I am going to disagree with most people here but imo Trump is one of the top reviewers out there. Yes, he has made some big whoopsies in the past but on the whole, he gets things right more often than not. Few could have predicted just how broken Caverns Below would be before the set released. He really knows the game very well and if you go back and watch his re-reviews of past sets you can see that he nails most of the cards he rates. One thing that does limit him is that he tends to only look at existing archetypes and some theory crafts that are too general like taunt warrior or control priest. That said though, not one reviewer ever predicted a deck like cyclone mage so nearly everyone was wrong about some of those cards. It’s impossible to be 100% accurate with ratings but Trump does a good job and gets it right more often than not.
For the more casual player, Kripp is good as well.
Top players like Thijs for example are much more hit and miss with their ratings. It seems like they just make a video without much research before hand and this leads to them either being overly generous with their ratings or not exploring possible synergies enough.
So for me, Trump gets the number one spot ito reviewers. He does the research and understands the game very well. And most of the times he is actually right. But as always, rather wait a few weeks before you craft anything to see how things shape up. It’s easy to get carried away on launch day and craft all the flashy stuff but that seldom works out once the meta settles down. Be patient, and wait a bit before blowing all that valuable dust you saved up.
3
This card has bigger brain then 99% of the player-base.
1
Is mechathun and hakkar rogue going to be a thing now, well time to prepare my new 6 mana epic hunter card for som rogue hunting.