Hearthpwn

Quote from Wailor >>

I made two similar cards:

 

Wandering Monk is a great warrior, but he will continue his journey after a while. Your paths shall meet again, though. This card can be compared to War Golem: it gives less board presence, but it helps you against fatigue. I gave it slightly better stats because I feel the drawback beats the advantage in Arena (where the card would be used the most).

Doomed Anihilian has an obviously worse effect, but his stats are better. What I like about this card is that it's effect is simpler (which fits better with a common card), and is also a huge guy (which highly stated minions tend to be). It might be slightly understated, though, as it's basically a delayed 9 damage that can be answered.

Do you like them? Would you change their stats? Thanks in advance!

I will review other cards when I have enough time ^^

Feedback? Anyone?

Quote from turnip_song >>

An awful lot of the submissions posted so far don't feel common to me, but then I myself can't come up with anything that does.

I've now updated Blast Goblin. Wording has been changed so it can't kill equal Attack minions, but now has +1/+1. So how is it?

I think it is quite strong for a common and feels similar to Firelands Portal, therefore I would make it a 4/4 and neutral (due to Priest -> less than 4 attack). I don't see a specific reason (people will figure out the handbuff thingy anyways) to make it tri-class only and especially the goons' reputation could hurt your entry more than it adds flavor...

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

I've now updated Blast Goblin. Wording has been changed so it can't kill equal Attack minions, but now has +1/+1. So how is it?

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

I think it is quite strong for a common and feels similar to Firelands Portal, therefore I would make it a 4/4 and neutral (due to Priest -> less than 4 attack). I don't see a specific reason (people will figure out the handbuff thingy anyways) to make it tri-class only and especially the goons' reputation could hurt your entry more than it adds flavor...

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

I think it is quite strong for a common and feels similar to Firelands Portal, therefore I would make it a 4/4 and neutral (due to Priest -> less than 4 attack). I don't see a specific reason (people will figure out the handbuff thingy anyways) to make it tri-class only and especially the goons' reputation could hurt your entry more than it adds flavor...

It actually was originally a 4/4 and could target equal Attack minions. People said the wording was weird so I changed it.

I don't think rarities really have power caps either and strong Commons have existed. Look at Piloted Shredder or Bonemare.

 

Quote from kegstandgoldmedalist >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

I think it is quite strong for a common and feels similar to Firelands Portal, therefore I would make it a 4/4 and neutral (due to Priest -> less than 4 attack). I don't see a specific reason (people will figure out the handbuff thingy anyways) to make it tri-class only and especially the goons' reputation could hurt your entry more than it adds flavor...

It actually was originally a 4/4 and could target equal Attack minions. People said the wording was weird so I changed it.

I don't think rarities really have power caps either and strong Commons have existed. Look at Piloted Shredder or Bonemare.

 

Now, if you made it 4/4 with the 5/5's text (so, it can destroy minions 3 atk or less unbuffed), I'd be interested in that card. I can't argue with powerful commons existing; splitting hairs about rarity aside, being able to unconditionally destroy a 4atk or less minions and develop of 5/5 feels a bit too strong for me personally.

My $0.02

My page isn't even full yet, and there already 2 disqualifications.

Quote from Zukuu >>

My page isn't even full yet, and there already 2 disqualifications.

Quote from kegstandgoldmedalist >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

I think it is quite strong for a common and feels similar to Firelands Portal, therefore I would make it a 4/4 and neutral (due to Priest -> less than 4 attack). I don't see a specific reason (people will figure out the handbuff thingy anyways) to make it tri-class only and especially the goons' reputation could hurt your entry more than it adds flavor...

It actually was originally a 4/4 and could target equal Attack minions. People said the wording was weird so I changed it.

I don't think rarities really have power caps either and strong Commons have existed. Look at Piloted Shredder or Bonemare.

 

Now, if you made it 4/4 with the 5/5's text (so, it can destroy minions 3 atk or less unbuffed), I'd be interested in that card. I can't argue with powerful commons existing; splitting hairs about rarity aside, being able to unconditionally destroy a 4atk or less minions and develop of 5/5 feels a bit too strong for me personally.

My $0.02

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

Quote from kegstandgoldmedalist >>

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

Quote from WUBRGWUBRG >>

I think it is quite strong for a common and feels similar to Firelands Portal, therefore I would make it a 4/4 and neutral (due to Priest -> less than 4 attack). I don't see a specific reason (people will figure out the handbuff thingy anyways) to make it tri-class only and especially the goons' reputation could hurt your entry more than it adds flavor...

It actually was originally a 4/4 and could target equal Attack minions. People said the wording was weird so I changed it.

I don't think rarities really have power caps either and strong Commons have existed. Look at Piloted Shredder or Bonemare.

 

Now, if you made it 4/4 with the 5/5's text (so, it can destroy minions 3 atk or less unbuffed), I'd be interested in that card. I can't argue with powerful commons existing; splitting hairs about rarity aside, being able to unconditionally destroy a 4atk or less minions and develop of 5/5 feels a bit too strong for me personally.

My $0.02

 Totally agree! That's what I wanted to say. No need to argue for or against powerful commons, but this card would define the arena meta for sure.

Quote from kegstandgoldmedalist >>

 Make that 4.

Quote from Don_Dingle >>

Here's three previous ideas, chosen out of six, and a new one in the form of Steam Hulk. Would love to know which of them you think is the most interesting.