Yes it's definitely not as good as Mana Wyrm, there are more spells available than decent low cost overload. Playing it on the same turn as a Feral Spirit could be nice but I have a hard time seeing it as an effective turn one drop. Basically just a matter of is this better than Zombie Chow. In certain decks I'm sure it will be but not in most. I guess we'll see!
Rogue hasn't been the worst class since GVG launch...
I just can't get (outside of the obvious, they have no idea what they are doing) why would they put Rumbling Elemental in shaman.The class is probably the one with less usable class minions with battlecry, not to mention the stat distribution is horrible, how much time do they need to figure that a 2/6 for 4 is not playable.
No shit Fire Elemental is a good battlecry minion is the first thing that comes to mind same for Tuskarr Totemic.That's 2 Oh wow that's why the card is shaking the meta so much right?. Of course a 3/6 with that effect would be good but is not, so I dont really see the reason for your post. But thanks for the comment on a 5 days old post. I guess.
No shit Fire Elemental is a good battlecry minion is the first thing that comes to mind same for Tuskarr Totemic.That's 2 Oh wow that's why the card is shaking the meta so much right?. Of course a 3/6 with that effect would be good but is not, so I dont really see the reason for your post. But thanks for the comment on a 5 days old post. I guess.
Three class cards along with three neutrals. I never said that the card was good, just that shaman could trigger its effect reliably.
The comment before mine was 10 hours ago, which is the only reason I saw this post.
If Neptulon is a good card is up for debate,when was the last time you saw someone playing him?Again I dont understand why they picked shaman for this card there's already enough gimmicky shit that doesn't work in the class, couldn't they just make a good Discover card?.
I'm probably coming a bit salty in here but I'm a bit tired of Blizzard failing at shaman cards giving them a worst version of cards from another class and tired of the the people that defend them "if x happen and y happen etc,etc,etc".
It's been the same shit since BRM.Remember when Lava Shock and Fireguard were going to be broken, or Healing Wave kill aggro, or Totem Golem and The Mystcaller were OP, and everytime you tell someone they are not that great they call you a hater and that the card need to be tested (notable mention to the people that defended Charged Hammer you could see that card being a joke from a mile away).
I know a class has to be the worst, but when priest was Naxx came out and the class was saved, when noone played pally they did a good job and they save it with GVG, hell when combo druid was probably at his worst state (and I wasnt even bad) before TGT they got Living Roots and Darnassus Aspirant and the decks is top tier again.At worst those classes where the worst for what 6 months?It's been a year and they could't turn shaman into a mid-tier class.How hard is to make the same that they did with the other classes.
If Neptulon is a good card is up for debate,when was the last time you saw someone playing him?Again I dont understand why they picked shaman for this card there's already enough gimmicky shit that doesn't work in the class, couldn't they just make a good Discover card?.
I'm probably coming a bit salty in here but I'm a bit tired of Blizzard failing at shaman cards giving them a worst version of cards from another class and tired of the the people that defend them "if x happen and y happen etc,etc,etc".
It's been the same shit since BRM.Remember when Lava Shock and Fireguard were going to be broken, or Healing Wave kill aggro, or Totem Golem and The Mystcaller were OP, and everytime you tell someone they are not that great they call you a hater and that the card need to be tested (notable mention to the people that defended Charged Hammer you could see that card being a joke from a mile away).
I know a class has to be the worst, but when priest was Naxx came out and the class was saved, when noone played pally they did a good job and they save it with GVG, hell when combo druid was probably at his worst state (and I wasnt even bad) before TGT they got Living Roots and Darnassus Aspirant and the decks is top tier again.At worst those classes where the worst for what 6 months?It's been a year and they could't turn shaman into a mid-tier class.How hard is to make the same that they did with the other classes.
Edit:Man I wrote a lot.
Neptulon isn't bad, but the meta has to be damn slow for him to kind of work.
I told people these 3 new cards were trash tier, but they didn't want to believe me. Hell, I told people all those cards would be shit, but no one wants to hear it.
Scarab is good in control shaman. It does not seem intended but that is good that might mean it's not shit because blizzard likes to be scared when making OP cards for shaman but it's ok to do it with every other class. Anyways shaman has dr 3, 3 mana board clears, and 3 mana heal so scarab might actually be an auto include in every control shaman list.
Yept tested the cards. Shaman has gotten better by a bit but so has other decks. Shaman left behind again. Oh and rumbling elemental deck is just a worse tempo mage.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
My legendary count excluding adventure legendaries, dupes and old murk eye: 40
Yes it's definitely not as good as Mana Wyrm, there are more spells available than decent low cost overload. Playing it on the same turn as a Feral Spirit could be nice but I have a hard time seeing it as an effective turn one drop. Basically just a matter of is this better than Zombie Chow. In certain decks I'm sure it will be but not in most. I guess we'll see!
No shit Fire Elemental is a good battlecry minion is the first thing that comes to mind same for Tuskarr Totemic.That's 2 Oh wow that's why the card is shaking the meta so much right?.
Of course a 3/6 with that effect would be good but is not, so I dont really see the reason for your post.
But thanks for the comment on a 5 days old post.
I guess.
If Neptulon is a good card is up for debate,when was the last time you saw someone playing him?Again I dont understand why they picked shaman for this card there's already enough gimmicky shit that doesn't work in the class, couldn't they just make a good Discover card?.
I'm probably coming a bit salty in here but I'm a bit tired of Blizzard failing at shaman cards giving them a worst version of cards from another class and tired of the the people that defend them "if x happen and y happen etc,etc,etc".
It's been the same shit since BRM.Remember when Lava Shock and Fireguard were going to be broken, or Healing Wave kill aggro, or Totem Golem and The Mystcaller were OP, and everytime you tell someone they are not that great they call you a hater and that the card need to be tested (notable mention to the people that defended Charged Hammer you could see that card being a joke from a mile away).
I know a class has to be the worst, but when priest was Naxx came out and the class was saved, when noone played pally they did a good job and they save it with GVG, hell when combo druid was probably at his worst state (and I wasnt even bad) before TGT they got Living Roots and Darnassus Aspirant and the decks is top tier again.At worst those classes where the worst for what 6 months?It's been a year and they could't turn shaman into a mid-tier class.How hard is to make the same that they did with the other classes.
Edit:Man I wrote a lot.
Scarab is good in control shaman. It does not seem intended but that is good that might mean it's not shit because blizzard likes to be scared when making OP cards for shaman but it's ok to do it with every other class. Anyways shaman has dr 3, 3 mana board clears, and 3 mana heal so scarab might actually be an auto include in every control shaman list.
Yept tested the cards. Shaman has gotten better by a bit but so has other decks. Shaman left behind again. Oh and rumbling elemental deck is just a worse tempo mage.
My legendary count excluding adventure legendaries, dupes and old murk eye: 40
$$$ spent on this game: 0
Check out my card collection: http://www.hearthpwn.com/members/MCFUser175154/collection
scarab is ok and finley is not bad either
and if you like to smorc face, trogg is there for you
the rest of us who prefer playing control have to suck it up, as usual