Elywnn Stalker: A Rogue-ish spin on Corpsetaker, one of my favorite cards.
Ephemeral Assasin: Solid card for Kingsbane Rogue that's especially good once Kingsbane gets a really high attack.
Baratus: Better/cooler version of Rotface that could be used to keep up pressure in a control warrior deck.
Elywnn Stalker: Maybe make it a 3/3, 4/2, 2/4 so that it isn't a vanilla minion when you just stick it in any random deck? That's my only real comment on this one. Hopefully, Blizzard adds more cards that have a similar "if you have minion with X, do Y" in the future!
Ephemeral Assassin: Why the stealth? Its battlecry will cancel the stealth when played from the hand. Also because of possible kingsbane stuff, maybe make the damage limited to minions? Otherwise I like the card, make more weapon rogues a thing!
Baratus: hmm, I think its too powerful, its a vanilla stated dragon with an upside. Maybe increase it to an 8 mana minion with 8 health (or maybe even 9 mana)? Also this is better than Rotface as I'm certain that a random dragon is more powerful than a random legendary.
I think my favorite of the bunch would be the stalker as it is a source for rogue healing (plus) and can be a pretty decent card!
I'll review every card I haven't yet 'cus I'm feeling like it.
@Demonxz95: I like this guy. I love the artwork -- and all the other ones from that guy which I can't remember the name -- and I think you could get away with saying it's a light revenant or something like that, even though it doesn't make much sense.
@nurgling18: Do you really intend to recycle your cycle for this competition? Of the three, I like Gray Cat the most. Too bad you can't make Brown Cat for Druid.
@Vilegloom: Both cards are cool, but I think the lamb would be fine with 1 more stat point and the Dragon just feels too similar to Ysera, which is something I don't really like 'cus it takes away from their uniqueness.
@ColinthePyro: One could say Elwynn Stalker is too good if it gets both buffs but I don't think it makes that big of a difference. I just don't like the flavor of it, it doesn't make sense as a wolf. Assassin is crazy overpowered with Kingsbane as it can target face and still way too good if it can't.
@Macabessa: I like Soul Carver, though it feels more like a Demon than an Elemental. Shady Dealer is already a card, but the effect is really cool and I would love to pull off some wacky combos with a card like this. Cursed Marauder is by far the least interesting one.
@zartgruen: I don't think either of them fits in a deck that would run Twig and even then, those effects are just so specific I'd rather you just make another Druid card that equips a weapon for you.
Here's one of my old designs, feedback would be much appreciated
That's a pretty cool card... although it seems really bad. Compared to Cataclysm this does nothing to the board and makes you very susceptible to even a weak aoe.
Some ideas I just had. Didn't put much thought into them. The Pirates are mostly about flavor, which is why they ended up nearly useless except in very specific situations.
I suppose we're not allowed to use fanmade keywords in the competition, am I right? Otherwise there's this card inside the spoiler alongside the Enrager I already posted here.
Alright, I got 3 ideas in fact two since I reused one so I'm putting them here I guess:
Yes I know there are two of the same cards, but they have different names, I want to see which one fits the card better.
I remember the Warturtle!
Regarding the cards, I love Coward Warturtle and Fin Reaper (Prefer that name, sounds cute). I think both cards are pretty balanced, the only thing I have to say about the murloc is that a big, bulky murloc seems pretty weird (but that's just me).
Decaying Hypograph is also a pretty cool card, seems fairly balanced (maybe one health reduction?) but I personally prefer the ideas mentioned above.
@nurgling18: Do you really intend to recycle your cycle for this competition? Of the three, I like Gray Cat the most. Too bad you can't make Brown Cat for Druid.
No, I don't, although I am trying to come up with a fourth cat.
Some ideas I just had. Didn't put much thought into them. The Pirates are mostly about flavor, which is why they ended up nearly useless except in very specific situations.
I suppose we're not allowed to use fanmade keywords in the competition, am I right? Otherwise there's this card inside the spoiler alongside the Enrager I already posted here.
Thanks for the feedback! Do you think I should change the Shady Dealer (name to be changed) into a 2/4 or 2/3 so that the damage is slightly less and perhaps alter the effect of Soul Carver to make it feel more elemental? Anyway, onto your cards.
Love the flavor of the pirate cards but I find the effect of the Marine Consciptor to be a bit boring.
Gnoll Lookout seems like a pretty good card for aggro/face hunters and seems pretty balanced on the surface (might be too powerful but probably fine). I like it!
My favorite card is the murloc though! This card alone could help make a Mur-Lock deck become a reality, potentially powerful and fun! love it!
This is the second time I close the fucking tab before posting this reply. Fuck me.
@nurgling18: Make Blue Cat for Mage/Shaman that freezes or devolves. lul
@Macabessa: You should definitely lower the Attack, but I think the card would be fine even as a 2/5 maybe. If you can pull off the combo, it's 4 cards -- which are pretty bad by themselves -- for 20 damage, which I think is probably fine. Soul Carver, on the other hand, should stay the same, except maybe for the artwork and name. You could try to improve the flavor by changing them.
Moving onto my cards now, first of all, thanks for the feedback. Do you think I should go with the Murloc instead of the Rager?
@Dr_Scaphandre: I like the Warlock card much better now, but I have no clue as to how to evaluate it. It seems strong but I don't know how much. The Mage one, on the other hand, is stupidly broken.
When I saw the artwork of Defias Squallshaper, it reminded me of a really old design I made as one of my first cards. It was something like this:
Some ideas I just had. Didn't put much thought into them. The Pirates are mostly about flavor, which is why they ended up nearly useless except in very specific situations.
I suppose we're not allowed to use fanmade keywords in the competition, am I right? Otherwise there's this card inside the spoiler alongside the Enrager I already posted here.
I'd definitely go with Bound Enrager. Marine Conscriptor is a good idea, too, but I think it's kinda weird to have a tech card like that be a class card (rather than neutral).
Here are my submissions! Feedback for feedback.
Soul Carver: Interesting card for trading. When using hellfire with this on board, it takes 3 damage then heals for 3.
Shady Dealer: Mill Druid! Might be a bit too powerful with shenanigans like turn 10 this + another + naturalize + naturalize?
Cursed Marauder: Make an aggro/shadowform priest more viable. Wording could probably have some change!
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
Unpopular opinion: Rogue is OP
I'll review every card I haven't yet 'cus I'm feeling like it.
@Demonxz95: I like this guy. I love the artwork -- and all the other ones from that guy which I can't remember the name -- and I think you could get away with saying it's a light revenant or something like that, even though it doesn't make much sense.
@nurgling18: Do you really intend to recycle your cycle for this competition? Of the three, I like Gray Cat the most. Too bad you can't make Brown Cat for Druid.
@Vilegloom: Both cards are cool, but I think the lamb would be fine with 1 more stat point and the Dragon just feels too similar to Ysera, which is something I don't really like 'cus it takes away from their uniqueness.
@ColinthePyro: One could say Elwynn Stalker is too good if it gets both buffs but I don't think it makes that big of a difference. I just don't like the flavor of it, it doesn't make sense as a wolf. Assassin is crazy overpowered with Kingsbane as it can target face and still way too good if it can't.
@Macabessa: I like Soul Carver, though it feels more like a Demon than an Elemental. Shady Dealer is already a card, but the effect is really cool and I would love to pull off some wacky combos with a card like this. Cursed Marauder is by far the least interesting one.
@zartgruen: I don't think either of them fits in a deck that would run Twig and even then, those effects are just so specific I'd rather you just make another Druid card that equips a weapon for you.
Here's one of my old designs, feedback would be much appreciated
Here are some of my ideas. What do you think? Any feedback is appreciated.
Alright, I got 3 ideas
in fact two since I reused oneso I'm putting them here I guess:Yes I know there are two of the same cards, but they have different names, I want to see which one fits the card better.
The joke is you.
Some ideas I just had. Didn't put much thought into them. The Pirates are mostly about flavor, which is why they ended up nearly useless except in very specific situations.
I suppose we're not allowed to use fanmade keywords in the competition, am I right? Otherwise there's this card inside the spoiler alongside the Enrager I already posted here.
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
Let me know what you think of my next two ideas. I got a huge catalog of Pirate cards and only one of them is gonna be my submission.
Fun fact: Defias Squallshaper is originally from the WoW TCG. If we ever do get that dream Pirate expansion of mine, I hope she gets added.
Basically, it works just like Jade golem. Any advice for this one?
This is the second time I close the fucking tab before posting this reply. Fuck me.
@nurgling18: Make Blue Cat for Mage/Shaman that freezes or devolves. lul
@Macabessa: You should definitely lower the Attack, but I think the card would be fine even as a 2/5 maybe. If you can pull off the combo, it's 4 cards -- which are pretty bad by themselves -- for 20 damage, which I think is probably fine. Soul Carver, on the other hand, should stay the same, except maybe for the artwork and name. You could try to improve the flavor by changing them.
Moving onto my cards now, first of all, thanks for the feedback. Do you think I should go with the Murloc instead of the Rager?
@Dr_Scaphandre: I like the Warlock card much better now, but I have no clue as to how to evaluate it. It seems strong but I don't know how much. The Mage one, on the other hand, is stupidly broken.
When I saw the artwork of Defias Squallshaper, it reminded me of a really old design I made as one of my first cards. It was something like this:
What do you think of it?
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
There's a new member of the Cat Cycle:
Brought to you by nurgling13, Defender of Cats
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition