One Night in Karazhan Community Ratings - All Card Scores - Card Discussion - Hearthstone General - HearthPwn Forums

One Night in Karazhan Community Ratings - All Card Scores

#1 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)
Fluxflashor
Fluxflashor

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Chief Executive of Deathwing
- 31
  
  104
  
  694
- Location: Canada
- Join Date: 5/23/2013
- Posts: 14,410
- BattleTag: Fluxflashor
- Member Details
Visit the news post here:
One Night in Karazhan Compendium - The Expansion as Rated by the Community

How are the scores calculated?

We gave the community five options: 'Meta defining', 'Very good', 'Playable', 'Bad' and 'Dust it!'. We then gave those options a value of 100, 75, 50, 25 and 0 and divided the result by the total amount of votes resulting in the following

86 - Menagerie Warden

84 - Cloaked Huntress

76 - Prince Malchezaar

75 - Enchanted Raven

75 - Arcane Giant

75 - Medivh's Valet

75 - Violet Illusionist

71 - Fool's Bane

70 - Medivh, the Guardian

70 - Kindly Grandmother

67 - Netherspite Historian

66 - Nightbane Templar

66 - Cat Trick

65 - Firelands Portal

65 - Moonglade Portal

65 - Babbling Book

65 - Moat Lurker

64 - Swashburglar

64 - Barnes

62 - Spirit Claws

60 - The Curator

60 - Avian Watcher

59 - Protect the King!

58 - Ivory Knight

56 - Book Wyrm

55 - Maelstrom Portal

55 - Silverware Golem

52 - Malchezaar's Imp

52 - Kara Kazham!

51 - Menagerie Magician

50 - Ironforge Portal

49 - Onyx Bishop

49 - Arcane Anomaly

47 - Zoobot

45 - Ethereal Peddler

44 - Priest of the Feast

44 - Deadly Fork

38 - Wicked Witchdoctor

37 - Silvermoon Portal

37 - Arcanosmith

36 - Pompous Thespian

34 - Runic Egg

32 - Pantry Spider

31 - Moroes

25 - Purify
Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
#2 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)
Sylicas
Sylicas

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Black Knight
- 13
  
  36
  
  99
- Location: Singapore
- Join Date: 9/1/2015
- Posts: 1,530
- BattleTag: Sylicas#6849
- Member Details
turns out Priest of the Feast is prettyyyy good.

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
#3 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)
AnkleShanker
AnkleShanker

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Warsong Commander
- 4
  
  9
  
  21
- Location: USA
- Join Date: 5/7/2016
- Posts: 182
- BattleTag: AnkleShanker#11354
- Member Details
Why is Prince Malchezzar so high on the list?

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack

Shanking ankles since 2015.
#4 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)
Fluxflashor
Fluxflashor

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Chief Executive of Deathwing
- 31
  
  104
  
  694
- Location: Canada
- Join Date: 5/23/2013
- Posts: 14,410
- BattleTag: Fluxflashor
- Member Details
Quote from AnkleShanker >>

Why is Prince Malchezzar so high on the list?

Because people initially believed he is awesome. Whether or not that holds true we'll have to wait and see.

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
#5 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)
user-23698347
user-23698347

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Sunwalker
- 5
  
  15
  
  33
- Join Date: 2/14/2016
- Posts: 449
- Member Details
Quote from AnkleShanker >>

Why is Prince Malchezzar so high on the list?

When he was initially revealed in asia at some convention, they translated the card and it said "At the start of your turn" (malchezar being in play like ancient harbinger) Instead of at the start of the game. Now can you imagine how it looked absoloutely busted untill they fixed the bad translation? Polls then showed meta defining and very good due to unexperience players, bad translation and just general confusion about how it worked.

Last edited by user-23698347 on Aug 22, 2016

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
#7 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)
Grounding
Grounding

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Shield Bearer
- 2
  
  13
  
  32
- Join Date: 7/9/2015
- Posts: 35
- BattleTag: Grounding #1875
- Member Details
Quote from Fheny123 >>

Worst list i ever seen.. Barnes should be on the top...

Most of the fun of card rating is watching people be wrong.

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
#9 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)
finniggann
finniggann

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Jouster
- 3
  
  18
  
  41
- Join Date: 1/28/2016
- Posts: 1,051
- BattleTag: finnaggann1560
- Member Details
People underrated so many cards, the whole bottom five are much better than people think, even purify, silence priest is not that bad. I think moroes is the least accurately rated card though. It actually is really good against most decks right now just because it helps with trades a lot if it lives a while and it often enough forces a board clear that does not deal efficiently with the board, nobody is running maelstrom portal or the Mage one that is worse.

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack

Just fill your deck with one drops, that is creative deck design, right?

#10 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)

Mad Scientist
- 12
- 35
- 102
Join Date: 5/7/2015
Posts: 3,667
Member Details

Quote from finniggann >>

People underrated so many cards, the whole bottom five are much better than people think, even purify, silence priest is not that bad. I think moroes is the least accurately rated card though. It actually is really good against most decks right now just because it helps with trades a lot if it lives a while and it often enough forces a board clear that does not deal efficiently with the board, nobody is running maelstrom portal or the Mage one that is worse.

Even when Moroes "Gets value", it has a very limited impact on both the game and board state because of how slow it is. It also struggles against warrior (what is considered to be the best class in the game right now) because of cards like ravaging ghoul. Maelstrom Portal is actually seeing some play in variants of evolve shaman and might see a significant boost in play once Spirit Claws has been released (or not we shall see). I've been seeing some control mage which does run Twilight Flamecaller and a number of classes can just leave it up and AOE later on during a game. Aggro decks on the other hand can completely ignore Moroes and pressure you too much to get value out of Moroes. If Moroes had a more immediate impact on the board, then it would likely be a lot more relevant, but right now, it just doesn't fit the meta well and requires a 6 mana two card combo to be stronger thanDreadsteed or Imp Master which don't see play.

As for purify, it's a little to expensive in my honest opinion. If it were 1 mana, it'd be a really solid way to cycle, but as it stands, it's just a bit too situational and difficult to abuse at a power level strong enough for constructed.

Last edited by notsoclutch on Aug 22, 2016

Witchwood Tempo Rogue Tempo Rogue Deck by notsoclutch - Apr 13, 2018 Export to BBCode Export to Cockatrice Export to MarkDown Export to Html Clone this deck
Minion (25) 1x Cairne Bloodhoof 1x Edwin VanCleef 1x Prince Keleseth 1x The Lich King 1x Bittertide Hydra 2x Vilespine Slayer 1x Cursed Castaway 2x Elven Minstrel 2x Saronite Chain Gang 2x SI:7 Agent 2x Argent Squire 2x Blink Fox 2x Cobalt Scalebane 2x Fire Fly 2x Hench-Clan Thug 1x Marsh Drake	Ability (5) 2x Backstab 2x Cold Blood 1x Fan of Knives
Loading Collection

#11 Aug 22, 2016 (Karazhan)

notsoclutch

Mad Scientist
- 12
- 35
- 102
Join Date: 5/7/2015
Posts: 3,667
Member Details

This list is so hilariously off. How are Barnes and the two good priest cards rated so low?

Witchwood Tempo Rogue Tempo Rogue Deck by notsoclutch - Apr 13, 2018 Export to BBCode Export to Cockatrice Export to MarkDown Export to Html Clone this deck
Minion (25) 1x Cairne Bloodhoof 1x Edwin VanCleef 1x Prince Keleseth 1x The Lich King 1x Bittertide Hydra 2x Vilespine Slayer 1x Cursed Castaway 2x Elven Minstrel 2x Saronite Chain Gang 2x SI:7 Agent 2x Argent Squire 2x Blink Fox 2x Cobalt Scalebane 2x Fire Fly 2x Hench-Clan Thug 1x Marsh Drake	Ability (5) 2x Backstab 2x Cold Blood 1x Fan of Knives
Loading Collection

#12 Aug 23, 2016 (Karazhan)
briankoontz
briankoontz

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Silvermoon Guardian
- 2
  
  26
  
  22
- Join Date: 6/14/2016
- Posts: 104
- BattleTag: Yunzi
- Member Details
Quote from notsoclutch >>

Quote from finniggann >>

Even when Moroes "Gets value", it has a very limited impact on both the game and board state because of how slow it is. It also struggles against warrior (what is considered to be the best class in the game right now) because of cards like ravaging ghoul. Maelstrom Portal is actually seeing some play in variants of evolve shaman and might see a significant boost in play once Spirit Claws has been released (or not we shall see).

There aren't enough spell power cards for Shaman to make this theoretical spell power deck work. Give Shaman something like Cult Sorcerer and a Spirit Claws/Wicked Witchdoctor + damage spells deck works - but with the exception of overload this deck closely resembles Tempo Mage, with the Wicked Witchdoctor closely resembling Violet Teacher, except with somewhat more powerful tokens.

Spirit Claws is great, but right now there are just not enough supporting cards for it - people will try though, using Bloodmage Thalnos, Azure Drake x2, and whatever else they can dredge up from the crap-pile of bad SP options.

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
#13 Aug 23, 2016 (Karazhan)
Songboh
Songboh

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Dread Corsair
- 9
  
  22
  
  38
- Join Date: 11/10/2015
- Posts: 160
- Member Details
What? Purify is last??

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack

Die, Insect!
#15 Aug 23, 2016 (Karazhan)
Ignaris
Ignaris

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Silvermoon Guardian
- 1
  
  5
  
  23
- Join Date: 4/12/2016
- Posts: 102
- BattleTag: Ignaris
- Member Details
Well this list sure is wrong. Witchdoctor is actually a pretty good card and the two priest cards are also really good for priest.

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack
#16 Aug 23, 2016 (Karazhan)
Tusina
Tusina

View User Profile

View Posts

Send Message
- Ogre Magi
- 6
  
  29
  
  50
- Join Date: 2/3/2016
- Posts: 299
- BattleTag: Colgate#2680
- Member Details
This community overvalues Arcane Giant way too much. It would be close the truth, if it were in the other end of the spectrum.

Rollback Post to Revision RollBack

Legendaries crafted so far: Dr. Boom, Kazakus, Lord Jaraxxus, Sylvanas Windrunner, Fire Plume's Heart, Mal'Ganis, Bloodreaver Gul'dan, Baku the Mooneater, Genn Greymane, Aya Blackpaw, Patches the Pirate, Leeroy Jenkins, Zilliax, Raid the Docks and ancharr
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.