When was face hunter(not undertaker hunter) a tier one deck?
On topic:
Freeze mage(beta)
Combo Druid(force+savage)
Zoo after Naxx release
Undertaker Hunter
Patron Warrior
Secret Paladin
Aggro/Midrange Shaman(both have been broken for over a year now, reason you don't see them more is because meta adapted to sort of counter them)
Pirate Warrior
Dragon Priest after MSOG(let people deny it all they want, but a midrange deck that manages to outvalue any other deck is NOT balanced)
Jade Druid
Nope. The good versions of undertaker hunter were midrangey aggro decks with highmane at the top of the curve. Sure you still played aggressively with them, but you didn't usually run things like arcane golem and wolfrider in them.
Also, it's been 3 years, and I only actually started playing HS halfway seriously(as in getting to ranks 5-legend) a bit after GvG was released, so maybe there was a small window of time when FH could in fact be considered a tier one deck. But people overrate face hunter way too much in the grand scheme of things. It's probably one of the easiest decks to counter in the history of HS.
When was face hunter(not undertaker hunter) a tier one deck?
On topic:
Freeze mage(beta)
Combo Druid(force+savage)
Zoo after Naxx release
Undertaker Hunter
Patron Warrior
Secret Paladin
Aggro/Midrange Shaman(both have been broken for over a year now, reason you don't see them more is because meta adapted to sort of counter them)
Pirate Warrior
Dragon Priest after MSOG(let people deny it all they want, but a midrange deck that manages to outvalue any other deck is NOT balanced)
Jade Druid