maybe Big Priest and Odd Paladin are also fun?
2
It is just a good murloc card. Nobody, except you, calling for such nerf :P
Now Murloc Shaman is a viable Tier2 deck (in Wild) and can compete with other Tier decks.
0
I think those 60% in 500 games probably on low ranks.
I tested exact list and it cannot have such high winrate against Priest (Big) and Paladin (Odd).
0
Tnx, i'll try to play without secrets.
0
Here is my current version:
### Nine Lives Oblivitron
# Class: Hunter
# Format: Wild
#
# 1x (1) Candleshot
# 2x (1) Play Dead
# 1x (1) Sir Finley Mrrgglton
# 1x (1) Tracking
# 2x (2) Explosive Trap
# 1x (2) Feign Death
# 2x (2) Mad Scientist
# 1x (2) Venomstrike Trap
# 2x (2) Wandering Monster
# 1x (3) Cloaked Huntress
# 2x (3) Nine Lives
# 2x (3) Spider Bomb
# 1x (3) Unleash the Hounds
# 2x (3) Ursatron
# 1x (4) Houndmaster Shaw
# 1x (4) Spiritsinger Umbra
# 1x (5) Carnivorous Cube
# 1x (5) Zilliax
# 1x (6) Deathstalker Rexxar
# 1x (6) Oblivitron
# 1x (6) Sylvanas Windrunner
# 1x (8) Sneed's Old Shredder
# 1x (10) N'Zoth, the Corruptor
#
AAEBAR8QlwjbCbkNxw+iEIQX4KwCxLQCycICncwChtMCi+EC4eMCgPMCoIAD8ZYDB8kE9w2czQLf0gK5+ALylgO2nAMA
#
# To use this deck, copy it to your clipboard and create a new deck in Hearthstone
0
Compare to this list (https://www.hearthpwn.com/decks/1266406-deathrattle-hunter-ros) i have:
-1 Dreadscale
+1 Rexxar DK
Another 10 games:
WINS:
vs Murloc Shaman
vs Reno Warlock
vs Darkest Hour
vs Big Priest
vs Odd Warrior
vs Token Aggro Druid
LOSES:
vs Odd Pala
vs Token Aggro Druid
vs Kingsbane Rogue
vs Even Shaman
My suggestion to improve:
1) As we can see, this deck is weak against combo. Because it is slow and can't interrupt opponent plan. Nothing can't be done about it. We are too slow.
2) Also it is weak against aggro deck, because it is have no good mass removal. And can't fight for board, so aggro snowball you easily.
But we can improve our deck against it and not lose key idea of a deck.
Cards that are good against aggro:
aoe secrets
rexxar dk
Dreadscale
Zilliax
unleash the hounds etc.
I dont like animal companion, Barnes, maybe other cards.
Maybe i'll add N'Zoth.
Need more testing.
0
i've almost finished another 10 games and after i will write my feedback :)
1
More statistic:
WINS:
vs Beast Druid (meme?)
vs Reno Warlock
vs Reno Warlock
vs Mill Rogue
vs Odd Bomb Warrior
LOSES:
vs Elemental Mage
vs Big Priest
vs Token Aggro Druid
vs Darkest Hour Warlock
vs Mecha'Thun Warlock
Better. Maybe i have faith in this deck now. Not sure.
1
First 10 games:
WINS:
vs Darkest Hour Warlock (he had no combo ever)
vs Mill N'Zoth Rogue (he didn't draw N'Zoth)
vs Heal Zoo Warlock (i draw Rexxar DK)
vs Token Aggro Druid (i draw Rexxar DK)
LOSES:
vs Anyfin Paladin (turn 10 Anyfin gg)
vs Big Priest
vs Big Priest
vs Reno Dragon Priest (game was super close)
vs Kingsbane Pirate Rogue
vs Even Shaman (almost win, but that good person get Army of the Dead from Lich King and roll for 2 Sea Giants, 1 faceless and 1 witch, nice)
Overall deck seems kinda weak.
Gonna try another 10 games.
1
Ok, thanks! :)
I have almost every card, so i'll test it on a legend rank ladder and later share my results.
0
So, i tried to build some variations of Hunter decks, but failed.
Maybe someone has success in rank5+ with some sort of Reno Hunter, or Spell Hunter, or Secret Hunter, or Juzeppe Maly Hunter?
HELP!
Can midrange, control or combo Hunter compete with all this Odd Paly, Even Shaman, Big Priest, Kingsbane Rogue decks?
1
There should be a kill demon, heal five zero mana spell for sure.
2
It is not about winrate of this deck, it is about frustrating and non-interactive experience and highrolling potential.
0
Dude, Nerubian Unraveler is a key card. With it this deck is immune to mass removal in early-mid game.
2
Enjoy! :D