Its a hunter deck. plain and simple, no real brain work required, the whole problem with hunter is that sometimes you win and sometimes you completely blow people out, but then you run into someone who stabilizes well enough to just stop you from winning, hunter either wrecks or gets wrecked, its not really consistent anywhere on the ladder, sometimes you have a really good day, and sometimes you don't welcome to huntard
1
Meta seems to have adjusted to this deck getting too popular. Almost everything beats it now.
6
Relax there chuckles, he's trying to contribute to the community and has done a good job. Just because it's not a deck to your fancy or it's not necessarily a revolutionary deck is no need to flame out.
15
Yes, unbeatable except vs Priests, Shammies, Pallies, Locks, Huntards, Mages, Rogues, and other Warriors.
Other than that, yes, "unbeatable."
Kidding. However, I'd advise against using words like that to be the deck's name as people tend to expect the deck's name to be relevant to the deck itself. While this is a good deck, a fun deck, it is hardly "unbeatable." Bad draws or vs a good control Priest or even aggro totem Shammy, this deck struggles.
2
I'm finding that the Pally Secret dominates this deck.
It's a good deck, but 1) it's over hyped (like a lot of new decks are) and 2) half the success with a deck lies with the person. There's a reason Kolento is a top ranked player. Take an average deck and give it to a top ranked player, they will always have a better win rate w/ it than the average Joe.
2
Fun deck, but the brawl Priest, control deck easily takes this deck out. Seems to do well vs other decks though.
So far, 0/3 vs Control Priest. They just counter everything, and it puts them 1 step ahead, always.
5
Not good to blatantly advertise your own deck in someone else's thread.
1
Almost every deck brutalizes this one. There's not enough control for all the aggro out there. Not enough momentum for all the new control decks popping up. This is trying to be too many things at once, and as a result, is failing to do any of them well.
It needs to make up its mind as to what it wants to be.
-1
EVERY deck is beatable if you play the other relevant deck well. No one said that the deck was unbeatable. Obviously, it isn't. There's a difference between:
"This deck cannot be beaten."
and
"This deck wins the vast majority of the time against the other deck."
The last statement is also speaking on general terms, as it relates to the general player base. You are trying to make a case about both decks, built only on your own personal, limited, successful experience with it. Either you are extremely lucky (having a great hand or your opponents not), or you are extremely good. Most people aren't exceptional players.
Decks in Tavern Brawl ought to have a measurable degree of equal competitiveness since TB isn't a "legend only" player feature, nor is it "100% luck" feature. It's a feature offered to the general public. That means it ought to have a respectable degree of balance. And so far, the overwhelming majority of the community has reported their experience of it not being balanced. That means that either those criticizing the decks are all below average players and the average and above average players don't post on Hearthpwn or it means there really is a balance issue here.
1
Jousting Tally Win Rate So Far : 7 / 17
Why didn't Blizz use the Paladin deck to showcase the Joust mechanic? This deck is absolutely horrible as a joust deck.
This deck will turn a lot of people off to jousting, and instead just emphasizes how good Inspire is over it.
As others have stated, similar to the very first Tavern Brawl, if this deck is drawn, it may just be better to auto-concede.
So far, I've lost every match in TB w/ this deck, I have won every match with the other.
--------------------
For a deck that is "reliant" on Jousting...it sure is poorly designed. I'll keep that ratio updated. 41% joust win rate (as of my current match) ? Seriously?
2
No contest. This wrecks the other deck, easily. So far, I'm won every match in Tavern Brawl with this deck. 0 wins in the other.