Hearthpwn

All these expansions seem really well done. I'm kinda sad i diden't enter during the first phase.

So this rating will be depending on how good they are compared to each other.

Nobravery

Brightwing seems busted, Trustworthy Coworker has a typo. Should be has been and not is. Living Meteor could almost just be a 4 mana 6/6 that requires you to deal 6 to one of your minions, since it will rarely be used as removal. And the theme is a bit too goofy for my tastes. Sensei of Chaos seems pretty cool tho.

Rating 1/5

RazorofArtorius

Voodoo seems like a great mechanic, and the troll theme was pretty cool. Trapologist and Legbas are my favorites, since they seem like really cool, simple and viable cards. Totemic Hammer and Gurubashi Warmage seems rather decent too. Hakkar's Fanatic is just a worse version of the GvG 2 mana 3/2 windfury.

Rating 4/5

Demonxy85

The void orb mechanic seems really clunkly. And how will you choose the amount when you have 8-10 void orbs? The Ui would go crazy. Besides that, your void orb cards are really well made, Leyarara is pretty cool. Maximillian seems really bad. As you would likely only draw 1 card. Icaria seems really clunkly and slow too.

Rating 2/5

Livienna

I like the winter theme, but the Chill mechanic seems way undervalued. If you hit 2 minions with your mage 3 drop, you ensure that these minions WILL die during the next 2/3 turns. It also seems like you tacked Elusive on your minions for no good reason. Unless i just don't understand the lore. Tyrande is also hand Attack, which is a big nono. The rest of the cards are pretty decent.

Rating 3/5

I think therefore i am

Latin classes finally paid off.

Your mechanics are really good, the theme is really good. And all the cards are pretty good. Although i don't find any outstanding.

Rating 4/5

SnorlaxBr

The theme is really... Hearthstoneish. Which is good i guess. Exhibit is Battlecry. Just restricting you from playing bad cards. Your cards seem pretty allright. Although Tained Claws and Master Demongolist seem great.

Rating 3/5

ShadowsofSensei

Great theme. Echo is a really cool mechanic, that i could see find it's way into the game. Forget-me-not is outstanding. Dragonguard Mallet seem really weird. The rest are okay to decent.

Rating 4/5

thepowrofcheese

Decent mechanic. Good theme, and you have the best cards overall with Terrorize, Blood Moon and Dreadlord Insurgent. The rest cards are also pretty good.

Rating 5/5

ThisOtherGuyTox

Allright theme. Intimidate is slightly unfun, although i can't really see how it turned out, since none of the cards feature the mechanic. Empower is what Inspire should've been. Guarenteed, which makes it good almost always, but not able to win you the game if your opponent diden't pack enough removals. A Moment of Silence, Iskar and Forest Frenzy are really great cards. Spirit of the Badger is kinda boring, and almost just a worse Heroic Strike. The rest are good too.

Rating 4/5 (Theme and Intimidate drags it down a lot.)

Broeck1

The best theme by quite a far shot. The Alliance and Horde faction thingy is also outstanding. Your faction mechanics are also really really good, and encourages to think your turn through. Your cards are not as great. Going from Mediocre to good. The mechanic and theme flavor makes this my favorite expansion.

Rating 5/5

Due to what i just said, then i would think that powrofcheese, Brock1, Razorofartorius and either ShadowofSensei/ThisOtherGuyTox/Cogito_Ergo_Sum will advance.

I will probaly vote for all these guys.

I actually like the idea that all the contestants vote for everyone. More votes=more fun, and the result will be decided by the remaining of the community.

I'll follow up and vote for everyone too! I already had a hard time choosing which ones to vote for, so this seems like the easiest solution.

Quote from Bratatata >>

Wow, the amount of love, time and energy put in to all this is absolutely amazing. Well done all. I hope Blizz is paying attention.

The Vodoo theme seems Blizz like. The best thing I have seen so far. But good job all of you.

BRIGHTWING OOOOMMMMEEEEEGESSHHHHH SOOOO CUUTTEEEEEE!!! Voted!

Concept's good too.

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from Dat_boi_Eow >>

 

Demonxy85

The void orb mechanic seems really clunkly. And how will you choose the amount when you have 8-10 void orbs? The Ui would go crazy. Besides that, your void orb cards are really well made, Leyarara is pretty cool. Maximillian seems really bad. As you would likely only draw 1 card. Icaria seems really clunkly and slow too.

Rating 2/5

 

There's a picture inside a spoiler in the OP which can give you a rough idea on spending Void Orbs. In addition to that, Hunters tend to run a lot of Beasts, so I feel Maximillion would draw 2 or more card often enough to justify considering him. He was mostly intended to give Hunters card draw, something that the class heavily lacks at the moment.

Quote from Cogito_Ergo_Sum >>

Quote from Dat_boi_Eow >>

All these expansions seem really well done. I'm kinda sad i diden't enter during the first phase.

So this rating will be depending on how good they are compared to each other.

Nobravery

Brightwing seems busted, Trustworthy Coworker has a typo. Should be has been and not is. Living Meteor could almost just be a 4 mana 6/6 that requires you to deal 6 to one of your minions, since it will rarely be used as removal. And the theme is a bit too goofy for my tastes. Sensei of Chaos seems pretty cool tho.

Rating 1/5

RazorofArtorius

Voodoo seems like a great mechanic, and the troll theme was pretty cool. Trapologist and Legbas are my favorites, since they seem like really cool, simple and viable cards. Totemic Hammer and Gurubashi Warmage seems rather decent too. Hakkar's Fanatic is just a worse version of the GvG 2 mana 3/2 windfury.

Rating 4/5

Demonxy85

The void orb mechanic seems really clunkly. And how will you choose the amount when you have 8-10 void orbs? The Ui would go crazy. Besides that, your void orb cards are really well made, Leyarara is pretty cool. Maximillian seems really bad. As you would likely only draw 1 card. Icaria seems really clunkly and slow too.

Rating 2/5

Livienna

I like the winter theme, but the Chill mechanic seems way undervalued. If you hit 2 minions with your mage 3 drop, you ensure that these minions WILL die during the next 2/3 turns. It also seems like you tacked Elusive on your minions for no good reason. Unless i just don't understand the lore. Tyrande is also hand Attack, which is a big nono. The rest of the cards are pretty decent.

Rating 3/5

I think therefore i am

Latin classes finally paid off.

Your mechanics are really good, the theme is really good. And all the cards are pretty good. Although i don't find any outstanding.

Rating 4/5

SnorlaxBr

The theme is really... Hearthstoneish. Which is good i guess. Exhibit is Battlecry. Just restricting you from playing bad cards. Your cards seem pretty allright. Although Tained Claws and Master Demongolist seem great.

Rating 3/5

ShadowsofSensei

Great theme. Echo is a really cool mechanic, that i could see find it's way into the game. Forget-me-not is outstanding. Dragonguard Mallet seem really weird. The rest are okay to decent.

Rating 4/5

thepowrofcheese

Decent mechanic. Good theme, and you have the best cards overall with Terrorize, Blood Moon and Dreadlord Insurgent. The rest cards are also pretty good.

Rating 5/5

ThisOtherGuyTox

Allright theme. Intimidate is slightly unfun, although i can't really see how it turned out, since none of the cards feature the mechanic. Empower is what Inspire should've been. Guarenteed, which makes it good almost always, but not able to win you the game if your opponent diden't pack enough removals. A Moment of Silence, Iskar and Forest Frenzy are really great cards. Spirit of the Badger is kinda boring, and almost just a worse Heroic Strike. The rest are good too.

Rating 4/5 (Theme and Intimidate drags it down a lot.)

Broeck1

The best theme by quite a far shot. The Alliance and Horde faction thingy is also outstanding. Your faction mechanics are also really really good, and encourages to think your turn through. Your cards are not as great. Going from Mediocre to good. The mechanic and theme flavor makes this my favorite expansion.

Rating 5/5

Due to what i just said, then i would think that powrofcheese, Brock1, Razorofartorius and either ShadowofSensei/ThisOtherGuyTox/Cogito_Ergo_Sum will advance.

I will probably vote for all these guys.

Thank you for taking the time to look at everyone's expansion and reviewing them. It means a lot!

And since your Latin classes payed off, surely your History classes will pay off because you totally know the significance of "Cogito ergo sum" right? ;)

Okay, so I need to make my cards more "outstanding". What you mean by that? I was more or less focusing more on the synergies of the cards rather than individual ones.

Voodoo mechanic is sweet

23 minutes left? Time to make a prediction!

Everything considered, including my own judgement, earlier stages, and this forums comments. I'd argue these four will advance.

1. Razor

2. thepowrofcheese

3. Broeck1

4. Cogito

And the order is irrelevant. Because i have a hard time judging who makes it on top.

This isen't saying that any other expansion is bad. All of them are AMAZING. Excluding my own. But these seems to do the best in the polls and have recieved the best feedback, and does great all around both in card quality and theme and mechanic quality.

Number Seven? 

Guess better luck next time. Eh?

Congratz to the our 4 finalists. You guys really deserved it!

I'm feeling a bit down over the fact that i diden't make it. But also slightly reliefed that it's over. I will obviously continue to review every single thing you 4 put out during the next discussion phase.

:D