A couple quick comments while I’m on my lunch break!
- Lifesteal didn’t exist in Standard, so it’s inclusion in Forte is odd. Actually, a Keyword that includes another Keyword is odd. But I do like the idea of situational Taunt.
- Bolster I worry could ramp out of control real quick. But I like the synergy with your Forte. Just be careful with your minions to not give them too much health.
- Cutting Words - Hearthstone doesn’t use -1 Health effects. And if it did... this is a 0 cost Arcane Explosion that also reduces their Attack temporarily. Too good for 0 mana.
- Other cards are fine, except...
- Scorpio. So he casts a free Avenging Wrath (6 mana) as a Battlecry. Which gets a LOT stronger the more minions you have, AND your hero power can preemptively boost it? This is C’Thun without the build around cards. This is an immensely powerful effect, and I don’t quite see how having stout minions leads to good barding. I’d consider toning down his Health if not giving him a new effect altogether.
IMO, if you are going for stout minions and taunt, you probably won’t have much in the way of removal or fast minions. It’s an intriguing set so far, I’d like to see what else you can do with it.
- I wasn't very clear about the premise of the competition being that the custom class existed in HS from the beginning, so keyword anachronisms were frowned upon, I did remove Lifesteal from the keyword. I think the keyword is strong enough without it, given buffing (esp. Health) is a core class competency.
- Cutting Words is now just "-1 Attack". It was never intended to kill minions that had 1 hp, but trying to explain that made the card text messy and un-HS-like, and a Basic 0 mana cantrip shouldn't be complicated anyway.
- I think you overestimate Scorpio. Sure, if everything has gone according to plan and you have board dominance it is a very powerful effect. But in most cases it will just be a decent board swing at best, or an unplayable understated minion at worse.
This is absolutely a class all about board control. As I say on the submission, it will have no weapons and very few direct damage effects. The fantasy behind it is that Silas is something of a pacifist. He will strengthen his companions and taunt his enemies (or on occasion mesmerise them), but he has no interest in keeping Charger or Rushers around.
You cannot find an innkeeper anywhere on Azeroth that hasn't heard tale of Silas Mellowsong, or that wouldn't pay a small fortune to have him perform in their tavern for even one night. His songs are known to lift the spirit, and move even the most calloused of souls to tears. But life on the road is not all fun and games. While he detests violence, if forced to fight Silas' performing gift can be used to strike fear and demoralise, with enemies been driven to the edge of insanity with the utterance of but a few verses.
Borrowing from classic themes of the Bard in a variety of fantasy mediums, the class has no direct damage spells or weapons, but rather excels in building a resilient board presence and efficiently manipulating the stats of minions on the board throughout the game.
The most basic tool in the Bard's arsenal is the Hero Power, giving a minion +2 Health for 2 mana. This allows the Bard to establish a more resilient early board presence than other classes, and synergises with many of the Bard's spells that benefit, or otherwise interact with, the highest Health minion on the board.
The importance of minion Health in the Bard's game plan is further bolstered by the class-specific keyword: Forte.
An artist as talented as Silas travels only with the best, and the best shine under the spotlight. Any minion with the Forte keyword has Taunt and Lifesteal when its health is the highest on the board. This makes for an extremely dynamic board: Trading into a minion with Forte active will more than likely cause it to lose Taunt and Lifesteal, but it may very well cause another Forte minion to gain it.
Example Cards
As the above cards make clear, the Bard is geared towards board control and midrange strategies. While all out aggression is possible, capitalising on early board superiority to beat the enemy into submission quickly, the class in at its best when it is ahead on board, and has a variety of tools allowing it to do just that.
Cutting Words is a Basic card, allowing the Bard to set up beneficial trades for a price that cannot be beat.
Young Troubadour is the perfect target for a turn-2 hero power, more than likely transforming it into a 2/3 with Taunt and Lifesteal.
Technicolor Dreamcoat exemplifies the Bard's ability to capitalise on being ahead on board. Quite inefficient as a +2/+2 buff, it becomes exceptional if it also gives the target Taunt and Lifesteal.
Persuasive Argument is another example of tools available to the Bard: Secrets. Costed at 2 mana, Bard Secrets act similarly to the rest of the class' arsenal, redirecting or stopping attacks and manipulating stats on board, rather than dealing direct damage.
Scorpio the Inimitable, on the other hand, (the Bard's Classic legendary) is one of the few Bard cards that deals direct damage, converting board presence into a finishing blow.
I hope you enjoyed this preliminary look at the Bard, and I hope I'll get a chance to showcase more of it in the future. As a final note, I'm not very happy with the class art assets borrowed from HearthCards.net (the pink might be a bit too bright for my taste), and should my submission pass to the next phase I'll more than likely create custom ones from scratch.
You cannot find an innkeeper anywhere on Azeroth that hasn't heard tale of Silas Mellowsong, or that wouldn't pay a small fortune to have him perform in their tavern for even one night. His songs are known to lift the spirit, and move even the most calloused of souls to tears. But life on the road is not all fun and games. While he detests violence, if forced to fight Silas' performing gift can be used to strike fear and demoralise, with enemies been driven to the edge of insanity with the utterance of but a few verses.
Borrowing from classic themes of the Bard in a variety of fantasy mediums, the class has no direct damage spells or weapons, but rather excels in building a resilient board presence and efficiently manipulating the stats of minions on the board throughout the game.
The most basic tool in the Bard's arsenal is the Hero Power, giving a minion +2 Health for 2 mana. This allows the Bard to establish a more resilient early board presence than other classes, and synergises with many of the Bard's spells that benefit, or otherwise interact with, the highest Health minion on the board.
The importance of minion Health in the Bard's game plan is further bolstered by the class-specific keyword: Forte.
An artist as talented as Silas travels only with the best, and the best shine under the spotlight. Any minion with the Forte keyword has Taunt when its health is the highest on the board. This makes for an extremely dynamic board: Trading into a minion with Forte active will more than likely cause it to lose Taunt, but it may very well cause another Forte minion to gain it.
Example Cards
As the above cards make clear, the Bard is geared towards board control and midrange strategies. While all out aggression is possible, capitalising on early board superiority to beat the enemy into submission quickly, the class in at its best when it is ahead on board, and has a variety of tools allowing it to do just that.
Cutting Words is a Basic card, allowing the Bard to set up beneficial trades for a price that cannot be beat.
Young Troubadour is the perfect target for a turn-2 hero power, more than likely transforming it into a 2/3 with Taunt.
Technicolor Dreamcoat exemplifies the Bard's ability to capitalise on being ahead on board. Quite inefficient as a +2/+2 buff, it becomes exceptional if it also gives the target Taunt.
Persuasive Argument is another example of tools available to the Bard: Secrets. Costed at 2 mana, Bard Secrets act similarly to the rest of the class' arsenal, redirecting or stopping attacks and manipulating stats on board, rather than dealing direct damage.
Scorpio the Inimitable, on the other hand, (the Bard's Classic legendary) is one of the few Bard cards that deals direct damage, converting board presence into a finishing blow.
I hope you enjoyed this preliminary look at the Bard, and I hope I'll get a chance to showcase more of it in the future. As a final note, I'm not very happy with the class art assets borrowed from HearthCards.net (the pink might be a bit too bright for my taste), and should my submission pass to the next phase I'll more than likely create custom ones from scratch.
"set" implies that you affect the number of crystals, not their status, meaning if you were at 10/10 and you play this you'll be at 1/5 (much better that you play a 4 mana card beforehand ofc)
you know what? this wouldn't be half bad in a tempo shudderwock deck (without Grumble).
Sure, it would delay Shudderwock by a few turns, but then you play it and you get 3-4 6/6s on the board (plus freezes, hagatha aoe etc) and good luck to your opponent answering it with 6 mana available.
At first look an amazing card, but for me there are 2 important questions on how it will work, which will influence how good it will be in practice.
1. Carnivorous Cube interaction: In the video Cube is mentioned as one of the cards this synergises with. It could be an off-hand comment, or it might mean that the battlecry indeed copies a Cube full with whatever that Cube had eaten. Some people mention that this isn't how it works with things such as Seeping Oozeling or when you Cube a Cube, but a. the Oozeling copies the effect of a Cube inside the deck, that has eaten nothing and b. The Cubes coming out of the Cube are copies, and copies in HS are generated as the "vanilla" version of the minion.
On a technical level, all minion effects in HS are buffs. If the Undatakah when summoned references a list of the actual deathrattles played this game, rather than a "vanilla" copy of the effect, the Cube it copies will be full.
2. Will the deathrattle have to have been activated for Undatakah to copy it? Meaning, if the minion was silenced before it died, does it count as "a friendly minion that has died this game"?
I'm inclined to think no, but the text leaves it up for debate, as it doesn't say "friendly Deathrattle minions".
0
- I wasn't very clear about the premise of the competition being that the custom class existed in HS from the beginning, so keyword anachronisms were frowned upon, I did remove Lifesteal from the keyword. I think the keyword is strong enough without it, given buffing (esp. Health) is a core class competency.
- Cutting Words is now just "-1 Attack". It was never intended to kill minions that had 1 hp, but trying to explain that made the card text messy and un-HS-like, and a Basic 0 mana cantrip shouldn't be complicated anyway.
- I think you overestimate Scorpio. Sure, if everything has gone according to plan and you have board dominance it is a very powerful effect. But in most cases it will just be a decent board swing at best, or an unplayable understated minion at worse.
This is absolutely a class all about board control. As I say on the submission, it will have no weapons and very few direct damage effects. The fantasy behind it is that Silas is something of a pacifist. He will strengthen his companions and taunt his enemies (or on occasion mesmerise them), but he has no interest in keeping Charger or Rushers around.
0
All feedback welcome.
6
The Bard
You cannot find an innkeeper anywhere on Azeroth that hasn't heard tale of Silas Mellowsong, or that wouldn't pay a small fortune to have him perform in their tavern for even one night. His songs are known to lift the spirit, and move even the most calloused of souls to tears. But life on the road is not all fun and games. While he detests violence, if forced to fight Silas' performing gift can be used to strike fear and demoralise, with enemies been driven to the edge of insanity with the utterance of but a few verses.
Borrowing from classic themes of the Bard in a variety of fantasy mediums, the class has no direct damage spells or weapons, but rather excels in building a resilient board presence and efficiently manipulating the stats of minions on the board throughout the game.
The most basic tool in the Bard's arsenal is the Hero Power, giving a minion +2 Health for 2 mana. This allows the Bard to establish a more resilient early board presence than other classes, and synergises with many of the Bard's spells that benefit, or otherwise interact with, the highest Health minion on the board.
The importance of minion Health in the Bard's game plan is further bolstered by the class-specific keyword: Forte.
An artist as talented as Silas travels only with the best, and the best shine under the spotlight. Any minion with the Forte keyword has Taunt when its health is the highest on the board. This makes for an extremely dynamic board: Trading into a minion with Forte active will more than likely cause it to lose Taunt, but it may very well cause another Forte minion to gain it.
Example Cards
As the above cards make clear, the Bard is geared towards board control and midrange strategies. While all out aggression is possible, capitalising on early board superiority to beat the enemy into submission quickly, the class in at its best when it is ahead on board, and has a variety of tools allowing it to do just that.
Cutting Words is a Basic card, allowing the Bard to set up beneficial trades for a price that cannot be beat.
Young Troubadour is the perfect target for a turn-2 hero power, more than likely transforming it into a 2/3 with Taunt.
Technicolor Dreamcoat exemplifies the Bard's ability to capitalise on being ahead on board. Quite inefficient as a +2/+2 buff, it becomes exceptional if it also gives the target Taunt.
Persuasive Argument is another example of tools available to the Bard: Secrets. Costed at 2 mana, Bard Secrets act similarly to the rest of the class' arsenal, redirecting or stopping attacks and manipulating stats on board, rather than dealing direct damage.
Scorpio the Inimitable, on the other hand, (the Bard's Classic legendary) is one of the few Bard cards that deals direct damage, converting board presence into a finishing blow.
I hope you enjoyed this preliminary look at the Bard, and I hope I'll get a chance to showcase more of it in the future. As a final note, I'm not very happy with the class art assets borrowed from HearthCards.net (the pink might be a bit too bright for my taste), and should my submission pass to the next phase I'll more than likely create custom ones from scratch.
1
Puns are the lowest form of wit, but I stand by this idea :P
2
.
"Get it? Three's a crowd, and the fifth wheel. Mwahahaha!"
0
DrNoOne#2533EUTrade only, you show the quest, I go first0
Battletag: DrNoOne #2533Region: EUTrade only?: Yes, you go first.1
Dragonhawks, because indiscriminate flamethrowing works every time.
0
Opened 67 packs, got Akali, the Rhino, Hir'eek, the Bat,Gral, the Shark and Zul'jin
Anyone knows, now that I have those 3 loa, is there a chance I'll get one of them as my free one from logging in at release?
0
Third month in a row, second time with DeathRecruit Hunter.
This is my list:
1
MCT is our bulwark against all the fucking smorc swarming decks, leave it alone.
0
"set" implies that you affect the number of crystals, not their status, meaning if you were at 10/10 and you play this you'll be at 1/5 (much better that you play a 4 mana card beforehand ofc)
2
you know what? this wouldn't be half bad in a tempo shudderwock deck (without Grumble).
Sure, it would delay Shudderwock by a few turns, but then you play it and you get 3-4 6/6s on the board (plus freezes, hagatha aoe etc) and good luck to your opponent answering it with 6 mana available.
0
Also Ancestral Call and Big Bad Voodoo. I really don't know, we either have to ask devs for clarification or wait for it to be playtested...
0
At first look an amazing card, but for me there are 2 important questions on how it will work, which will influence how good it will be in practice.
1. Carnivorous Cube interaction: In the video Cube is mentioned as one of the cards this synergises with. It could be an off-hand comment, or it might mean that the battlecry indeed copies a Cube full with whatever that Cube had eaten. Some people mention that this isn't how it works with things such as Seeping Oozeling or when you Cube a Cube, but a. the Oozeling copies the effect of a Cube inside the deck, that has eaten nothing and b. The Cubes coming out of the Cube are copies, and copies in HS are generated as the "vanilla" version of the minion.
On a technical level, all minion effects in HS are buffs. If the Undatakah when summoned references a list of the actual deathrattles played this game, rather than a "vanilla" copy of the effect, the Cube it copies will be full.
2. Will the deathrattle have to have been activated for Undatakah to copy it? Meaning, if the minion was silenced before it died, does it count as "a friendly minion that has died this game"?
I'm inclined to think no, but the text leaves it up for debate, as it doesn't say "friendly Deathrattle minions".