Hearthpwn

Quote from Whiskey_Jack >>

Ice Block
Gadgetzan Auctioneer
Malygos
Doomsayer
Leeroy Jenkins

Those 5 cards are probably most likely includes in HoF, IMO, since they limit design space or encourage broken archetypes.

I don't think Shadowstep will be sent to HoF; it would make the Quest Rogue much less viable, and it's not even a broken deck anymore. Class minion legendaries are probably safe too...VanCleef and Tirion while powerful, do not define their deck and are not even auto-includes.

What they are going to do is rotate Wild into being the "standard" ladder for most players. 

If the change too much, players will just migrate to Wild. 

Take Ice Block for instance. Even though I can't stand Exodia Mage ... removing Ice Block effectively kills that deck, and effectively makes the mage quest, and Archmage useless cards. (I know Leyline has made a questless exodia possible now, but I am assuming it still relies on Ice Block). 

I kinda hate to say it ... but the game is pretty much busted as a whole, and unless they want to consider a complete overhaul, then just picking off a few of the numerous OP card interactions would just be silly. IMHO, fix it all, or leave it all as is. 

Ice Block

Brawl

Shadowstep

Savage Roar

HOF the entire Warrior class because it as well as doesnt exist nowadays on ladder

If they will HoF anything, they will do it in a similar way they did before (power level/desing space). As sad as it sounds (at least for me), if they are going to rotate something out, it would probably be Bloodmage Thalnos. If you have a deck with at least 2-3 burst spells, you can include that card and roll it. I see the skinny guy almost everywhere and he's been in  at least one Tier 1 deck in pretty much every meta in the last year.

Nobody mentioned Thalnos. I'm up for it, the more the better, more dust for me. I play Wild anyway xD

Quote from One_Man_Army >>

Ice Block

Brawl

Shadowstep

Savage Roar

 

Move to HOF the followings:

Cancermare
Skillbane
Patches
Iceblock
Hunter
Jades

Thanks.

HOFing Doomguard would be a very risky proposition for Blizzard. They've just encouraged many of us to spend dust on a whole raft of cards to craft Cubelock decks so they would lose A LOT of goodwill from their player base if they were to nerf the deck so quickly.

Other than being a charge minion that can be cheated out very easily, Doomguard I think has the issue of restricting card design from here until the rotation after this one. 

Something very easily could make it broken with lackey, cube, gul’dan and Umbra already existing. 

Quote from TheHoodedClaw >>

HOFing Doomguard would be a very risky proposition for Blizzard. They've just encouraged many of us to spend dust on a whole raft of cards to craft Cubelock decks so they would lose A LOT of goodwill from their player base if they were to nerf the deck so quickly.

As fun and hard as it is to pull it off, it does feel a little broken. I blame Faceless Manipulator though, not Malygos. I think I would rather see faceless manipulator HOF'ed than malygos, as its used in all sorts of decks, although its not quite on the same level as azure drake or ragnaros.

Quote from scorpyon >>

Wait, where are the HOF for Northshire Cleric and Mana Wyrm exactly? These two cards should have gone out with Tunnel Trogg, but somehow managed to escape the cut back then and it was a huge misstep from Blizzard.

Personally i think Spellbreaker might go and then blizzard will replace it with conditional silence effect. 

For example silence an death rattle or silence if your holding an dragon. so you will have to run them if you want silence or use Ironbeak Owl again.

Leeroy has been my pick for awhile. First list I've seen. I think that is right after gadgetzan in probability

I don't see a case for a single card on your list, besides salt, of course.

Ice Block
Leeroy Jenkins
Doomguard
Bloodmage Thalnos

They would have rotated Leeroy and Thalnos last time.  Why now?