I usually have to tell ppl to post smaller images, to you i kinda have to say the opposite :) go for 220px width, thats ideal ;-)
That being said, i dont like it. I was never rly a fan of extra stats for the downside, especially, if said downside is kinda irrelevant in the right deck/situation.
Interesting cards, but the second (discarding) feels warlocky and the charge on the last card is too strong, should be rush, otherwise it's more like a 7 mana deal 7 damage spell.
I don't think Team 5 will ever print a Choose One card with negative choices, specifically because Fandral exists. In addition to that, Giant Treant's first effect does literally nothing if you don't control any other minions. Unchained Guardian's second effect also should say "their" instead of "his". No card uses "his" to describe their opponent because there are female heroes.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Click the image to go to my custom Time Traveler class.
I usually have to tell ppl to post smaller images, to you i kinda have to say the opposite :) go for 220px width, thats ideal ;-)
That being said, i dont like it. I was never rly a fan of extra stats for the downside, especially, if said downside is kinda irrelevant in the right deck/situation.
I don't think Team 5 will ever print a Choose One card with negative choices, specifically because Fandral exists. In addition to that, Giant Treant's first effect does literally nothing if you don't control any other minions. Unchained Guardian's second effect also should say "their" instead of "his". No card uses "his" to describe their opponent because there are female heroes.
That makes sense, English isn't my first language and sometimes that has his consequences haha.
The first two are too warlock-y. The third is cool, but one option is too good in mill decks, and the other is a better dirty rat. You're onto something, but none of these quite hot the mark
I like the premise of choosing between bad effects, but...
5-mana 7/7... maybe that's acceptable, but it might just be a bit too big. I don't even know. The drawback is almost surely never going to matter.
I like the mirror symmetry between the Forecaster and a Succubus. However, discarding two cards from a deck literally does not matter to an aggro deck. We learned this with Fel Reaver. A 2-mana 3/4 is going to be almost impossible to remove early, and while it doesn't grow, would be an oppressive early game card.
Unchained Guardian is just broken levels of powerful. Double Dirty Rat on a Rush minion (who also has taunt! insane!). Drop this on 8 mana with a Naturalize in hand, and you'll have essentially an auto-kill card against combo decks. I don't really like combo decks, but this is just beyond. This isn't a drawback, it's a massive, massive benefit. It probably goes 2-1 with the minions it pulls since it has both rush and taunt. Now, if it was "summon a copy of a minion in your opponent's hand" it might work, since that's just extra value for your opponent, rather than disruption. Maybe not, since the mill effects of forcing an opponent to draw 3 cards are also incredibly powerful in Druid. Oh, and it's also super powerful with Hadronox. Summoning 7/9 rush minions to go with a giant taunt wall...
Thoughts?
My custom expansion: Game of Thrones
Intresting...
I usually have to tell ppl to post smaller images, to you i kinda have to say the opposite :) go for 220px width, thats ideal ;-)
That being said, i dont like it. I was never rly a fan of extra stats for the downside, especially, if said downside is kinda irrelevant in the right deck/situation.
- Click Here To Join Us On Discord! -
Interesting cards, but the second (discarding) feels warlocky and the charge on the last card is too strong, should be rush, otherwise it's more like a 7 mana deal 7 damage spell.
--Alfi--
The Fandral sinergy is awesome. :P
I don't think Team 5 will ever print a Choose One card with negative choices, specifically because Fandral exists. In addition to that, Giant Treant's first effect does literally nothing if you don't control any other minions. Unchained Guardian's second effect also should say "their" instead of "his". No card uses "his" to describe their opponent because there are female heroes.
Click the image to go to my custom Time Traveler class.
Thank you, I never knew what was the best size.
My custom expansion: Game of Thrones
That makes sense, English isn't my first language and sometimes that has his consequences haha.
My custom expansion: Game of Thrones
The first two are too warlock-y. The third is cool, but one option is too good in mill decks, and the other is a better dirty rat. You're onto something, but none of these quite hot the mark
I like the premise of choosing between bad effects, but...
5-mana 7/7... maybe that's acceptable, but it might just be a bit too big. I don't even know. The drawback is almost surely never going to matter.
I like the mirror symmetry between the Forecaster and a Succubus. However, discarding two cards from a deck literally does not matter to an aggro deck. We learned this with Fel Reaver. A 2-mana 3/4 is going to be almost impossible to remove early, and while it doesn't grow, would be an oppressive early game card.
Unchained Guardian is just broken levels of powerful. Double Dirty Rat on a Rush minion (who also has taunt! insane!). Drop this on 8 mana with a Naturalize in hand, and you'll have essentially an auto-kill card against combo decks. I don't really like combo decks, but this is just beyond. This isn't a drawback, it's a massive, massive benefit. It probably goes 2-1 with the minions it pulls since it has both rush and taunt. Now, if it was "summon a copy of a minion in your opponent's hand" it might work, since that's just extra value for your opponent, rather than disruption. Maybe not, since the mill effects of forcing an opponent to draw 3 cards are also incredibly powerful in Druid. Oh, and it's also super powerful with Hadronox. Summoning 7/9 rush minions to go with a giant taunt wall...
The last one is way too op due to Mill Druid.