Well you can't really say that because you have no gauge for whether it would change anything or not— it's pure speculation. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Of course I agree with that. I recognize that card quality is not uniform, and of course only certain people go into the finals. I wasn't saying that everyone or more people should get into the finals, but I've browsed through some pages with very even card quality (by my standards) in some past competitions, but those pages have the same vote differentials as many other pages— one or two submissions get 10 or more votes, while some others which I considered to have similar quality (many factors) are left with 0, 1, or 2 votes. I can't really explain that other than 1) I can't discern card quality whatsoever, or 2) Card quality isn't everything when it comes to voting.

I wasn't looking for a 'more even' trail of votes, but perhaps a more honest trail of votes where people have to look through the page to see who to vote for — you can't deny that submissions near the top of each page get more votes than ones near the bottom.

Ok so I've limited my choices to 2 options. One of them was shown before, the other is brand new.

1. "If 4 or more Health were restored" series:

I showed this one before but I modified it a bit. I also added one card because I'm indecisive about that as well.

Changes compared to before:

1. Threshold change from 5 to 4. 5 is too hard to trigger while 3 is too easy.
2. Names changed to "X's vigor"
3. Druid card effect changed to "summon a Treant"
4. Paladin card added. I need to choose between the Paladin and the Priest card but I don't know which is the most interesting.

2. Exodar series:

Aka "Give token-generating classes better tokens". I have doubts about balanced as well as flavor but making them cost 4 would make them unplayable.

Which is best ?

Well...Zence just made page 3 the page of death. (Nothing personal Zence, I still like your cards :P)

I'm just here lookin' at my cards, and trying to figure out how to balance Photokinesis...

Quote from MrUncreative >>

Unbound cross-class spells

---

Rapid Mage spells

 

Quote from Livienna >>

Okay here's another attempt!

and my old idea which I'm pretty sure is way too boring...

would love some feedback!!! :D

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

 

 

Quote from ScubaHelm >>

Any thoughts?

Quote from Zence >>

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Ok so I've limited my choices to 2 options. One of them was shown before, the other is brand new.

1. "If 4 or more Health were restored" series:

I showed this one before but I modified it a bit. I also added one card because I'm indecisive about that as well.

Changes compared to before:

1. Threshold change from 5 to 4. 5 is too hard to trigger while 3 is too easy.
2. Names changed to "X's vigor"
3. Druid card effect changed to "summon a Treant"
4. Paladin card added. I need to choose between the Paladin and the Priest card but I don't know which is the most interesting.

2. Exodar series:

Aka "Give token-generating classes better tokens". I have doubts about balanced as well as flavor but making them cost 4 would make them unplayable.

Which is best ?

 

 I really love the 1st set! It feels just right where it is honestly, and all the effects are good. Choosing between the 2, i'd say go with Pally. When you think about it, it packs some serious turnabout power and would feel right at home in any Control Pally. The priest one is good too, but with so many different ways for Anduin and Tyrande to draw cards, it feels a bit boring.

The 2nd set is also really unique, although I'd say balance wise its a bit harder. The first card is okay, but I dont like how you lose SHR synergy, meaning you'd have to run this card as a standalone, which is as bad as that new Legend that got released. Not to mention you lose that 1 HP buff theme that pally can have. The 2nd looks cool too, but its way too slow. Even though your HP is pretty basic as a Shaman, you would much rather summon 0/2 totems with nice effects on them than a blank 0/4 totem. The last one is also nice, but it upstages Justicar way too much. So basically this is a long way of saying go with the first set :p

Quote from Teknician >>

Quote from MrUncreative >>

Unbound cross-class spells

---

Rapid Mage spells

 

 The Unbound cards: Anger seems a little good— I know that Execute deals with any minion, but 3 damage seems a little much for the utility (especially drawing another); compare Backstab. I'd say 2 damage. Evolution is great, flavorful; while it might not be "unique" it's definitely very useful. You might want to make it (2) more though, because Evolve exists and that's 1 mana too.

The Rapid spells are all very well thought out, and they work well together. They even stand up on their own (except Rapid Flames).

Quote from Livienna >>

Okay here's another attempt!

and my old idea which I'm pretty sure is way too boring...

would love some feedback!!! :D

 Naga Sorceress is fine, mainly because it has an appreciable body for the cost anyway. I feel like the latter two are a little bit understatted, as they depend on your opponent not killing them to have any positive effect for you. I'm sure you could have 4/5 or 5/4 on the Seductress and 5/5 or 5/6 on Azshara.

You're right, the other cards are a bit boring... But that doesn't make them bad. They're quite good for what they do— I especially like that these are the classes you're giving card draw.

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

 

 

 For the first set, I really like them. They should read "If 4 or more health was restored" instead of "were". You could probably ditch the Priest card, because they already had Flash Heal which makes this a bit undercosted. It's also the least interesting side effect. You might want to just make all of them 2 mana.

The second set is a bit... Well it's already been done before. It's essentially Justicar Trueheart. Exodar Bodyguard is the Paladin upgrade except the recruits are consolidated into one body. Exodar Scimitar is literally the Rogue upgrade. While Exodar Totem is pretty much strictly better then the normal Shaman HP or even the upgrade, it's still different. Overall, I'd actually go with your first set of cards without the Priest one.

Quote from ScubaHelm >>

Any thoughts?

 Arcane Influencer: Really just a good card. Max. 9 damage so it's a flexible Flame Lance for what amounts to 1.5 mana. Astral Influencer should read "Battlecry: Gain a Mana Crystal this turn only for each spell in your hand." Aside from that, it's really good and could be an immense tempo swing card. Fel Influence: "Discard all spells in your hand and give your minions +1/+1 for each." It should really be like +2/+2 or even +3/+3 because discarding cards is really extreme. Then again, if you've only got minions this can be OP, but you could specify "Give your Demons +2/+2(or +3/+3)." Overall I really like these cards.

Y'all don't need to give me feedback, I've already submitted— too early I think, I regret submitting what and when I did :/