If you want to make a minion that comes back forever, balance it against Dreadsteed but then take into consideration why it was nerfed so it doesn't come back immediately. (Defile)
Not a valid entry. Please read the competition guidelines again:
Competition-Specific Restrictions:
You must make a card that directly uses the Reborn mechanic. (Cards like Embalming Ritual or Psychopompdo not count.) EDIT: Cards that *gain* Reborn are allowed. (Ex. When this minion attacks, gain Reborn)
You must also choose one of the three following prompts:
Your submission must be a weapon.
Your submission must be a Neutral minion that costs 7 or more.
Your submission must be a class minion that did not receive a Reborn-related card. (You may not choose Rogue, Warrior, Priest, or Paladin.)
Misread the card, yeah it does count, but yeah, it's totally broken.
Well, most of the pictures you see here aren't photoshopped at all. It just takes some time and effort to find a good picture. I sometimes spend hours finding the perfect card art for a larger scale project. If you want a program just for general and/or future use, GIMP is free and can do most thing Adobe Photoshop can do.
Under this effect you never run out of patrons, right? (It's not spelled patreon) I don't know if taking three damage is enough compensation for an infinite body, though Bittertide Hydra did something similar.
Furthermore, it does not matter that people who submit later get fewer votes. Votes are weighted depending how far back an entry was submitted. Everything you need to know about how we calculate score is in the opening post.
Wicked Tracker is a very neat, smart idea. No one has done a highlander cards yet and this one is worth playing highlander for.
Deadscale Seer is probably too expensive to see play, due to the Neutral costing 7 or more restriction. It's a nice idea, might work better as a class minion.
Unfortunately, both are not valid entries:
You must make a card that directly uses the Reborn mechanic. (Cards like Embalming Ritual or Psychopomp do not count.)
If anything, she should be stronger. I think 6 mana 4/6 is good. Also, there is a rule of thumb when creating cards: Do not go over four lines of text. Do your best to make it more concise.
Is not a valid entry. Please read the contest requirements in the opening post again. Also try to refrain from just saying "Thoughts?" and not offering any feedback to others. At the very very least, try to give some thought process behind your card or something.
As someone pointed out, this card does not have Reborn itself so would not qualify. There are a few other things, as well. You forgot to select a class. Is it Paladin? Shaman? And as for balance I'd probably give this a 3/2. You pretty much lock in your board *twice* at 3/2 with this card. That's already insane. It's like two better Soul of the Murlocs in one card, plus a 2.5 mana weapon. This might honestly be better at 6 mana, just for balance's sake.
Yeah, like others have said, this won't work. At 0 mana, however, this card becomes very interesting. I wouldn't mind seeing this card at 0 mana honestly, gives a big incentive for Token/Totem Shaman, especially with the new EVIL Totem as a follow up on turn 2. While it's a 0 mana with a big upside, a 1/1 is honestly small enough of an impact that I think it could work. Now *that*, I think, would be interesting.
This is an excellent concept. It's smart and clean. But, yeah, someone pointed out it's paladin. In my opinion, I would also put this at 2/2. 3/1 is rather aggressive for a magnetic effect at 3 mana.
Yeahhh it's perma-Reborn, haha. Back to the drawing board, unfortunately. It is also not a valid card. If you do a Neutral minion, it must cost 7 or more.
Deal 10, heal 10, summon 8/4 in stats, all at 8 mana. Hmmmm. I would like to see this at 4/4, so it's more in line with Walking Fountain. They would both damage and heal the same while your card has a lot of tokens while Walking Fountain can live for next turn.
Don't forget to use postimages or another external site, unless you don't mind your card vanishing after a week or so. If you do not re-host using postimages, the hearthcards.net server purges all cards regularly to save space.
As for the card itself, it's weak. Definitely needs a lot more stats. I'd give it a 6/12 or something.
Hmmmm not bad. Could be a very powerful tool to refill your hand in Quest Druid. Would like to see better art (this looks like a generic fantasy character on a very bland background) and better formatting on the card. You have a random empty line and forgot the period.
I think this is too similar to Colossus of the Moon with a lot less stats. Would have to be a 7/7 to even compete with Tirion. I think this card could be more interesting, though, instead of just 3 keywords, especially when another in-game legendary has two of those on it already.
It's also a Paladin card, and that does not qualify. Please double-check the rules in the opening post.
Hmmmm I like this! It's perfectly balanced. Too bad Blizzard doesn't reuse Recruit. While this card is fine as-is, if you want to be more authentic, just simply replace "Recruit" with summon.
Couple of things wrong with the formatting of this card: If a Keyword is by itself on a line, no need for a comma (So it is not Reborn, but just Reborn). Next, no need to italicize Zephyrus the Great.
As for the balance... having 3 Zephyrus is really really... let's just say un-interactive. I realize this is extremely slow the turn you play it but just keep in mind one Zephryrus is already a get out of jail free card. Technically balance wise it's probably ok, just not sure if this kind of card should exist.
Just to clarify about the rules: I know you can't make cards that give or just synergise with reborn, but does it count if I make a card that gains reborn under certain conditions?
Like something for hunter that says "Battlecry: gain reborn if you have a beast." or something?
I decided to let this go through, so yeah go for it.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
⚙
Learn More
Cosmetics
Related Cards
Card Pools
✕
×
PopCard Settings
Click on the buttons to change the PopCard background.
Elements settings
Click on the button to hide or unhide popcard elements.
Apologies guys, I'll get on it right away. Counting the scores now.
If you want to make a minion that comes back forever, balance it against Dreadsteed but then take into consideration why it was nerfed so it doesn't come back immediately. (Defile)
I like the second one more as well.
Not a valid entry. Please read the competition guidelines again:
I cannot see any images. Please ensure you are not using imgur and re-read the posting tutorial in the opening post.
I feel like 3/4 is better. Since the requirement for getting Reborn is a a drawback, premium stats for a 3-drop is best but 3/4 is not as aggressive.
Misread the card, yeah it does count, but yeah, it's totally broken.
Well, most of the pictures you see here aren't photoshopped at all. It just takes some time and effort to find a good picture. I sometimes spend hours finding the perfect card art for a larger scale project. If you want a program just for general and/or future use, GIMP is free and can do most thing Adobe Photoshop can do.
It doesn't use Reborn itself. It's not valid.
Under this effect you never run out of patrons, right? (It's not spelled patreon) I don't know if taking three damage is enough compensation for an infinite body, though Bittertide Hydra did something similar.
Furthermore, it does not matter that people who submit later get fewer votes. Votes are weighted depending how far back an entry was submitted. Everything you need to know about how we calculate score is in the opening post.
Solid card. Nothing needs to be changed.
Wicked Tracker is a very neat, smart idea. No one has done a highlander cards yet and this one is worth playing highlander for.
Deadscale Seer is probably too expensive to see play, due to the Neutral costing 7 or more restriction. It's a nice idea, might work better as a class minion.
Unfortunately, both are not valid entries:
Just clarifying this entry before a discussion happens... technically, yes, it follows the rules.
Rules aside, this card is broken because of Stonetusk Boar, or even Skaterbot.
If anything, she should be stronger. I think 6 mana 4/6 is good. Also, there is a rule of thumb when creating cards: Do not go over four lines of text. Do your best to make it more concise.
Yeah lowering it is a good idea. Thing is, this is most likely played in face Warrior where they rarely use the Hero Power.
Is not a valid entry. Please read the contest requirements in the opening post again. Also try to refrain from just saying "Thoughts?" and not offering any feedback to others. At the very very least, try to give some thought process behind your card or something.
Hmmm a 3-cost Arcanite Reaper. I'd say deal 4. Deal 12 to your own face is really steep.
Whew, that's a lot of posts. Here we go:
As someone pointed out, this card does not have Reborn itself so would not qualify. There are a few other things, as well. You forgot to select a class. Is it Paladin? Shaman? And as for balance I'd probably give this a 3/2. You pretty much lock in your board *twice* at 3/2 with this card. That's already insane. It's like two better Soul of the Murlocs in one card, plus a 2.5 mana weapon. This might honestly be better at 6 mana, just for balance's sake.
Ok, please review the posting tutorial in the opening post on how to put images in a post.
Second, I can only assume your card was meant to be a weapon so I recreated it for you. I didn't find the exact art so here is a replacement.
Yeah, like others have said, this won't work. At 0 mana, however, this card becomes very interesting. I wouldn't mind seeing this card at 0 mana honestly, gives a big incentive for Token/Totem Shaman, especially with the new EVIL Totem as a follow up on turn 2. While it's a 0 mana with a big upside, a 1/1 is honestly small enough of an impact that I think it could work. Now *that*, I think, would be interesting.
This is an excellent concept. It's smart and clean. But, yeah, someone pointed out it's paladin. In my opinion, I would also put this at 2/2. 3/1 is rather aggressive for a magnetic effect at 3 mana.
Yeahhh it's perma-Reborn, haha. Back to the drawing board, unfortunately. It is also not a valid card. If you do a Neutral minion, it must cost 7 or more.
Deal 10, heal 10, summon 8/4 in stats, all at 8 mana. Hmmmm. I would like to see this at 4/4, so it's more in line with Walking Fountain. They would both damage and heal the same while your card has a lot of tokens while Walking Fountain can live for next turn.
Don't forget to use postimages or another external site, unless you don't mind your card vanishing after a week or so. If you do not re-host using postimages, the hearthcards.net server purges all cards regularly to save space.
As for the card itself, it's weak. Definitely needs a lot more stats. I'd give it a 6/12 or something.
Hmmmm not bad. Could be a very powerful tool to refill your hand in Quest Druid. Would like to see better art (this looks like a generic fantasy character on a very bland background) and better formatting on the card. You have a random empty line and forgot the period.
I think this is too similar to Colossus of the Moon with a lot less stats. Would have to be a 7/7 to even compete with Tirion. I think this card could be more interesting, though, instead of just 3 keywords, especially when another in-game legendary has two of those on it already.
It's also a Paladin card, and that does not qualify. Please double-check the rules in the opening post.
Hmmmm I like this! It's perfectly balanced. Too bad Blizzard doesn't reuse Recruit. While this card is fine as-is, if you want to be more authentic, just simply replace "Recruit" with summon.
Very strong. 4/3 is already worth 5.5 mana, then you get an extra 4+3+2+1=10 more damage. I think this should start off as a 4/2.
Couple of things wrong with the formatting of this card: If a Keyword is by itself on a line, no need for a comma (So it is not Reborn, but just Reborn). Next, no need to italicize Zephyrus the Great.
As for the balance... having 3 Zephyrus is really really... let's just say un-interactive. I realize this is extremely slow the turn you play it but just keep in mind one Zephryrus is already a get out of jail free card. Technically balance wise it's probably ok, just not sure if this kind of card should exist.
I decided to let this go through, so yeah go for it.