Here’s the thing about Theotar, he’s bad. He was bad at 5 mana. He is bad at 6 mana. It’s a turn 6 4/4 with no immediate impact. I see everyone saying he steals denathrius and so he is mandatory, but that is pretty much for ramp Druid and maybe phylactery warlock. The best decks and most popular decks don’t care about Theotar at all. Shaman being able to abuse it with schooling is a different story because you are almost guaranteed a terrible trade, so it makes Theotar a bit better. If you are playing Theotar, cut him and win more games. Theotar is so niche that if you need him to beat ramp Druid, you are probably going to lose to one of the other wincons in that deck.
Well you hit a good point there. Most top dog decks dont need Denathrius, runing him in token druid and imp lock is kind of "optional" You have REALLY good reasons to run him on Warlock tho. The problem is: what about the other top decks? Value mage, value rogue, Paladin, Ramp Druid, those kind of decks have a card that will beat u if you play slow decks of any kind that dont insta win, if you dont have Theotar.
Theothar is just Half of the problem, the other half is this meta with decks that cant dealt with Denathrius, Tess, cards with really strong Battle Cry effects that change win the game when played. What do u do against those cards? The main reason why Theothar is played in every single deck is that...well there is nothing better to play to balance the game. Devs dont like him, probably players neither but without him a lot of decks would be doomed.
Mage doesn’t need Denathrius and has redundancy. Rogue is playing jackpot, Theotar does little against this matchup. Paladin is the same, if you have to choose between jailer and Denathrius, is it better to play something else? The answer to denathrius decks is to play something more proactive that has a gameplan. Relying on Theotar to solve denathrius isn’t it.
Do you think Theotar being released with Denathtrius is an oversight or a coincidence by the dev team?
Do you think Theotar being released with Denathtrius is an oversight or a coincidence by the dev team?
Once DK starts going, you’ll be wishing Theotar was back at 4 mana. Careful what you wish for, Sire DK is coming.