Help
  • cdig's avatar

    1

    Jun 6, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed priest card? (preliminary)

    https://strawpoll.com/63zy262

    https://strawpoll.com/1ws9drb

    https://strawpoll.com/6x8b528

    Three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 7% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    Previous poll winners

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana winner: Twilight Drake

    5 mana winner: Azure Drake

    6 mana winner: Reno Jackson

    7+ mana winner: The Curator

    Druid winner: Fandral Staghelm

    Hunter winner: Savannah Highmane

    Mage winner: Archmage Antonidas

    Paladin finalist: Ivory knight, sunkeeper tarim, tirion fordring, anyfin can happen, truesilver champion, wickerflame burnbristle, equality, aldor peacekeeper, keeper of uldamen, hydrologist, forbidden healing, shielded minibot

    Posted in: Priest
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    Jun 5, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed paladin card? (preliminary)

    https://strawpoll.com/5w9rbbz

    https://strawpoll.com/3agr5es

    https://strawpoll.com/gyc43yz

    Three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 7% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    Previous poll winners

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana winner: Twilight Drake

    5 mana winner: Azure Drake

    6 mana winner: Reno Jackson

    7+ mana winner: The Curator

    Druid winner: Fandral Staghelm

    Hunter winner: Savannah Highmane

    Mage winner: Archmage Antonidas

    Posted in: Paladin
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    Jun 4, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What are the best designed Druid, hunter and mage card? (finals)

    Druid https://strawpoll.com/4w1bd7g

    Hunter https://strawpoll.com/cg866dc

    Mage https://strawpoll.com/f74b1d1

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    Sorry for the delay, computer died.

    Previous poll winners

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana winner: Twilight Drake

    5 mana winner: Azure Drake

    6 mana winner: Reno Jackson

    7+ mana winner: The Curator

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    Jun 2, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed mage card? (preliminary)

    https://strawpoll.com/r19es24

    https://strawpoll.com/y48g9x5

    https://strawpoll.com/e25x393

    Three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 7% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Tomorrow will be the finals for druid, hunter and mage.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    Previous poll winners

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana winner: Twilight Drake

    5 mana winner: Azure Drake

    6 mana winner: Reno Jackson

    7+ mana winner: The Curator

    Druid finalist: Nourish, living mana, kun the forgotten king, ancient of war, aviana, fandral staghelm, druid of the claw, swipe, astral communion, wild growth, wrath, innervate, raven idol, darnassus aspirant

    Hunter finalist: savannah highmane, eaglehorn bow, animal companion, call of the wild, tundra rhino, houndmaster, kill command, unleash the hounds, cloaked huntress, freezing trap, desert camel, crackling razormaw, kindly grandmother, lock and load, quick shot, tracking

    Posted in: Mage
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    Jun 1, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed hunter card? (preliminary)

    https://strawpoll.com/yw59c9y

    https://strawpoll.com/s3r2w17

    https://strawpoll.com/zy6fez7

    three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 7% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    Previous poll winners

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana winner: Twilight Drake

    5 mana winner: Azure Drake

    6 mana winner: Reno Jackson

    7+ mana winner: The Curator

    Druid finalist: Nourish, living mana, kun the forgotten king, ancient of war, aviana, fandral staghelm, druid of the claw, swipe, astral communion, wild growth, wrath, innervate, raven idol, darnassus aspirant

    Posted in: Hunter
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 31, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed druid card? (preliminary)

    https://strawpoll.com/aay1yfg

    https://strawpoll.com/f5b8yzy

    https://strawpoll.com/3y9929g

    three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 7% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana winner: Twilight Drake

    5 mana winner: Azure Drake

    6 mana winner: Reno Jackson

    7+ mana winner: The Curator

    Posted in: Druid
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 30, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What are the best designed 4+ mana neutrals? (finals)
    Quote from SchruteBucks >>

    Dr. Doom?

    Also, is Yogg the pre-nerf or post-nerf version?

     Whoops.  Typo.  I bet most can figure it out.  I sorta blow through the typing and misspell.  It takes about 30 mins to set up each poll every morning.
     
    Post nerf.  I intend each card to be judged by their current position.
    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 30, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What are the best designed 4+ mana neutrals? (finals)
    Quote from definitelynotsalty >>

     No Vol'jin.  Disappointed. 

     This is just neutral cards.  The priest poll will be in 6 days.
     
    Also, Voljin won in the last version of this series, two expansions ago.  I'm interested to see how he does this time.
    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 30, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What are the best designed 4+ mana neutrals? (finals)
    Quote from FortyDust >>

    We all understand that the average player's perception of "well-designed" has very little to do with what is actually good game design, right?

     Well, since everyone finds themself to be above average, and having the only correct answer, this should work ok.  
    Kidding aside, the people who visit and comment on HS forums are more likely to know more about the game than people who only play on the toilet and never engage with the game any other way.
     
    It is all opinions, and for fun. 
     
    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 30, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What are the best designed 4+ mana neutrals? (finals)

    4 mana https://strawpoll.com/1yfsrfe

    5 mana https://strawpoll.com/2cywz7z

    6 mana https://strawpoll.com/9waefr9

    7+ mana https://strawpoll.com/78x8rw3

    Here are all the finalist from the last 4 days of voting.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    Tomorrow will be start on the class cards.

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 29, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed 7+ mana neutral? (Preliminary round)

    7 mana, 10% vote threshold to advance

    https://strawpoll.com/5c34bdg

    8 mana, 13% vote threshold to advance

    https://strawpoll.com/4bfa51x

    9 mana, 13% vote threshold to advance

    https://strawpoll.com/ee365b1

    10+ mana, 14% vote threshold to advance

    https://strawpoll.com/9x9rc5a

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    Tomorrow will be the finals for mana cost 4-7+.

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana finalist: Defender of Argus, Barnes, Chillwind Yeti, Elise Starseeker, Faceless Shambler, Twilight Drake, Piloted Shredder, Voilet Teacher, Refreshment Vendor, Sen'jin Shieldmasta

    5 mana finalist: Azure Drake, Elise the trailbazer, Loatheb, Grim Patron, Faceless Manipulator, Antique Healbot, Sludge Belcher, Stampeding Kodo, Second rate Bruiser

    6 mana finalist: Emperor Thaurissan, Gadgetzan Auctioneer, Cairne Bloodhoof, Justicar Trueheart, Hemet jungle hunter, Reno Jackson, Slyvanas Windrunner

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 28, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed 6 mana neutral? (Preliminary round)
    Quote from 4wd >>

    What's point of this polls? Are you going to award Ben Brode for some card best design or what?

     Its fun for me.  I'm interested to see what the community thinks.  I like seeing the prelim rounds, and guessing how the individual contenders do in the finals.  I'm curious to see which of my favorites are liked by others too.
    I like tournaments, so I wanted to pit every card in the game against each other in 48 prelim rounds, 16 finals, and 1 grand finals.
    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 28, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed 6 mana neutral? (Preliminary round)

    https://strawpoll.com/6b5rf4z

    https://strawpoll.com/wbc2e9c

    https://strawpoll.com/aw445yg

    three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 11% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    The neutrals will be broken into 7 brackets, with 0 mana ignored and 7+ mana lumped together. After 4 days of prelims, the finals for mana cost 4-7+ will be run concurrently.

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana finalist: Defender of Argus, Barnes, Chillwind Yeti, Elise Starseeker, Faceless Shambler, Twilight Drake, Piloted Shredder, Voilet Teacher, Refreshment Vendor, Sen'jin Shieldmasta

    5 mana finalist: Azure Drake, Elise the trailbazer, Loatheb, Grim Patron, Faceless Manipulator, Antique Healbot, Sludge Belcher, Stampeding Kodo, Second rate Bruiser

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 27, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed 5-mana neutral? (preliminaries)

    https://strawpoll.com/16dwsc7

    https://strawpoll.com/r56fzge

    https://strawpoll.com/asfz5e6

    three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 9% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    The neutrals will be broken into 7 brackets, with 0 mana ignored and 7+ mana lumped together. After 4 days of prelims, the finals for mana cost 4-7+ will be run concurrently.

    1 mana winner: Fire Fly 2 mana winner: Doomsayer 3 mana winner: Tar Creeper

    4 mana finalist: Defender of Argus, Barnes, Chillwind Yeti, Elise Starseeker, Faceless Shambler, Twilight Drake, Piloted Shredder, Voilet Teacher, Refreshment Vendor, Sen'jin Shieldmasta

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • cdig's avatar

    0

    May 26, 2017
    cdig posted a message on What is the best designed 4-mana neutral? (preliminaries)

    https://strawpoll.com/9yg1272

    https://strawpoll.com/b45a68y

    https://strawpoll.com/fw6zbcx

    three polls are posted at once, and any card that gets more than 8% of the vote will move onto finals match.

    Vote on the card that is best designed mechanically, ignoring art, lore and theme.

    The neutrals will be broken into 7 brackets, with 0 mana ignored and 7+ mana lumped together. After 4 days of prelims, the finals for mana cost 4-7+ will be run concurrently.

    1 mana winner: Fire fly

    2 mana winner: Doomsayer

    3 mana winner: tar creeper

    Posted in: Card Discussion
  • To post a comment, please login or register a new account.