Weekly Card Design Competition #34 - FINALIST POLL
Poll: Competition #34 - HOUSE OF DISCARDS
Log in with your Curse username to vote in this poll.
Competition #34 - HOUSE OF DISCARDS - Multiple Choice
- "Wrathion" by PookieJunk 15.5% of Users - 70 votes
- "Voidbringer" by superoutman 13.2% of Users - 60 votes
- "Lil' Librarist" by Telefonkabel 10.4% of Users - 47 votes
- "Corrupted Blue Whelp" by VenusCity 7.3% of Users - 33 votes
- "Rain of Arrows" by nobravery 22.7% of Users - 103 votes
- "Confused Treant" by Kheesan 17% of Users - 77 votes
- "Dreaming Whelp" by Beesman93 10.6% of Users - 48 votes
- "Presence of Mind" by modded 11.5% of Users - 52 votes
- "Gillok Darkeye" by nurgling13 9.3% of Users - 42 votes
- "Enraged Treant" by Hatchie_47 6.4% of Users - 29 votes
- "Adrenaline Rush" by Zeppo122 17.7% of Users - 80 votes
- "Soul Jar" by ManyCookies 13.7% of Users - 62 votes
- "Mannoroth" by BOOSHACK360 10.2% of Users - 46 votes
- "Imp Lord Pinprik" by ProjectHS 9.1% of Users - 41 votes
- "Bildros Nullvoid" by Maedhros5 7.5% of Users - 34 votes
- "Gordunni Warlock" by Aizai88 8.4% of Users - 38 votes
- "Kalecgos" by X1l3nc3d 10.6% of Users - 48 votes
- "Divine knowledge" by matrixmr5 8.6% of Users - 39 votes
- "Undead Menace" by Machinae 7.5% of Users - 34 votes
- "Enslaved Demon" by Zukuu 14.8% of Users - 67 votes
- "Jadefire Satyr" by Gabriel_the_angelfire 4.2% of Users - 19 votes
- "Blood Moon" by ttBIGGER 9.3% of Users - 42 votes
- "Victory or Death" by Hassashu 11.7% of Users - 53 votes
- "Presence of Mind" by Lord_HS 9.3% of Users - 42 votes
- "Mysterious Egg" by Shnayzr 7.7% of Users - 35 votes
- "Poisonmist Totem" by Keghumper 8.2% of Users - 37 votes
- "The Maelstrom" by Vegust 10.6% of Users - 48 votes
- "Metamorphosis" by crowman1337 5.1% of Users - 23 votes
- "Doubling Pod" by hauauftastatur 16.3% of Users - 74 votes
- "Kil'Jaeden" by cheesytwiglets 22.3% of Users - 101 votes
Ended Oct 1, 2015
Posts Quoted:
Reply
Clear All Quotes
Holy jeez that is a lot of entries. tl;dr
5 second thought: Could we split the vote into two separate 15 card polls? Like give each one 12 hours to be voted on, then do a 12 hour poll between the two finalists? That might be more easily processed for peeps.
12 hours isn't long enough, given there are people all over the world. A 12 hour poll is pretty much guaranteed to fall at a bad time for some people.
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
My first time participating in this and when I saw my entry actually got some upvotes I thought I had a chance. Turns out, you need a lot more than a couple! Oh well, better luck next time.
Decided to vote for Blood Moon, sort of a Lock and Load for a Warlock discard deck. Neat.
Well, what I'd like to do is to just go with top 20 according to formula and have that be it, but that makes things even more brutal. Because the formula is weighted by page, people usually just keep track of their own page to see how their odds are of going to the finals. Unfortunately, if we go formula-only, that means that people who got first on their page can still end up not making it, which folks really hate because it means having to also look at how every other page is doing. That's why we now have the guarantee where if you're first on your page then you definitely become a finalist. And that means we have to have at least one finalist per page. We can probably get away with not counting pages that don't have more than 10 valid submissions, but either way when we have a hugely popular contest like this that still means a ton of finalists. =P
Sad to see that I had several people message me saying my card Mannoroth was probably going to win while by the looks of things I won't even get a top 3 ranking :(
My submission for this week's Weekly Card Design Competition, Paper Airplane!
It's impossible to predict these competitions. I've seen people say things like that before, and they never end up being right. Just getting to the finals is an accomplishment, though. Only a little more than 1 in 20 entries do when we have this many submissions.
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
At first the card seems rly cool and innovative, but in reality it kinda sucks. Sure doomguard might give u two cards or something like that, but u basicly lock yourself out of your hero power and that seems like more of a disadvantage, especially since this is a 6 mana card, that will be contested with some other top tier legendaries out there. I dont see this being in any serious deck, but it would be fun card to have, thats for sure ;-)
Im also kinda sad, that Imp Lord Lipnik is not doing better, i havent been excited about a finalist like this one in a looong time :) but Wrathion that is in lead is also pretty cool, if we forget the fact, that if it did exactly what the card says and not what author intended, it would be pretty broken :D
- Click Here To Join Us On Discord! -
Haha I've entered 8 times and been in the finals 5. Dunno if that gives me bragging rights though...but yolo.
My submission for this week's Weekly Card Design Competition, Paper Airplane!
Competed for the first time and missed the final round by 1 vote. Too bad, before I went to bed I was still leading... Ah well. Unfortunately none of my favorites went on to the final either, so I went with Victory or Death. It just captures the flavor of Warrior really well.
If you're getting to the finals consistently, you're doing something right.
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
30...really big number...imp 20-23 is enough :-)
Because there're 26 pages this week, and the one gets most upvotes on each page should be in the final poll.
THERE IS NO GAME.
My vote goes to Rain of Arrows, I absolutely love the simple elegance of it, making unused cards playable (sorta)
@nobravery but i notice a few pages where about half posts were deleted, and the remainings didn't get many votes.... so is it about scores or pages?...
Finaly made it to the finals =D
I like how (in the original post) the related cards are just below the created cards, like Dreadsteed and such... can you also do that with the spoilers?
Pleas vote on my submission on the Weekly Card Design Competition: Fahrum Specter!
The way it's currently written definitely doesn't imply you would draw 3 cards, though. It doesn't say to put the card you choose plus two copies of it in your hand. It doesn't say anything about what you do with that card. If you really took the card literally, you might interpret it as putting that card back on top of your deck, but not putting three of it in your hand.
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition
I believe there was at least one Kil'Jaeden on every page of the submission thread. And almost as many Sargerases.
I wish I understood what people liked and upvoted. I feel like every week a number of the same people make it into the finals over and over with somewhat un-inspired designs. Its also just a bummer in general this week that sooooo many cards were effectively the same, I think it hurt some of the better options of those types. I think a least 1 of the "You pick which cards you discard" guys should have made it, and at least one of the, "When you discard shuffle it back in instead." But that is how it goes I guess, votes get diluted and things just end up missing the mark.
At least only one "opponent discards" card made it to the finals.
To crush your enemies, to see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentations of the women.
30 cards is too much and some people wont read all of them. what will happen when the submission thread reaches 50 pages? will you put 50 cards?
why you dont lock the submission thread when there is 18 pages so we have 18 cards + 2 of your choice.
so make the competition ends on Wednesday or when it reaches 18 pages, which comes first.
This is kind of a dumb suggestion. You're complaining that there are too many cards and trying to blame it on the mods for some reason instead of the 300+ people who submitted cards. Plus, a first come first serve design for the competition would incentivize people rushing through card design. And you want to cut people out of the competition because you are too lazy to read 30 cards.
Come Play Make the Keyword!!!
Check out my Worgen Class in the Class Competition