Van Cleef is more important, both in this deck and going forward into the future. After BGH and Silence Owl were nerfed, Edwin VC saw HUGE increase in play, and basically became an essential craft if you play Rogue. Shaku is a 'very nice' or 'luxury' card - very good, but can be replaced. You can try 2nd SI Agent, Plague Scientist, Southsea captain. Lot's of decent 3-drops can be replacements.
hi all, i'm missing two cards from my tempo Rogue which seem core, Edwin VanCleef and Shaku, the Collector.
I've almost got anough dust to craft one of them, which do you think is more important? I'm currently playing this list, -1 Counterfeit Coin , -1 Tar Creeper, +1 Saronite Chain Gang, +1 Bonemare substituting the missing legendaries for 1 Plague Scientist and 1 Shadowblade which is quite effective.
Van Cleef is more important, both in this deck and going forward into the future. After BGH and Silence Owl were nerfed, Edwin VC saw HUGE increase in play, and basically became an essential craft if you play Rogue. Shaku is a 'very nice' or 'luxury' card - very good, but can be replaced. You can try 2nd SI Agent, Plague Scientist, Southsea captain. Lot's of decent 3-drops can be replacements.
Definitely go Edwin. He's a classic card too so he will never rotate out.
Not really a competition. Edwin is both more impactful and is classic card.
Unanimous decision then, thanks everyone!!