Hearthpwn

I'm fairly a new player and like like playing control decks and I was wondering which card should I be crafting first

I'm going to say Sylvanas first, because it fits in every non-Freeze Mage control deck fairly well.  Ysera can be phased out of an overly aggressive meta and Justicar is only mandatory in priest and warrior.

NOONE VOTED YSERA :D

I wouldn't craft anything yet, unless you want to jump straight into control decks. My advice would be to wait for standard, let the new meta develop a bit because (hopefully) it will be a more slow paced, control meta. After that, you'll probably know what legendary to craft. However if u do want a legendary now, I would go with Justicar if you're planning on playing control warrior or priest and sylvannas if otherwise.

I agree

To quote myself: A shit deck with Sylvanas in it is still a shit deck.

1600 dust can get you quite far, but getting a legendary just to have it is not very effective.

So... Please post your current deck list. You say you like Control decks, but there's a huge variety, especially in Warrior and Priest. If we know what you currently play, we can tell you what cards you need to make that deck better.

For example, even if the vote says Justicar, that's a bad idea if your favorite control deck is Reno Freeze Mage.

I would have to agree with these people that you should wait until the expansion and nerfs to see exactly what you want to play in the formats that you want to play in (most likely standard if you are fairly new).