Hearthpwn

Quote from Flesch >>

Quote from Kibelas >>

That's actually one of the reason my friend i showed this game quit.

 MEGALUL if this is true. Quitting the game for a case that happens 1/1000 games.

Quote from Flesch >>

Quote from Kibelas >>

That's actually one of the reason my friend i showed this game quit.

 MEGALUL if this is true. Quitting the game for a case that happens 1/1000 games.

I agree with OP. Many C'Thun interactions are incoherent to say the least, wording is very very poor (Doomcaller's battlecry not activating if C'Thun is stolen is silly) and that's a big no for a game that claims to be competitive.

The card for at checks if the buffed C'thun of the Player is above 10 OR the C'thun itself is above 10 disguised toast made a video about it.

Quote from Ashaf306 >>

When your C'Thuns get buffed, your C'Thuns get buffed. You can't nerf or silence your C'Thuns man. That ain't right.

Quote from Ashaf306 >>

When your C'Thuns get buffed, your C'Thuns get buffed. You can't nerf or silence your C'Thuns man. That ain't right.

Quote from KeMT >>

Quote from Kibelas >>

That's actually one of the reason my friend i showed this game quit.

 After spending 5 hours of watching twitch streams and reading twitch retard chat today, I thought I've already read the most stupid things for the day ... I was wrong ...

Quitting something because one don't understand how it works is not an argument that should be used in any conversation ... Ever ... Unless you're 7 years old

Quote from HavvkPwn >>

Quote from GiantDwarf0 >>

The card works the way it is supposed to.  Now, is the 10/10 trigger remotely appropriate given how easy that is to pull off?  Of course not, but we can't really expect blizzard to actually balance the game.

 This! 10 is just too low, too easily achieved for being a relevant trigger limit, making AS a bit OP. This goes for the Twin Emperor as well btw, but at least he's a legendary ^^

The real problem is "how the hell can C'Thun synergy work without C'Thun"? It should at least require it to exist in the deck/hand/dead pile.

Quote from rudeteenager >>

Dang man cant believe your friend was so mad about that he quit the game. Just like that. Crazy

Quote from rudeteenager >>

Dang man cant believe your friend was so mad about that he quit the game. Just like that. Crazy

Quote from dread05 >>

Really with all these arguments going around, just watch disguised toast's video I posted earlier. He explains every little C'thun interaction.

Quote from Rozenhal >>

I agree with OP. Many C'Thun interactions are incoherent to say the least, wording is very very poor (Doomcaller's battlecry not activating if C'Thun is stolen is silly) and that's a big no for a game that claims to be competitive.

Quote from MvonTzeskagrad >>

The real problem is "how the hell can C'Thun synergy work without C'Thun"? It should at least require it to exist in the deck/hand/dead pile.

I would have thought that he would quit just because of how frustrating Ancient Shieldbearer is to play against. 

10 armor for 1.5 mana is preeeetty dumb. 

So I'm still new to this form and just learned how to reply back to where the individual can see I'm replying to them. My posts about immaturity etc. are in regards to the few people who only came on here to call people names. They don't care about mature discussion only name calling and disrespect. O well you have to expect in a huge forum like this for some people to be hateful or trolls.

Thank you everyone!

Quote from Piterik >>

dude 1st day of ladder and meta is 100% aggro there is 0 C Thun warriros only aggro shamans zoolocks and aggro Hunters.

Quote from Ehronatha >>

I would have thought that he would quit just because of how frustrating Ancient Shieldbearer is to play against. 

10 armor for 1.5 mana is preeeetty dumb. 

Cthun buffs are a global effect. If you play mtg, think of each +1/+1 buff as one enchantment. Even though cthun is silenced it still gets buffs from a seperate source.

The expansion is titled "Whispers of the Old Gods" and C'Thun is a God, the card/minion is simply his Avatar.  I'm pretty sure the mechanic is working as intended and it wasn't just lazy programming.

Quote from Kibelas >>

Quote from Piterik >>

dude 1st day of ladder and meta is 100% aggro there is 0 C Thun warriros only aggro shamans zoolocks and aggro Hunters.

 That's not accurate. This discussion is not only about cthun. The new people I bring don't just quit because of Cthun. That only adds to it when they are new playing against gold hero's which is not balanced and very unfair. My friend Watashi for instance... tried rank... 4 games in a row someone with a gold hero power. So would you say that is balanced or not? Would you say that would make new players want to stay around or not?

As others have said, the stats of C'Thun are hardcoded to the player not the minion and it should be. There are so many reasons, you're building an entire deck around C'Thun so it would be far too devastating if you could just gimp that players entire deck by silencing C'Thun or stealing the hardcoded stats with something like Sylvannas/Entomb etc.