I really expected to see him in the final four, if not further.
I guess it depends on the motivation for voting.
I'd say a lot of people voting might be voting for the character and not necessarily the Hearthstone card in this one.
I was pretty fascinated with her as a character even back before she got redesigned in WoW: and I mean... for anyone who doesn't remember, she used to look like this:
So, you know... it's not always about the sexy pixels.
I tried to make my choice strictly on the cards themselves. I voted for Sylvanas because to this day it is my favorite card art. Plus the effect can be fun - had some good times wit her in deathrattle hunter meme decks.