please give me a moment to review information, there has been a dispute and I was also having difficulty getting internet back. Ill have a resolve in 10-15min
I have reached a Resolve from the information presented, Joidivir is in the right by reporting an illigally used card not presented in the original decklist of STAR.
For this I will allow Joidivir a chance to play for first, im advancing you in the tournament and I need you to contact Logical#1916 for your finals Matches.
This dispute is has slowed our tourny to a stand still but because this is the finals, I need you guys to play your matches by midnight tonight. If they are not played NO ONE WILL BE FIRST. so this is important.
Be good sports gents, this is a good example where screen shots help a whole lot in decision making. Get your matches done and someone gets paid. Ill keep checking back for results.
Ok. I accept, I had an illigal card. But it wasnt intentional.
I had in my mind that, I have that card in sideboard. After all, before the tournament started, I had to submit my sideboard at last moment. Admin knows that.
And this was the only card, so I wasnt cheating at all. I won first game vs Joidivir very fairly 1-0.
id good with a rematch, continue or give you a free first match. Im good with either, obviously some preferred then others :) just waiting to here back.
Close match, he won games 1 & 3, I won 2, 4 & 5. On game one I used the deck with 2 subbed in misdirection's from the previous match before him and he won. He told me I couldnt use that, which I was unaware of & I used my orginal deck submission with no subs for game 2-5. Agreed at 2-2 to play the last match for winner. Had a lot of fun would love to play in next tournament. Everyone was very friendly!
please give me a moment to review information, there has been a dispute and I was also having difficulty getting internet back. Ill have a resolve in 10-15min
I have submitted decklist and sideboard.
I have reached a Resolve from the information presented, Joidivir is in the right by reporting an illigally used card not presented in the original decklist of STAR.
For this I will allow Joidivir a chance to play for first, im advancing you in the tournament and I need you to contact Logical#1916 for your finals Matches.
This dispute is has slowed our tourny to a stand still but because this is the finals, I need you guys to play your matches by midnight tonight. If they are not played NO ONE WILL BE FIRST. so this is important.
Be good sports gents, this is a good example where screen shots help a whole lot in decision making. Get your matches done and someone gets paid. Ill keep checking back for results.
playing now.
Ok. I accept, I had an illigal card. But it wasnt intentional.
I had in my mind that, I have that card in sideboard. After all, before the tournament started, I had to submit my sideboard at last moment. Admin knows that.
And this was the only card, so I wasnt cheating at all. I won first game vs Joidivir very fairly 1-0.
We didnt play second game. Winner is Joidivir.
Playing LogicaL atm, he isn't following the rules either...
2. You may swap cards out for your pre listed side board after your initial match, YOU CAN NOT DO IT BEFORE THEN.
http://www.iforce.co.nz/View.aspx?i=tzapfsin.hlf.png
Misdirection is in his sideboard...he's using it in the first game
id good with a rematch, continue or give you a free first match. Im good with either, obviously some preferred then others :) just waiting to here back.
We ended up just playing that one out...I won that one and the 3rd match. He won games 2,4 and 5
Close match, he won games 1 & 3, I won 2, 4 & 5. On game one I used the deck with 2 subbed in misdirection's from the previous match before him and he won. He told me I couldnt use that, which I was unaware of & I used my orginal deck submission with no subs for game 2-5. Agreed at 2-2 to play the last match for winner. Had a lot of fun would love to play in next tournament. Everyone was very friendly!
http://imgur.com/PHtEV4u
http://imgur.com/wtsklXL
http://imgur.com/OtqWl81
http://imgur.com/E8u5Yxe
Im glad you guys came to a resolve, congrats to Logical on his First place win! find the full results here http://challonge.com/OasisHearth