It seems like warrior is top 1. For warrior, grommash is definitely a must have in control as a win con and removal. I still believe Iron juggernaut is overestimated as I said in my previous post.
In arena, it's too random to get value not mentioning you may have better choices over it. In constructed, in most of your matches against non-draw heavy opponent, it's most likely a worst boulderfist ogre that's way too slow for all kinds of warrior. Now that soulfire and auctioneer are nerfed, I don't think top draw heavy decks such as zoo, handlock and miracle will be played a lot in the meta anymore. Freeze mage relies on heavy draws but warrior has had no problem dealing with it. Even for mechbrew fun decks, being a legendary really hurts its consistency.
IMO I would give grommash 8 out of 10, juggernaut 3 out of 10. That's 2.75 out of 5.
Main problem I'm finding is most classes have 1 good legend and 1 bad legend so I ended up with 6 classes having a 3
I thought about making a second poll that would allow everyone to rate each class legendary but not sure people would make it through rating 18 cards. Some folks would rate maybe some cards but not all so not sure results would be reliable. There's probably some of that in the Class poll already.
After 185 votes, the order seems to be largely the same:
Warrior
Warlock
Druid
Priest
Rogue
Hunter
Paladin
Shaman
Mage
I find it odd to see that hunter is above paladin, I doubt hunter's new class legendary can beat Tirion, Bolvar seems to be bad, but so was king Krush. This is of course people's opinions, but really?
After 185 votes, the order seems to be largely the same:
Warrior
Warlock
Druid
Priest
Rogue
Hunter
Paladin
Shaman
Mage
I find it odd to see that hunter is above paladin, I doubt hunter's new class legendary can beat Tirion, Bolvar seems to be bad, but so was king Krush. This is of course people's opinions, but really?
We've had another 20ish votes. Hunter is just slightly above Paladin. They are basically equivalent.
We've had another 20ish votes. Hunter is just slightly above Paladin. They are basically equivalent.
Yeah I see now, will be interesting to see if Gazhrilla is actually good in control hunter.
I'm a bit concerned he'll be like Kel'thuzad. Either silenced immediately or otherwise removed because leaving him on the board for any amount of time is trouble.
I wonder if they make an exception and buff the Lame Leviathan. Some class legendaries are not great, but I can't picture anyone including that thing in a deck.
As for the vote, pretty much my impression as well. Mage is still way too high, Antonidas doesn't make up for one of the worst cards I have ever seen.
Why druid so high? I play druid and I think those cards sucked.
We needed removal, got a bad card, the legendary is kind of cool but it's just a big body and I'd go with something that has a stronger/immediate effect. The other ones... the most interesting two have symmetric effect... bah I hope I'm wrong.
I voted warrior, priest, mage and hunter as best overall.
Looking back at this after several weeks of GvG, I'd have to say that Warlock, Paladin, Warrior and Druid are about even as most class decks contain one of the class legendaries. Some Mage decks might carry Antonidas. But the rest of the classes only rarely carry a class legendary.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
It seems like warrior is top 1. For warrior, grommash is definitely a must have in control as a win con and removal. I still believe Iron juggernaut is overestimated as I said in my previous post.
In arena, it's too random to get value not mentioning you may have better choices over it. In constructed, in most of your matches against non-draw heavy opponent, it's most likely a worst boulderfist ogre that's way too slow for all kinds of warrior. Now that soulfire and auctioneer are nerfed, I don't think top draw heavy decks such as zoo, handlock and miracle will be played a lot in the meta anymore. Freeze mage relies on heavy draws but warrior has had no problem dealing with it. Even for mechbrew fun decks, being a legendary really hurts its consistency.
IMO I would give grommash 8 out of 10, juggernaut 3 out of 10. That's 2.75 out of 5.
Yeah that's the idea! Two or more mines in your deck and you just squeal every time you draw.
"Everyone! Get in here!"
Main problem I'm finding is most classes have 1 good legend and 1 bad legend so I ended up with 6 classes having a 3
After 185 votes, the order seems to be largely the same:
I thought about making a second poll that would allow everyone to rate each class legendary but not sure people would make it through rating 18 cards. Some folks would rate maybe some cards but not all so not sure results would be reliable. There's probably some of that in the Class poll already.
I find it odd to see that hunter is above paladin, I doubt hunter's new class legendary can beat Tirion, Bolvar seems to be bad, but so was king Krush. This is of course people's opinions, but really?
We've had another 20ish votes. Hunter is just slightly above Paladin. They are basically equivalent.
Yeah I see now, will be interesting to see if Gazhrilla is actually good in control hunter.
I'm a bit concerned he'll be like Kel'thuzad. Either silenced immediately or otherwise removed because leaving him on the board for any amount of time is trouble.
I wonder if they make an exception and buff the Lame Leviathan. Some class legendaries are not great, but I can't picture anyone including that thing in a deck.
As for the vote, pretty much my impression as well. Mage is still way too high, Antonidas doesn't make up for one of the worst cards I have ever seen.
Why druid so high? I play druid and I think those cards sucked.
We needed removal, got a bad card, the legendary is kind of cool but it's just a big body and I'd go with something that has a stronger/immediate effect. The other ones... the most interesting two have symmetric effect... bah I hope I'm wrong.
I voted warrior, priest, mage and hunter as best overall.
Warrior
I don't play Rogue much. Why do you guys think these legendaries are good? What kind of Rogue deck is going to play Gallywix?
Signature !!!!
Looking back at this after several weeks of GvG, I'd have to say that Warlock, Paladin, Warrior and Druid are about even as most class decks contain one of the class legendaries. Some Mage decks might carry Antonidas. But the rest of the classes only rarely carry a class legendary.