Hearthpwn

Madam Goya

Quote from Pullaa >>

Welp... I crafted the voraxx, I thought it would be good in paladin decks... Dusted it later on so basically my golden lanathel gave me only 400 dust... F-_k me... Fail of the year

No way!! I had an awesome deck with The Voraxx and Lynessa Sunsorrow... Spikeridged Steed on The Voraxx was bonkers... 32 stats for 10 mana... Buff Paladin was one of my favorite archetypes of all time.

Kragwa the Frog

Quote from Horkinger >>

Princess Huhuran

At that time, deathrattle hunter did not work properly. And now, a rare does her job better.

 This was me as well. I only had Hunter cards then and enjoyed hand buffing my first pack legendary King Krush. Good times, but a bad card. 

sindragosa

Leeroy Jenkins

Just think about him, his stats are terrible. Nobody use him as anything else then +1mana cost fireball.

(But i still hope he will go to HoF.)

Leeroy Jenkins is one of the most powerful cards ever printed! A 5 mana fireball attached to a minion you can buff is really good. Classes are purposely designed in specific ways, like how Warlock is supposed to have little burst damage (which is why Doomguard was moved to HoF). Leeroy breaks that pattern and gives classes access to burn damage they shouldn't have. He's a finisher that can fit in almost every Aggro deck or Midrange deck. For reference, he used to cost 4 mana, but was nerfed, and is still sooooo good. Don't sleep on Leeroy

Don Hancho

The Darkness

1600 dust to trash

Quote from Oireal >>

Leeroy Jenkins is one of the most powerful cards ever printed! A 5 mana fireball attached to a minion you can buff is really good. Classes are purposely designed in specific ways, like how Warlock is supposed to have little burst damage (which is why Doomguard was moved to HoF). Leeroy breaks that pattern and gives classes access to burn damage they shouldn't have. He's a finisher that can fit in almost every Aggro deck or Midrange deck. For reference, he used to cost 4 mana, but was nerfed, and is still sooooo good. Don't sleep on Leeroy

 You don't get what i am saying. I am not saying he don't have abilities about which you talking, i am talking about how powerfull is card standalone. And there are only few worse standalone cards. (And because they are not played i didn't craft them either.)

Before the leaching poison nerf, I crafted lorewalker cho for my kingsbane mill rogue.

Quote from Qwert >>

Quote from Oireal >>

Leeroy Jenkins is one of the most powerful cards ever printed! A 5 mana fireball attached to a minion you can buff is really good. Classes are purposely designed in specific ways, like how Warlock is supposed to have little burst damage (which is why Doomguard was moved to HoF). Leeroy breaks that pattern and gives classes access to burn damage they shouldn't have. He's a finisher that can fit in almost every Aggro deck or Midrange deck. For reference, he used to cost 4 mana, but was nerfed, and is still sooooo good. Don't sleep on Leeroy

 You don't get what i am saying. I am not saying he don't have abilities about which you talking, i am talking about how powerfull is card standalone. And there are only few worse standalone cards. (And because they are not played i didn't craft them either.)

 This doesn't make sense.. He's a 6 attack with charge, that costs 5 mana... Those are the only stats that matter... He can do 6 to 12 damage to face on the turn he is played... Stand alone, or next to other cards... That is amazing... You can only compare his stat line to other Charge cards.

Are you trying to say he's bad, because it's 8 stats for 5 mana? Because that is not how value works... You have to include "worst case scenario"... Like if someone shuffles crap in your deck, Zephyrs isn't 5 stat vanilla card... But, no matter what happens... Leeroy is still a 6 attack, buffable Charge minion.

Doomguard had bigger stats, but originally, his "downside" of Discards was worse than "summoning 2 1/1 minions for your opponent"... But then Skull of the Man'ari made it too easy to cheat them out... Not to mention, they were Epic, so you could carry 2... Plus they were easy to cube for 15 damage in one turn... So, they went HOF.

"Standalone" in this case would mean without the ability to cheat anything out... So, in this case, I'd say Leeroy is better than Doomguard, because cost/attack are the only stats that matter in a Charge card.

Lady in White

Skeleton knight. I’m really in to silly deathrattle shenanigans 

Not sure about the worst one, but I did craft Shudderwock and Grumble the day after new expansion came out. Those were fun days

Sergeant Sally for Handbufflock... xd

Mayor Noggenfogger. Thought his ability would make minions attack minion on each side of the board (like misdirection/mass hysteria). Turned out it was just a random enemy.

Goodbye, dust.

Splintergraft

Thats actually the reason some play HS,i crafted them as well and still enjoy playing them.i crafted even the new 3 mana neutral legendary dragon , and 2 weponized pinatas.its cool to have some meme decks,even if they never fit the metas

I think I decided I wanted to play Kingsbane Rogue.  So I crafted the Hero.  I think I played one game with it, then decided it wasn't for me.  It happens a lot that I THINK I want to play Rogue, then I do and I find I don't really.

Sometimes I just try a new deck out and go against a bad matchup or someone that gets the nuts and I just give up after one try.  It's a personal failing.  Happened again with Galakrond Shaman, I tried it out post nerf and matched up against a deathrattle rogue that went bonkers and decided Galakrond Shaman sucked.  (I think most decks would have lost that match though)