Hearthpwn

Quote from LucasPassado >>

Quote from Hackergrad >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from TheWamts >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Hackergrad >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

No, I think Paladin is perfect.

Okay. You scratch my back and I'll scratch yours.

Here's my card.

 Why would i want to pay 8 mana for 12hp heal that WILL lose me the game? Immune to effects doesnt seem to be so valuable, what effects would that be? Like battlecries? And is it suppose to protect the hero or the weapon from being destroyed? Very unclear :x

Think of the card as reducing your heroes health to 1, but give your hero 11 Divine Shields.

 Right ok, i kinda didnt realize that any dmg would be reduced to "one", that makes it a lot better, but what about the immune part? What do u mean by that?

Acidic Swamp Ooze, Bloodsail Corsair, Sabotage and Harrison Jones has no effect on it.

 But Harrison Jones draws the cards, right?

Quote from Hackergrad >>

[Snip]
It does not.

This is a perfectly fine card that does exactly what it states. If you have this minion on the board, and your hero's health is reduced below zero, you lose the game. It ticks all the boxes for this week and it's balanced too.

I have no idea how this is branded as a troll entry. Maybe I forgot to include a white girl stereotype and a smartphone? Or is it that I'm not a mod?

Quote from mk572 >>

This is a perfectly fine card that does exactly what it states. If you have this minion on the board, and your hero's health is reduced below zero, you lose the game. It ticks all the boxes for this week and it's balanced too.

I have no idea how this is branded as a troll entry. Maybe I forgot to include a white girl stereotype and a smartphone? Or is it that I'm not a mod?

Quote from Hackergrad >>

Quote from LucasPassado >>

Quote from Hackergrad >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from TheWamts >>

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from Hackergrad >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

No, I think Paladin is perfect.

Okay. You scratch my back and I'll scratch yours.

Here's my card.

 Why would i want to pay 8 mana for 12hp heal that WILL lose me the game? Immune to effects doesnt seem to be so valuable, what effects would that be? Like battlecries? And is it suppose to protect the hero or the weapon from being destroyed? Very unclear :x

Think of the card as reducing your heroes health to 1, but give your hero 11 Divine Shields.

 Right ok, i kinda didnt realize that any dmg would be reduced to "one", that makes it a lot better, but what about the immune part? What do u mean by that?

Acidic Swamp Ooze, Bloodsail Corsair, Sabotage and Harrison Jones has no effect on it.

 But Harrison Jones draws the cards, right?

It does not.

Quote from Sinti >>

Quote from mk572 >>

This is a perfectly fine card that does exactly what it states. If you have this minion on the board, and your hero's health is reduced below zero, you lose the game. It ticks all the boxes for this week and it's balanced too.

I have no idea how this is branded as a troll entry. Maybe I forgot to include a white girl stereotype and a smartphone? Or is it that I'm not a mod?

 Very funny card, it made me laugh, good job! :) but i wouldnt want it in finals anyway tho, if it were me, just sayin ;-)

FYI no rarity is wierd :P

All right, submissions are now over. You now have the next 2 hours for some final upvoting before the final poll. :)

Quote from RenoJackson >>

 

[...]

 

 Well, it doesn't really tick all the boxes for the competition: "Your card must, under some condition, explicitly lose you the game."

This card itself can't lose you the game (which is what the contest rules require), it just states a pre-existing rule that loses you the game.

Quote from mk572 >>

This is a perfectly fine card that does exactly what it states. If you have this minion on the board, and your hero's health is reduced below zero, you lose the game. It ticks all the boxes for this week and it's balanced too.

I have no idea how this is branded as a troll entry. Maybe I forgot to include a white girl stereotype and a smartphone? Or is it that I'm not a mod?

Quote from mk572 >>

This is a perfectly fine card that does exactly what it states. If you have this minion on the board, and your hero's health is reduced below zero, you lose the game. It ticks all the boxes for this week and it's balanced too.

I have no idea how this is branded as a troll entry. Maybe I forgot to include a white girl stereotype and a smartphone? Or is it that I'm not a mod?

Quote from ScaryKoolaid >>

Quote from mk572 >>

This is a perfectly fine card that does exactly what it states. If you have this minion on the board, and your hero's health is reduced below zero, you lose the game. It ticks all the boxes for this week and it's balanced too.

I have no idea how this is branded as a troll entry. Maybe I forgot to include a white girl stereotype and a smartphone? Or is it that I'm not a mod?

 I think the argument is "Wight Girl" actually did something relevant within the rules. Captain Obvious is funny, but it's effect doesn't do anything until and unless there's ever a card that says "You don't lose the game for having 0 or less Health." This card is more akin to the Optimistic Ogre card that was in the Giant contest with the play on typical Ogre wording. This is basically just Spider Tank without Mech?

Quote from Shnayzr >>

what do think about this card?  initially it was draw 3 cards, but then players will go for a build of all minions/spells of cost 10+ to guarantee a win at turn 10 but that will make them have low defence at the start of the game.

do you think 2 or 3 is better?

Quote from Veggente >>

Quote from ScaryKoolaid >>

Quote from mk572 >>

This is a perfectly fine card that does exactly what it states. If you have this minion on the board, and your hero's health is reduced below zero, you lose the game. It ticks all the boxes for this week and it's balanced too.

I have no idea how this is branded as a troll entry. Maybe I forgot to include a white girl stereotype and a smartphone? Or is it that I'm not a mod?

 I think the argument is "Wight Girl" actually did something relevant within the rules. Captain Obvious is funny, but it's effect doesn't do anything until and unless there's ever a card that says "You don't lose the game for having 0 or less Health." This card is more akin to the Optimistic Ogre card that was in the Giant contest with the play on typical Ogre wording. This is basically just Spider Tank without Mech?

 I'm wrong, or this card kill you if you have 1-2hp and trigger an explosive trap using Truesilver Champion?

Quote from LucasPassado >>

Quote from ShadowsOfSense >>

All right, submissions are now over. You now have the next 2 hours for some final upvoting before the final poll. :)

 wtf? Already? I couldn't submit it, I just saw it today, you guys should warn us in the front page, very small time to submit.

All right then, the final poll topic is now up! Go ahead and vote on your favourite entries that made it into the finals.