Hearthpwn

Can definitely also be useful for fetching a Battlecry card like Hydrologist or the upcoming Cathedral Gargoyle. In other cases, people might be obligated to use Call to Arms as their Turn 4 play. 

Still though, drawing a Minion from your deck cannot be underestimated, and she can grab more late game hitters like Sunkeeper Tarim if a game gets drawn out long enough that early drops have already been either drawn or played out.

While not exactly someone worth building a deck around, this Bolvar does have some merit in already existing decks, provided one has room for him. Tirion and Wickerflame are typical auto includes these days, then there's people considering new cards like Corpsetaker and Righteous Defender, that's already a decent amount of Divine Shields there.

Also, it should be worth noting how 7 health with a shield can be a pain in the neck to quickly remove, especially if played on curve. Sure, the enemy can ignore it, but Spikeridged Steed on 6 can land a handful of them in a world of hurt unless they have sufficient removal.

I have a feeling that Tarim will be hard to replace, but is there any substitute for Wickerflame? Maybe a second Tar Creeper, perhaps? I can actually make this Deck since I have all the other cards except for those two Legendaries.

Edit: Recently crafted Tarim, though I've decided to put in Elise the Trailblazer to replace Wickerflame for long term value.

Quote from DirtyGoons >>

People are underestimating this cards. It will most likely see play as a 1-off in midrange/control paladins.

Before Un'goro got released, 2 SHR were "worth" 2 mana, playing Justicar Truehearth on turn6, using your hero power the following 3 turns was already in some control decks an option. This weapon has more value  than that and if you synergize it with Sunkeeper Tarim / adapt poison / high cost buffs you are fine. The opponent hardly can clear all little dudes efficently over few turns.

Quote from Nanoarciere >>

yeah you right, blizzard should make a 2 mana 5/10 taunt divine shield   for paladin for balancing the early game 

Quote from NovaGlacial >>

Paladin has a 2 drop again... YAAAASSSSSS

Quote from SirRandsborg >>

So heres the big thing about this card I don't see a lot of people talking about: It has 7 Health

This is a small detail that makes a huge difference. With 7 health, it trades into and kills 3 of your opponents 3/3 transformed minions, and has Taunt to keep you alive. People are complaining about it not having good consecration synergy, but it in itself is a big board clear. And if they do waste hard removal or damage on it, that's less damage going to your face and less removal for your other gigantic (maybe Dinosized) minions to wreak havoc. All in all, playable card, if not amazing or creative.

Aside from Mistcaller, I feel like Hunter's Dispatch Kodo would've been a great addition to Handbuff Paladin's arsenal. Free damage for a Battlecry on top of having a Minion in play could be nice.

That being said, I highly doubt I'll have enough time go get Consort and Corruptor before they're sent to Wild, and getting Deathwing or Rag Fire should be feasible if I don't get Kazakus or Wickerflame right now.

What are some worthwhile replacements for them? 

I'm guessing Book Wyrm isn't good enough to consider in this Deck? Or the Netherspite Historian for that matter?

With Humility, Aldor Peacekeeper and Keeper of Uldaman, Paladins also seem like a decent Candidate for Book Wyrm too.

Quote from xGodOfUnityx >>

To be honest, the only Card I'm missing for this Deck is Ysera. Is there anything that can replace her?

To be honest, the only Card I'm missing for this Deck is Ysera. Is there anything that can replace her?

I suppose I picked a wrong day to post this?

Placed this Card in my Divine Shield Paladin that has Late Game power. If the opponent can't handle him immediately, it's close to over. Aggro can't usually rush the Paladin down with Rag Light on the Board.

Clearly, this is meant to combo with something like Steward of Darkshire. 5 1/1s for 5 is too vulnerable to immediate response from the opponent. Name one Class that'll actually struggle against a bunch of defenseless Recruits on Turn 5.