Weekly Card Design Competition 3.01 [Final Poll]
Poll: Vote for your favourite "Feugen and Stalagg Need Friends" cards!
Log in with your Curse username to vote in this poll.
Vote for your favourite "Feugen and Stalagg Need Friends" cards! - Multiple Choice
- “Dark Howl & Night Gore” by FrostedBricks 23.3% of Users - 20 votes
- “Arthas Menethil & The Lich King” by havox112 15.1% of Users - 13 votes
- “Red Little Riding Hood & The Big Bad Wolf” by MardyVain 17.4% of Users - 15 votes
- “Mankrik & Olgra” by SyrianeKT 15.1% of Users - 13 votes
- “Murloc Holmes & Watt-son” by RandomScribbles 45.3% of Users - 39 votes
- “Arthas Menithil & The Lich King” by DougBarrett 4.7% of Users - 4 votes
- “Kael’thas Sunstrider & Al’ar” by Elyxie 20.9% of Users - 18 votes
- “Captain Cookie & Captain Raisin” by Agithore 9.3% of Users - 8 votes
- “Madam Goya & Mister Chu” by SWGolgoth 12.8% of Users - 11 votes
- “Lady Sacrolash & Grand Warlcok Alythess” by Zukuu 8.1% of Users - 7 votes
- “Li Li Stormstout & Po Stormstout” by Elewinduu 8.1% of Users - 7 votes
- “Alexi Barov & Weldon Barov” by Qormusata 9.3% of Users - 8 votes
- “Boom Master & Gadget Master” by Kroneker 14% of Users - 12 votes
- “Gatewatcher Gyro-Kill & Gatewatcher Iron-Hand” by Firebolts 11.6% of Users - 10 votes
- “High Inquisitor Whitemane & Scarlet Commander Mograine” by BeastlyDecks 9.3% of Users - 8 votes
- “Dalliah the Doomsayer & Wrath-Scryer Soccothrates” by Advocent 3.5% of Users - 3 votes
- “Midnight & Attumen The Huntsman” by sean0e 8.1% of Users - 7 votes
- “Ji Firepaw & Aysa Cloudsinger” by Sebastian_Michaelis 11.6% of Users - 10 votes
- “Hellbourne & Terrorblade” by sashashepto 16.3% of Users - 14 votes
- “Castor & Pollux” by Gomelus 9.3% of Users - 8 votes
Ended Jan 14, 2016
Posts Quoted:
Reply
Clear All Quotes
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
You cannot attack his submission and then ask him not to defend it, that is just unreasonable, unfair, and childish.
Pretty sure everyone heard you the first two-three times, you like Murlock-Holmes and Watt-Son, and dislike Arthas Menethil and The Lich King. Is it really necessary to continue spamming your opinion? I mean what's the point? Clearly you've made it known, so why bother posting the same thing over and over again?
Yes, that is how arguments and debates work. When one side says something, the other side responds, and then you keep iterating on that. I'm not going to stop when they are still points to refute.
That is part of the problem. A lot of us use the Discussion Forum and go to great effort to balance our cards (including, you know, acquiring and responding to feedback). The fact that he did not do this is the problem, not an excuse. As I said, it cheapens the competition when someone made no effort to balance their card, despite the resources here to do so, then wins a competition,
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
I'm just going to say good luck to everybody and I hope bashing in the voting thread doesn't derail anyone's chance of winning the competition.
I'm not going to bother fighting against someone who is adamant on destroying my idea without being respectful in any way.
P.S. I didn't see the feedback thread and now that I've seen it I am still standing by my decision on the card. I made the card in good faith and my reasons are stated in the thread/this thread as to why it is.
3.01 Finalist| 3.04 Finalist|3.05 Finalist
a harsh attack isn't needed AT ALL unless they get offensive first. you can easily make valid points WHILE being polite. saying you have to attack someone because they didn't do what you said is dangerously close to (if it isn't) harassment. my first comment was actually longer but I felt it came off as offensive to other peoples choice of vote and their opinions so I edited it. it's not that you conveyed your opinion, it's how you said it.
I really like the Dark Howl/Night Gore combo, it's a really neat Legendary idea, flashy enough for it to be creative without making it borderline OP just for show.
First time Finalist :D
Good luck everybody else!
Been in the finals a few times before, but i've never been so excited to see who will win what with the hidden votes and all. Good luck to everybody!
I am a servant of the world. And if I'm a servant, then you should consider yourself a tool, at best.
Siras Terra, the Geomancer
Glad to have at least made it this far.
Murloc Holmes probably has this in the bag, but I'll see how far my two will get.
Also, will the total votes for all finalists be revealed after this?
Give a man a Murloc, and he'll eat for a day.
Give him a Murloc Knight, and people will hate him.
I actually think that Dark Howl and Night Core are actually a bit weak. Compare Dark Howl to Goblin Auto-Barber and I feel like it should be a 3/3.
I also really question the Combo effect. 'From the Hand'? It would actually be better if it was something like 'Night Gore costs (3) less this turn' and vise versa so that you can actually get the benefit of both.
Give a man a Murloc, and he'll eat for a day.
Give him a Murloc Knight, and people will hate him.
"Completely OP broken card pair."
if I had made my cards 3/15 it probably wouldn't see play for the reason of not enough value for the investment and too much risk of being screwed by your opponent.
in this meta people are running removal so I can't understand why a 5/15 with a reliance on RNG is game breaking. It's like you can't step slightly over this "lin e" without triggering people. I made the card playable unlike Majordomo Executus which is insanely unplayable. Will this card see play in every deck? Hell no. It only fits long game control looking for another tool at their disposal.
3.01 Finalist| 3.04 Finalist|3.05 Finalist
You can find me here! Good luck everyone!
Very restrictive competition, my hope was it won't be the chosen theme. Have to vote for Murloc Holmes & Watt-son, everything else pales in comparison.
I see a lot of people talk about Arthas and The Lich King. I can't vote for it, not so much because balance but because the large generation of generic tokens makes it feel like a mess and I prefer simple designs. Never understood what excites people about submissions like that. Also, anything including Arthas removes him as a potential future Death Knight hero. Just my opinion, I don't mind much if it wins.