Yeah, I thought my Sunwell Sorceress entry was solid, but it got buried under a bunch of highly upvoted spells and legendaries. No matter what happens there’s gonna be a bunch of disappointed people because certain ones didn’t read the rules. But on top of that the ‘rule’ that it had to be a buildable unit or building from the main 4 races wasn’t exactly enforced.
A better link would have helped. I was a big fan of WC3 back in the day, so it was clear to me what the intention was. I feel bad for the Pig Farm guy. I like the idea of a Pig Farm card, but that's only for fel orcs and blackrock orcs. The playable orcs only have burrows.
There’s gonna be a lot if invalid entries this week... too many people making spells or legendary minions.
the top voted entries on page 2 are spells and there's also a hero card with a bunch of upvotes. Pretty sure my Lazy Peon is going to get lost in the clutter.
Edit: It's way worse than I thought. I looked at current entries (68, posts 2-69) and by my unofficial judgement, 39 of 68 entries are valid, while the other 29 are breaking rules. Many rulebreakers are obvious: spells, legendary minions and hero cards. Other's are more subtle: minions based off of 1 time hero units, minions based on neutrals you can't recruit, minions that are based on unplayable factions from the campaigns, minions based on buildings that are only 1 offs or only part of the campaign mode.
I think this contest needed firmer rules from the get-go. I can't imagine you're actually going to disqualify people for making Pig Farm, Goldmine or Naga cards, but by the rules, they should be disqualified.
Two entries are kinda funny. Spellbreaker and Archmage. Both are already cards, with those exact names! The Spellbreaker isn't disqualifying by the rules... but it should kinda go without saying you can't reuse an existing card's name? Archmage is disqualified because you can't recruit multiple archmages, since it's a hero unit.
Does our submission have to be a minion? Tree of Life is a spell and an original wc3 night elf building. I think a lot of the buildings lend themselves to being spells over minions. Though some might make good minion cards. Thinking up Moon Well ideas....
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
⚙
Learn More
Cosmetics
Related Cards
Card Pools
✕
×
PopCard Settings
Click on the buttons to change the PopCard background.
Elements settings
Click on the button to hide or unhide popcard elements.
A better link would have helped. I was a big fan of WC3 back in the day, so it was clear to me what the intention was. I feel bad for the Pig Farm guy. I like the idea of a Pig Farm card, but that's only for fel orcs and blackrock orcs. The playable orcs only have burrows.
the top voted entries on page 2 are spells and there's also a hero card with a bunch of upvotes. Pretty sure my Lazy Peon is going to get lost in the clutter.
Edit: It's way worse than I thought. I looked at current entries (68, posts 2-69) and by my unofficial judgement, 39 of 68 entries are valid, while the other 29 are breaking rules. Many rulebreakers are obvious: spells, legendary minions and hero cards. Other's are more subtle: minions based off of 1 time hero units, minions based on neutrals you can't recruit, minions that are based on unplayable factions from the campaigns, minions based on buildings that are only 1 offs or only part of the campaign mode.
I think this contest needed firmer rules from the get-go. I can't imagine you're actually going to disqualify people for making Pig Farm, Goldmine or Naga cards, but by the rules, they should be disqualified.
Two entries are kinda funny. Spellbreaker and Archmage. Both are already cards, with those exact names! The Spellbreaker isn't disqualifying by the rules... but it should kinda go without saying you can't reuse an existing card's name? Archmage is disqualified because you can't recruit multiple archmages, since it's a hero unit.
Here's what I got, Lazy Peon is my favorite. Meat Wagon probably needs a different price or stats.
Does our submission have to be a minion? Tree of Life is a spell and an original wc3 night elf building. I think a lot of the buildings lend themselves to being spells over minions. Though some might make good minion cards. Thinking up Moon Well ideas....