Hearthpwn

So I was just playing against a C'Thun priest and killed his C'Thun expecting it to be reshuffled into his deck with Doomcaller and of course it was. He played another copy of it while C'Thun was still in his deck, but he ended up playing him 3 times total.  This was the first time I've seen it, but should it have added a 3rd copy if the second was in his deck? Does that technically not count as being revived?

It counts C'Thun as having died once, so regardless if a second C'Thun was shuffled into the deck, a second Doomcaller would check "Has C'Thun died this game?" to which the answer is "Yes", and then shuffle a third copy into the deck. The Doomcaller only checks if C'Thun has died, not if it's been revived.

If he had a C'Thun that died that game, Doomcaller will shuffle a another into his deck regardless of what else is in the deck.

http://www.hearthpwn.com/forums/hearthstone-general/general-discussion/137758-multiple-doomcallers-creating-more-copies-of-cthun