This really needs fixed one way or the other. Currently, when you play CtA, regardless of the order Murlocs get pulled in, the Tidecaller will get the appropriate buffs.
Knife Juggler though, it depends on which place it is of the 3 cards drawn how many knives get thrown.
It absolutely needs to be changed to be consistent one way or the other. Changing knife Juggler probably better as Tidecaller’s is simpler and consistent.
Other option I could see is have neither activate since one could say they summon simultaneously.
It's definitely a weird interaction, the key word that changes everything is the whenever as the previous dude says but it still is hard to work around it cause you could argue ok call to arms summons all minions at the same exact time so it doesn't technically matter if you get the tidecaller "first" or "last" cause all minions fo out at the same time so they are all both first at last and that's why the tidecaller triggers no matter what which would make complete sense but then why does knife juggler only triggers if he gets out of the deck and then either one or two minions, why doesn't he trigger 3 times evey time? if all the minions get played at the exact same time he should trigger cause technically both minions go with and after him at the same time if we follow the example one logic right? cause if they do get summonend at the same time technically then the knifejuggler should either get trigger 2 times always or not get triggered at all and if they do not get recruited at the same time but in a 1 after the other basis then the knife juggler interaction is perfectly fine cause he only gets triggered if he gets drawn in first or second place but then the murloc one is just bs, it does say whenever but if they do get recruited in that specific 1-2-3 order and they hit the board in that specific order then it makes no sense that the murloc triggers if he hits last, even if it says whenever he would technically not be at the board when the other 2 murlocs get recruited so there would be nothing to give the +1 to, so both interactions are fine but they can't work at the same time (like both work in the game) as there is a crucial conflict between them.
It should go off which you pull first. It makes no sense for tidecaller to get 2 buffs when it's the 3rd card pulled. Side note, this card can burn in hell along with the aggro/murloc paladin archtype
It should go off which you pull first. It makes no sense for tidecaller to get 2 buffs when it's the 3rd card pulled. Side note, this card can burn in hell along with the aggro/murloc paladin archtype
This and this ^^
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
This really needs fixed one way or the other. Currently, when you play CtA, regardless of the order Murlocs get pulled in, the Tidecaller will get the appropriate buffs.
Knife Juggler though, it depends on which place it is of the 3 cards drawn how many knives get thrown.
It absolutely needs to be changed to be consistent one way or the other. Changing knife Juggler probably better as Tidecaller’s is simpler and consistent.
Other option I could see is have neither activate since one could say they summon simultaneously.
Murloc Tidecaller uses the word "whenever" while Knife Juggler uses the word "after"
This is what is causing Tidecaller to trigger regardless of order; while restricting Knife Juggler to trigger depending on when it is summoned.
It's definitely a weird interaction, the key word that changes everything is the whenever as the previous dude says but it still is hard to work around it cause you could argue ok call to arms summons all minions at the same exact time so it doesn't technically matter if you get the tidecaller "first" or "last" cause all minions fo out at the same time so they are all both first at last and that's why the tidecaller triggers no matter what which would make complete sense but then why does knife juggler only triggers if he gets out of the deck and then either one or two minions, why doesn't he trigger 3 times evey time? if all the minions get played at the exact same time he should trigger cause technically both minions go with and after him at the same time if we follow the example one logic right? cause if they do get summonend at the same time technically then the knifejuggler should either get trigger 2 times always or not get triggered at all and if they do not get recruited at the same time but in a 1 after the other basis then the knife juggler interaction is perfectly fine cause he only gets triggered if he gets drawn in first or second place but then the murloc one is just bs, it does say whenever but if they do get recruited in that specific 1-2-3 order and they hit the board in that specific order then it makes no sense that the murloc triggers if he hits last, even if it says whenever he would technically not be at the board when the other 2 murlocs get recruited so there would be nothing to give the +1 to, so both interactions are fine but they can't work at the same time (like both work in the game) as there is a crucial conflict between them.
It should go off which you pull first. It makes no sense for tidecaller to get 2 buffs when it's the 3rd card pulled. Side note, this card can burn in hell along with the aggro/murloc paladin archtype