Hearthpwn

"Here is the "base list" for every Shaman deck, in my opinion (and the interwebz - try to find a "serious" Shaman deck that doesn't have these!)"

Trump's F2P Shaman that hit Legendary doesn't run Squires and ran only 1 Defender of Argus. Personally, I have not run into many Squires during my ladder climbing, but I have also gotten only up to Rank 8 this season so I am not exactly a worldbeater. The Shaman I'm running also doesn't run either of these cards and I am personally glad for it (The Argus honestly didn't help me in many MUs).

The card draw would be when the effect resolves, not when it is first played. This would also help it by making the cycling delayed, preventing too much cycling during your turn.

Quote from Anteaterking »

Quote from CasmX »

Personally, I think if they'd just add the text, 'and draw a card' to the text of Eye for an Eye it'd be an okay secret to play with.

But then you would know which secret it was.

Make it so that it draws a card when activated, not played, and you wouldn't.

It seems somewhat odd, since it doesn't seem quite as death related/deathrattle-y as the others, and is pretty strong. What about something that gave your weapon Silence to counter Deathrattles? (IE Silence the minion before you attack)

Not too strong since Blessing of Might probably outclasses it, but Avenge + Noble Sacrifice does seem like a fun combo and it could be useful in Arena.