• 0

    posted a message on Should Blizzard add more deck slots with the release of GvG?

    Technology is not there yet.

    Posted in: General Discussion
  • 0

    posted a message on New card - Gnomish Experimenter discussion
    Quote from Ballinglikeafool »
    Quote from lynxbird »
    Quote from totallyabiscuit »
    Quote from lynxbird »

    You forget that in 29 games you will get key card one turn earlier, and in only 1 game it will turn key card into chicken. So you loose 1 game 90% but 29 games win 53%. On average you win more. Profit.

    Your logic is flawed.  A 3 mana 3/2 draw a card isnt good enough to win you the game 3% more of the time.  Also, you can have more than 1 important card.  There is a rather new mage OTK mage deck on ladder.  It runs double sorcerers apprentice and ancient mage.  If you burn any of those cards, or alextrasa, you are in deep trouble.  This means that every game you play him, you have a 10% chance to lose.  This means that it decreases you win percentage by about 8%.  This is just one example but there are a lot of decks with multiple very important cards that need to be drawn before turn 30.

    I'm not saying this card is must for every possible deck. I just say it is okey card.

    You must look best decks for card to see is it good, not worst decks. Your current logic is like "Ragnaros is weak card, because if you put him in zoo you will more loose. He can be dead card in zoo."

    Of course there are decks where this card would be bad, as any other card in this game.

    Where is it good though? What decks rely on spell-based combo enough to warrant this, and also don't have better options already.

    On the first thought, midrange hunter can use this.

    1) Lot of spells.

    2) Chicken/beast synergy.

    3) You can leave any minion on bottom of deck and still win a game.

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • 1

    posted a message on New card - Gnomish Experimenter discussion
    Quote from totallyabiscuit »
    Quote from lynxbird »

    You forget that in 29 games you will get key card one turn earlier, and in only 1 game it will turn key card into chicken. So you loose 1 game 90% but 29 games win 53%. On average you win more. Profit.

    Your logic is flawed.  A 3 mana 3/2 draw a card isnt good enough to win you the game 3% more of the time.  Also, you can have more than 1 important card.  There is a rather new mage OTK mage deck on ladder.  It runs double sorcerers apprentice and ancient mage.  If you burn any of those cards, or alextrasa, you are in deep trouble.  This means that every game you play him, you have a 10% chance to lose.  This means that it decreases you win percentage by about 8%.  This is just one example but there are a lot of decks with multiple very important cards that need to be drawn before turn 30.

    I'm not saying this card is must for every possible deck. I just say it is okey card.

    You must look best decks for card to see is it good, not worst decks. Your current logic is like "Ragnaros is weak card, because if you put him in zoo you will more loose. He can be dead card in zoo."

    Of course there are decks where this card would be bad, as any other card in this game.

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • 1

    posted a message on New Card - Feign Death
    Quote from Thotor »

    It doesn't matter if this card is OP or not. The simple fact that is the same mana cost as reincarnate with better effect and no drawback is inconceivable.

    Wrong. Reincarnate can work with any minion as:

    -healing

    -giving divine shield back

    -removing silence

    -removing bad buffs

    -knife jungler activator

    -giving second charge.... etc..

    This one work only on minions with deathrattle and don't do anything from above. Maybe even worse card than Reincarnate.

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • 1

    posted a message on New card - Gnomish Experimenter discussion

    You forget that in 29 games you will get key card one turn earlier, and in only 1 game it will turn key card into chicken. So you loose 1 game 90% but 29 games win 53%. On average you win more. Profit.

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • 0

    posted a message on New Card - Druid of the Fang

    Venture Co Mercenary have huge drawback, against paladin he can even loose a game after peacekeeper. I like this card more than yeti.

     

    This card is more like giants in handlock, you need to set situation to get huge body for not lot mana. This card would be playable with few taunt givers.

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • 0

    posted a message on New card - Gnomish Experimenter discussion

    Just imagine that card would be at a bottom of deck and would never be drawn. Tracking discard 2 cards, and it's still good, because those 2 cards would stay at a bottom of deck.

    So this card is 3/2 draw a spell or free chicken card. That Giant would anyway stay at a bottom of deck and would never see play.

    This card is very good in aggro decks.

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • To post a comment, please login or register a new account.