Hearthpwn

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Daybreaks >>

I forgot about the whole discover with Priest. Tht is why I originally modeled it after Kabal Chemist as neutral but I changed it later. Thanks for the heads up.

Just a suggestion, use Quote instead of Reply, when u want to reply to someone's post around here. It copies the post ur replying to into your response and makes for a more clear string of discussion. If u just use Reply it will get lost quickly.

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

This might be the best steed in the history of steeds, maybe ever

Its missing mana cost. Also im not too sure about the wording, but mby it should be Greater Spellstone. Also the name isnt too exciting for a legendary minion.

Quote from Shatterstar1998 >>

Repost my cards:

Unidentified Strike is the Rogue version of the Unidentified spells part. All four tend to be close to power level than the others UI parts for easier to balance.

Dark Calling is intended to be a better version of Gather Your Party at the cost of a card in your hand. Good for Control Warlock as they have big minions to play like Giants or big Demons.

Token:

Razorpetal, Kobold Geomancer.

The effects seem fine, tho mby u want to have combo on all of them, to keep consistency. I get that on the "lesser" ones u probably meant to make them stronger by not forcing the combo on em, but dunno. I guess u decide ;-)

Quote from Zukuu >>

I

Does it have to be "Unidentified Object"? I think those are artifacts.

edit: Shit, just saw someone had the same idea. >_>

Yeah, someone already tried this and i think your card suffers the same problem ... discover a card from three different classes? Not without a tri-class emblem u dont. And u cannot cover the existing unidentified cards with a tri-class, since they r in a different category ...

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Sorry I haven't been here much. I think I'll go with A New Ally Emerges. Looking for extra feedback and will try to return it.

Dungeon Run is awesome by the way. I beat it on my third try with Hunter. Vicious Fledgling is awesome with Cloak of Invisibility. Primordial Wand is also amazing on the final boss. My free weapon was Skull of the Man'ari. What about you guys?

I like this a lot, but it could be a tiny bit OP. Im not rly sure how exactly to fix that, mby give it a hard cap on the cost? Something like Geosculptor Yip has for armor. Btw i got Skull of the Man'ari as well. Yaaay ... now to craft Bloodreaver Gul'dan :D

Quote from Lathy >>

[card]

Woo, we're back! Time to turn my inactiveness to activeness. First idea:

[/card]

Im not sure about taunt part. I can definitely see the argument for it, but you could discover some high cost card and cheat it out early, or you could play this in a Inner Fire priest and "guratee" yourself a minion on board, since your opponent wouldnt want to kill this. I guess the card has such a randomness in it, that taunt or no taunt r both viable options as i see it. Cool idea tho.

---

My card, thoughts?

 

Quote from Vilegloom >>

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

GLOBAL REVIEW

Would vote for:

Feasting Rander by MrUncreative (page 1)

Azgalor, the Tempter by Teknican (page 3)

Would vote for (with modifications):

None

Won't vote for no matter what:

The rest, because the base concept is bad (unoriginal, too complicated, etc...)

As for me, I will expand on my first simple idea. I made 3 new versions which I think have more flavor:

(far-right is the original one)

Which version is best?

 

 I like Looking for Group the most. It can interact with other 1-drops such as the new Gravelsnout Knight. Also, flavour is pretty nice.

On the other hand, the first two versions of Treat (+Attack/+health) are nice. I think those could be a bit better in Druid though, the buffing just feels more like it.

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Daybreaks >>

I forgot about the whole discover with Priest. Tht is why I originally modeled it after Kabal Chemist as neutral but I changed it later. Thanks for the heads up.

Just a suggestion, use Quote instead of Reply, when u want to reply to someone's post around here. It copies the post ur replying to into your response and makes for a more clear string of discussion. If u just use Reply it will get lost quickly.

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

This might be the best steed in the history of steeds, maybe ever

Its missing mana cost. Also im not too sure about the wording, but mby it should be Greater Spellstone. Also the name isnt too exciting for a legendary minion.

Quote from Shatterstar1998 >>

Repost my cards:

Unidentified Strike is the Rogue version of the Unidentified spells part. All four tend to be close to power level than the others UI parts for easier to balance.

Dark Calling is intended to be a better version of Gather Your Party at the cost of a card in your hand. Good for Control Warlock as they have big minions to play like Giants or big Demons.

Token:

Razorpetal, Kobold Geomancer.

The effects seem fine, tho mby u want to have combo on all of them, to keep consistency. I get that on the "lesser" ones u probably meant to make them stronger by not forcing the combo on em, but dunno. I guess u decide ;-)

Quote from Zukuu >>

I

Does it have to be "Unidentified Object"? I think those are artifacts.

edit: Shit, just saw someone had the same idea. >_>

Yeah, someone already tried this and i think your card suffers the same problem ... discover a card from three different classes? Not without a tri-class emblem u dont. And u cannot cover the existing unidentified cards with a tri-class, since they r in a different category ...

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Sorry I haven't been here much. I think I'll go with A New Ally Emerges. Looking for extra feedback and will try to return it.

Dungeon Run is awesome by the way. I beat it on my third try with Hunter. Vicious Fledgling is awesome with Cloak of Invisibility. Primordial Wand is also amazing on the final boss. My free weapon was Skull of the Man'ari. What about you guys?

I like this a lot, but it could be a tiny bit OP. Im not rly sure how exactly to fix that, mby give it a hard cap on the cost? Something like Geosculptor Yip has for armor. Btw i got Skull of the Man'ari as well. Yaaay ... now to craft Bloodreaver Gul'dan :D

Quote from Lathy >>

[card]

Woo, we're back! Time to turn my inactiveness to activeness. First idea:

[/card]

Im not sure about taunt part. I can definitely see the argument for it, but you could discover some high cost card and cheat it out early, or you could play this in a Inner Fire priest and "guratee" yourself a minion on board, since your opponent wouldnt want to kill this. I guess the card has such a randomness in it, that taunt or no taunt r both viable options as i see it. Cool idea tho.

---

My card, thoughts?

 

Why is AOE the common element here? It doesn't make a lot of sense. Like, why does Travel form deal damage to all enemy minions?

To be honest, the aoe was the starting point, so thats why. Then when i looked to which part of druid identity could i put it to, i found the 4 shapeshift forms and it seemed like a perfect solution. Yeah, the aoe doesnt make total sense in that regard, but i kinda justified it by that the druid switches stances during the fight to deal with multiple opponents, so he deals some dmg to all of em. Not sure if that reasoning can hold tho :)

About your cards:

Catacobms Conjurer: feels a lot like the Astral Tiger, i suppose thats where u got the inspiration. Do cards like a deathrattle copy of Astral Tiger count as "not started in your deck" for this purpose? Or is it meant as a soft counter to Psychic Scream and/or other shenanigans?

Unidentified Chest: i think u have a typo in the deathrattle part > "draws", other than that i feel like its too strong, for a neutal 2-drop its rly rly strong. Sure, u give your opponent a card, but i guess u could look at Dancing Swords and go from there. Your card gets more value effect/stat wise compared to the sword for their respective cost and the card draw.

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Daybreaks >>

I forgot about the whole discover with Priest. Tht is why I originally modeled it after Kabal Chemist as neutral but I changed it later. Thanks for the heads up.

Just a suggestion, use Quote instead of Reply, when u want to reply to someone's post around here. It copies the post ur replying to into your response and makes for a more clear string of discussion. If u just use Reply it will get lost quickly.

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

This might be the best steed in the history of steeds, maybe ever

Its missing mana cost. Also im not too sure about the wording, but mby it should be Greater Spellstone. Also the name isnt too exciting for a legendary minion.

Quote from Shatterstar1998 >>

Repost my cards:

Unidentified Strike is the Rogue version of the Unidentified spells part. All four tend to be close to power level than the others UI parts for easier to balance.

Dark Calling is intended to be a better version of Gather Your Party at the cost of a card in your hand. Good for Control Warlock as they have big minions to play like Giants or big Demons.

Token:

Razorpetal, Kobold Geomancer.

The effects seem fine, tho mby u want to have combo on all of them, to keep consistency. I get that on the "lesser" ones u probably meant to make them stronger by not forcing the combo on em, but dunno. I guess u decide ;-)

Quote from Zukuu >>

I

Does it have to be "Unidentified Object"? I think those are artifacts.

edit: Shit, just saw someone had the same idea. >_>

Yeah, someone already tried this and i think your card suffers the same problem ... discover a card from three different classes? Not without a tri-class emblem u dont. And u cannot cover the existing unidentified cards with a tri-class, since they r in a different category ...

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Sorry I haven't been here much. I think I'll go with A New Ally Emerges. Looking for extra feedback and will try to return it.

Dungeon Run is awesome by the way. I beat it on my third try with Hunter. Vicious Fledgling is awesome with Cloak of Invisibility. Primordial Wand is also amazing on the final boss. My free weapon was Skull of the Man'ari. What about you guys?

I like this a lot, but it could be a tiny bit OP. Im not rly sure how exactly to fix that, mby give it a hard cap on the cost? Something like Geosculptor Yip has for armor. Btw i got Skull of the Man'ari as well. Yaaay ... now to craft Bloodreaver Gul'dan :D

Quote from Lathy >>

[card]

Woo, we're back! Time to turn my inactiveness to activeness. First idea:

[/card]

Im not sure about taunt part. I can definitely see the argument for it, but you could discover some high cost card and cheat it out early, or you could play this in a Inner Fire priest and "guratee" yourself a minion on board, since your opponent wouldnt want to kill this. I guess the card has such a randomness in it, that taunt or no taunt r both viable options as i see it. Cool idea tho.

---

My card, thoughts?

 

Why is AOE the common element here? It doesn't make a lot of sense. Like, why does Travel form deal damage to all enemy minions?

To be honest, the aoe was the starting point, so thats why. Then when i looked to which part of druid identity could i put it to, i found the 4 shapeshift forms and it seemed like a perfect solution. Yeah, the aoe doesnt make total sense in that regard, but i kinda justified it by that the druid switches stances during the fight to deal with multiple opponents, so he deals some dmg to all of em. Not sure if that reasoning can hold tho :)

About your cards:

Catacobms Conjurer: feels a lot like the Astral Tiger, i suppose thats where u got the inspiration. Do cards like a deathrattle copy of Astral Tiger count as "not started in your deck" for this purpose? Or is it meant as a soft counter to Psychic Scream and/or other shenanigans?

Unidentified Chest: i think u have a typo in the deathrattle part > "draws", other than that i feel like its too strong, for a neutal 2-drop its rly rly strong. Sure, u give your opponent a card, but i guess u could look at Dancing Swords and go from there. Your card gets more value effect/stat wise compared to the sword for their respective cost and the card draw.

I think the entire idea of Unidentified Form doesn't make sense, really. The KoC unidentified cards are supposed to be things you would find in a dungeon, and they're unidentified in the sense of classic rogue-like adventure games: they are magical items where you don't know what the enchantment is. A Druid Form does not make any sense for this theme. The Druid knows what he's shapeshifting into. It's not something he finds in a dungeon. Plus, the AOE doesn't really make sense as a starting point.

For Catacombs Conjurer, yes, any card that was shuffled into or added to your deck for any reason did not start in your deck. 

For Unidentified Chest, Dancing Swords is like a super-bad card, so if I balance against it, I'll have a super-bad card. Unless you think my card is too powerful for mill, which is the only place Dancing Swords saw use? None of my cards are strictly better than it, anyway. The Vicious Mimic costs 1 less and has 1 less Attack, which I think is the kind of balance it would need to be playable.

Fair points about the Unidentified form, thanks.

Your Unidentified Chest is strong even now, cause it is an early drop. The card draw doesnt even matter in the end to be honest, i know its a decent drawback and lets a card have some extra stuff in exchange, but like i said, since its an early drop, the drawback will most likely never rly matter in the end.

I tried to make a spellstone, "Deal 1 damage to all enemy minions. (Attack twice with your Hero to upgrade)" Rogue spell, but gave up due to missing art lol. 

I think I will settle for this:

edit: Oh submission is up. Going to post it then.

Here's a new idea I had while thinking about Swamp King Dred:

The idea was to make a card for "Big Hunter" while giving it some control options. Obviously the enemy minions will stop attacking once the recruited minion is dead.

The cards I've posted before for comparison:

I had this idea for a spellstone-like card:

It's basically unplayable until you play 4 cards, at which point it's better than Vanilla statline. You get a better unit by waiting to play it. Not sure on the balance. I was thinking I could maybe up the attack of each one (1/2 to 3/2 to 5/2). Or I could make it 1 mana and 0/1 to 2/1 to 4/1. Also, here are the other cards I came up with:

And explanation:

This is merely placeholder art and I’ll make all properly colored/named tokens but I wanted to get my idea down on paper before bed.

Gemstone Collector actually upgrades 3 times (+1/+1) requiring a rarer gem each time until shes a legendary 4M 7/7.

Common - 4/4/4 - Play a Rare card to upgrade.

Rare - 4/5/5 - Play an Epic card to upgrade.

Epic - 4/6/6 - Play a Legendary card to upgrade.

Legendary - 4/7/7

Quote from waterwaIker >>

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Here's a new idea I had while thinking about Swamp King Dred:

The idea was to make a card for "Big Hunter" while giving it some control options. Obviously the enemy minions will stop attacking once the recruited minion is dead.

The cards I've posted before for comparison:

I like the idea, but I'm not sure how much should it cost. It's hard to evaluate the clear by itself, let alone the residual body it leaves behind.

What do you think? The 4M 7/7 meme lives on through Janek.

EDIT: I think I may change the cards to read as “(Play a card of higher Rarity to upgrade.)” for consistency with Spellstones and so the card is less rigid for the earlier upgrades.