...This is quite complicated. Um. Ok, battlecry. Sure, I guess, but just this card alone should be 5 mana from that Battlecry. Then the combo, you silence everything and summon Sonya. If you're going to summon a silenced Sonya, why not just summon a 2/2 vanilla minion token? I actually don't really see the point of all this, other than just a big ball of stats that's costed way too low.
Both legendary Shaku, the Collector and Sonya Shadowdancer are pretty weak in any of competitive decks like Tempo, Aggro, Miracle or Sprint Rogue (that's my expirience + history of top rated decks). Rogue feels like a weak class right now (only weapons helps smash face, which is shame) cut all the weapons and Rogue "weakest class in the game". So what we do when class are not that great ? I think we buff it.
My card is legendary - so only one copy in the deck, max stats 14 (6 attack and 8 health) with silence on them + u need combo (use card that takes a slot in your deck), otherwise u have 10 stats (4 attack + 6 health) with positive effect like Shaku, the Collectoron next turn.
Cards like Oasis Surger have 20 stats (10 Attack and 10 health with positive effect like Rush on your turn + often this is 5th turn).
So I completly disagree with "5 mana from that Battlecry".
"Why not just summon a 2/2 vanilla minion token? " - Both legendary are weak (they are OK only in specific types of deck) for people who like non-standard plays it would be fun and interesting to use Shadowstep on Sonya and not for 2/2 vanilla minion, don't see any of problems with impact for the game.
I understand you - Shaku, the Collector and Sonya Shadowdancer are 6 mana , but i take it + add 2/3 body and put it for 4 mana , that's why so many quesions. So how i said legendary are not that strong to make a huge impact, 4 mana is OK for class like Rogue right now.
For me it's complicated for no reason. I think Combo should give Shaku Rush or Charge instead of the current effect. Silence is not Rogue's theme.
Often i'am playing only Rogue, so i've try to make card that I want in standart right now....(really don't want to change it). This effect can be compare to [card]Myra's Unstable Element[/card], it's weird and respectively magnetic for me. And yes i've miss [card]Fal'dorei Strider[/card] too much... P.S. Fal'dorei Strider much better than this card.
I don't think it's crazy that much, but ofcourse it's a lot of stats for 4 drop... that stats which is no longer in their 4 drops.
Seems a bit overcomplicated with the additional Silence effect. Generally you'll want to keep it to a maximum of 4 lines of text. If you're afraid of some powerful combo without the Silence effect, have the summons changed to be added to your hand instead.
Will do "Quote" as "Reply" don't show the essence.
Silence effect pushes you to play this card in 2 ways, 1st is play aggressive with full board of Silenced minions and 2nd take value of Shaku, the Collector , also Silence effect give u a good reason to play Shadowstep in your deck to get a different options.
P.S. I think we had and already have a bit more comlicated cards in HS, more of the line space takes cards names.
Silence effect pushes you to play this card in 2 ways, 1st is play aggressive with full board of Silenced minions and 2nd take value of Shaku, the Collector , also Silence effect give u a good reason to play Shadowstep to get a different options.
P.S. I think we had and already have a bit more comlicated cards in HS, more of the line space takes cards names.
Both legendary Shaku, the Collector and Sonya Shadowdancer are pretty weak in any of competitive decks like Tempo, Aggro, Miracle or Sprint Rogue (that's my expirience + history of top rated decks). Rogue feels like a weak class right now (only weapons helps smash face, which is shame) cut all the weapons and Rogue "weakest class in the game". So what we do when class are not that great ? I think we buff it.
My card is legendary - so only one copy in the deck, max stats 14 (6 attack and 8 health) with silence on them + u need combo (use card that takes a slot in your deck), otherwise u have 10 stats (4 attack + 6 health) with positive effect like Shaku, the Collector on next turn.
Cards like Oasis Surger have 20 stats (10 Attack and 10 health with positive effect like Rush on your turn + often this is 5th turn).
High Priest Amet also have positive effect on your turn.
So I completly disagree with "5 mana from that Battlecry".
"Why not just summon a 2/2 vanilla minion token? " - Both legendary are weak (they are OK only in specific types of deck) for people who like non-standard plays it would be fun and interesting to use Shadowstep on Sonya and not for 2/2 vanilla minion, don't see any of problems with impact for the game.
I understand you - Shaku, the Collector and Sonya Shadowdancer are 6 mana , but i take it + add 2/3 body and put it for 4 mana , that's why so many quesions. So how i said legendary are not that strong to make a huge impact, 4 mana is OK for class like Rogue right now.
Will do "Quote" as "Reply" don't show the essence.
Silence effect pushes you to play this card in 2 ways, 1st is play aggressive with full board of Silenced minions and 2nd take value of Shaku, the Collector , also Silence effect give u a good reason to play Shadowstep in your deck to get a different options.
P.S. I think we had and already have a bit more comlicated cards in HS, more of the line space takes cards names.
Silence effect pushes you to play this card in 2 ways, 1st is play aggressive with full board of Silenced minions and 2nd take value of Shaku, the Collector , also Silence effect give u a good reason to play Shadowstep to get a different options.
P.S. I think we had and already have a bit more comlicated cards in HS, more of the line space takes cards names.
I don't think it's crazy that much, but ofcourse it's a lot of stats for 4 drop... that stats which is no longer in their 4 drops.