Rarity isn't supposed to a measure of power, it's a measure of how unique their effect is. You can easily replace your Chillwind yeti with any other common 4 drop but you can't replace your Reno in your renolock or Hadronox in your taunt druid
It should be noted that a lot of the "bad" legendaries on your list were played in past meta decks. By "meta" I mean seen in at least 5 tournament lists at some point
- Sherazin was in tier 1 miracle rogue in early Un'Goro
- Mosh is an uncommon card in control warriors throughout his existence in standard
- Tyrantus was a popular anti-druid tech card during the druidstone era from WW until the recent ramp nerfs
- Prince Valanar was played in some fringe warlocks
- Kingsbane, but you already explained that
- The Boomship is played in Mecha'thun warriors
- Millhouse is played in some paladins for call to arms synergy
- Cenarius was a good card in classic and was also played more recently in token druid
- Mukla is a tech card that occasionally shows up in aggro decks
- Jaraxxus was played in classic up until around the first rotation
- Cairne was played in classic and in tempo warrior (from last year or before that?)
- Ditto Deathwing. especially in tempo dragon warrior
If they were good, they can be good again. On the flip side, there are cards like Hadronox that were unplayable until they were tier 1. Also, I had Gonk and Zentimo carry me to legend once each they're perfectly fine cards as long as you're not trying hard to netdeck
1
Just FYI outof.cards have a working plugin for Hearthstone Deck Tracker to sync your collection now...
1
Maybe if you look at all the other topics regarding this matter you may find an answer to your question.
9
It never will (at least what we know off) since it was discontinued a couple off months ago.
The new owners have not addressed the issue at all so for the time being the client is dead.
2
Definitely the best deck around to beat this boss for real. No restart bullshit. Just play Reno at 6 and you are good to go! Great work man!
3
More than often people just concede when they are down to 15 health and I am sitting there with 5 secrets :D
2
Pirate Warrior is always fun :D
2
Fun to Play. Usually you never even need to use C'Thun. But it makes your opponent nervous :D
As a casual player usually in the 18-13 ranks lately it's actually pretty great! Thanks for sharing!
2
Good deck to play still in current meta. Haven't played too many games yet but have a decent winrate. Also cheap, which will be good for your dust-bank :) Just board-control until Turn 5-6 something and then go for the kill.
4
Even though Pirate Warrior isn't that viable in the current meta it's still fun to play. This is also the best guide for it for any beginner! (at least how to build it when you have nothing). Great work!
2
Really good and fun deck to play for a somewhat new player. Got me to rank 16 at least in current meta but after that it got really hard. Really good for learning the Midrange Hunter Mechanics but it needs some medicine against the dark knights and the a lot of priests.