Dagger of Venom: This is just busted. Win Axe is already one of the best cards in the game, and you want to make a more flexible version :/
The Maddest Bomber: This feels... weird. It just feels like a straight bad card.
Mana Hungry Elemental: This is pretty cool. I'd argue that this is too strong in a control deck. Since your average card will be so much stronger. The name also feels a bit iffy. But the idea is really good. I would vote for a tweaked version of this.
I think i'm going with Household Adventurer. Simple cards actually usually do pretty well.
For Ivar Bloodfang. Then...
He is really broken. Getting a free 0 mana 1/1 insane. And even more so considering that it's in rogue, where Combo cards exists.
Furthermore, it's a big advantage to start with fewer cards in your deck. Had you had the chance to play with 29-20 cards, then you would probaly do it, since every card in your deck just have become a lot stronger on average.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I want a new title, but Flux won't let me have one,
1. Maddest Bomber: would have to find better art for the Dynamite :D Not sure why it has classic emblem and not gvg lol :p
2. Dagger of Venom: Pretty much more versatile winaxe :)
3. Honorable mention - Deathwing Incarnate: this one is just for fun :D iv made up a crazy story back in a day for it as well, where DW woke up in a female body after a drunken bender with Nozdormu :D
... so Deathwing and Nozdormu had too much to drink one night and they were messing around transforming into dragon and human forms back and forth, but before they passed out, they didnt realize that something was wrong. In Deathwings last transformation, he transfromed into a female!
When he woke up next to Noz in the morning, he was all confused, but after one look in the mirror, it all became painfully clear ... at least the fact that Noz cant do anything for longer than 15s was a tiny consolation in his mind, but that didnt stop him from breaking the mirror in anger anyway ... oh well, now back to ol' drake self before Noz wakes up and remmember: LAST NIGHT NEVER HAPPEND!!!
I think this could be rly interesting. Would u gamble on this card or not ?:)
My Ramp Druid would love this card. Especially given that I have initiative in using the card. Probably too broken to ever be printed.
I was trying to find some Hearthstone-y art of a merchant in a hurry or smth similar, but no such luck and since I remembered the rabbit from MSG I decided to go with it.
The Discarded Coins do nothing, but can combo well with decks that want to use them in conjunction with Gadgetzan Auctioneer (potentially all classes), Flamewaker, Demented Frostcaller and Archmage Antonidas (Mage) and most importantly to be used as a discard source for Warlock. What do you guys think?
Edit: Ignore this card. As it is, its pretty broken in Exodia Mage, looking for appropriate art to convert this to a Warlock card.
Hasty Pickpocket: this looks like a bit too strong of a card for any combo deck. Mby do just battlecry or battlecry+deathrattle at best? I guess it wouldnt survive 2 turns on average anyway, but i dont think it should give more than 2 coins.
Another idea. Not sure if it's a little underpowered? I find it pretty flavorful, but I'm biased after all. Waddayathink?
Sweet idea. Effective when given Taunt. Why not make it just a Portal :)
I get your idea. It's just that it would be weird giving it damage and it would be able to attack. Then again there's Summoning Stone and Summoning Portal, so it might not make a difference :)
Here are some ideas I've come up with so far. Thoughts?
Edit: I added two others (Hatchling and Satchet)
Out of the designs I do like Faux Wizard and Tar Hatchling. However I think you may want to have a different name for the wizard card because it's a rogue card and well it would seem to be more like mage minion rather than a rogue minion.
As for the rat and satchet, I think these card would be broken in certain decks (I mean the rat in a Paladin deck would be very dangerous).
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
My Entry for this week's Card Design Competition - Season 8.16:
1. Maddest Bomber: would have to find better art for the Dynamite :D Not sure why it has classic emblem and not gvg lol :p
2. Dagger of Venom: Pretty much more versatile winaxe :)
3. Honorable mention - Deathwing Incarnate: this one is just for fun :D iv made up a crazy story back in a day for it as well, where DW woke up in a female body after a drunken bender with Nozdormu :D
... so Deathwing and Nozdormu had too much to drink one night and they were messing around transforming into dragon and human forms back and forth, but before they passed out, they didnt realize that something was wrong. In Deathwings last transformation, he transfromed into a female!
When he woke up next to Noz in the morning, he was all confused, but after one look in the mirror, it all became painfully clear ... at least the fact that Noz cant do anything for longer than 15s was a tiny consolation in his mind, but that didnt stop him from breaking the mirror in anger anyway ... oh well, now back to ol' drake self before Noz wakes up and remmember: LAST NIGHT NEVER HAPPEND!!!
I think this could be rly interesting. Would u gamble on this card or not ?:)
The effect of that is a 50/50 "I win or my opponent wins". Too strong in a ramp deck or combo deck.
These are my ideas, thoughts? . I'll try to return the feedback but I'm not very good evaluating cards.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Ahh yes, we've been expecting you. You'll have to be recorded before you're officially released. There are a few ways we can do this, and the choice is yours. See my submission to the WCDC hereand upvote if you like it. WCDC 8.3
Here are some ideas I've come up with so far. Thoughts?
Edit: I added two others (Hatchling and Satchet)
Oh yeah, Tar Hatchling is definitely the winner here, go with that one :) First two cards are OP and last one has wording issues and probably broken as well considering lol :D
1. Maddest Bomber: would have to find better art for the Dynamite :D Not sure why it has classic emblem and not gvg lol :p
2. Dagger of Venom: Pretty much more versatile winaxe :)
3. Honorable mention - Deathwing Incarnate: this one is just for fun :D iv made up a crazy story back in a day for it as well, where DW woke up in a female body after a drunken bender with Nozdormu :D
... so Deathwing and Nozdormu had too much to drink one night and they were messing around transforming into dragon and human forms back and forth, but before they passed out, they didnt realize that something was wrong. In Deathwings last transformation, he transfromed into a female!
When he woke up next to Noz in the morning, he was all confused, but after one look in the mirror, it all became painfully clear ... at least the fact that Noz cant do anything for longer than 15s was a tiny consolation in his mind, but that didnt stop him from breaking the mirror in anger anyway ... oh well, now back to ol' drake self before Noz wakes up and remmember: LAST NIGHT NEVER HAPPEND!!!
I think this could be rly interesting. Would u gamble on this card or not ?:)
I like the idea behind Maddest Bomber, though the summoning-dynamites thing just seems kind of clunky. I dunno, the card just doesn't appeal to me. It's also no more useful than its brethren. Dagger of Venom is more interesting, especially in light of that new Rogue card, though it's OP as it is now. Fiery War Axe is already really strong, and this card is strictly better. It's probably fine at 3, though. I think Mana Hungry Elemental could actually see play-you can play the card right away, and on average you benefit more because of the minion itself- especially in Ramp Druid or a control deck. It seems cool, I would just make it bigger for less turn 3 Tirions. And it should probably say "they cost (0)".
Dagger of Venom: This is just busted. Win Axe is already one of the best cards in the game, and you want to make a more flexible version :/
The Maddest Bomber: This feels... weird. It just feels like a straight bad card.
Mana Hungry Elemental: This is pretty cool. I'd argue that this is too strong in a control deck. Since your average card will be so much stronger. The name also feels a bit iffy. But the idea is really good. I would vote for a tweaked version of this.
Do u think it would be better as later drop? So u cant ramp it up too early to have a random big minion as tempo swing?
I think this could be rly interesting. Would u gamble on this card or not ?:)
The effect of that is a 50/50 "I win or my opponent wins". Too strong in a ramp deck or combo deck.
These are my ideas, thoughts? . I'll try to return the feedback but I'm not very good evaluating cards.
Do u think higher cost would solve the issue of the 50/50 coin toss? Im kinda liking this ability so i would like to balance it if possible, but i can see how it could be bad early on, even tho it would still be pretty random, even inramp druid, u can still pull innervate or some other low cost crap :)
To your cards:
Mana Essence: cool :)
Chillblade Horse Rider: i think this card is too complicated. I mean not rly, but its kinda trying too hard. Also 4 charge for 3 mana is kinda a lot, even with the condition, which could be easilly met.
Injured Crusader: i rly dont like 0 Health minions that have some "super duper" deathrattle. I mean its balanced, but i dont like this type of cards. Im glad u made it epic, cause it would be busted in arena with the +1/+1 buffs to your minions in hand.
First of all. Thanks for your reviews :D
I made Household a 2/1. Making Counterfeit Coin and Backstab relatively reasonable.
I want a new title, but Flux won't let me have one,
- Click Here To Join Us On Discord! -
On my phone so art isn't as polished as I want, but this is basically what I plan to submit.
I want a new title, but Flux won't let me have one,
My Entry for this week's Card Design Competition - Season 8.16:
Probably the one card that quest-discardlock needs
https://www.hearthpwn.com/forums/hearthstone-general/general-discussion/240800-hearthstone-board-improvement-idea#c6
The effect of that is a 50/50 "I win or my opponent wins". Too strong in a ramp deck or combo deck.
These are my ideas, thoughts? . I'll try to return the feedback but I'm not very good evaluating cards.
Ahh yes, we've been expecting you. You'll have to be recorded before you're officially released. There are a few ways we can do this, and the choice is yours.
See my submission to the WCDC here and upvote if you like it. WCDC 8.3
- Click Here To Join Us On Discord! -
Which one is better balanced do you guys think?
- Click Here To Join Us On Discord! -