Hearthpwn

I love the flavor of backstabber's bluff, really good wild card pick.

Quote from PupleMD jump

I love the flavor of backstabber's bluff, really good wild card pick.

I would like it more for a class that already has weapon, so you would be "locked" out of it, if you wanted to keep that minion, in WL its just 4 mana mindcontrol rly :/

Quote from rdeegan jump

Quote from Sinti jump

Quote from PupleMD jump

I love the flavor of backstabber's bluff, really good wild card pick.

I would like it more for a class that already has weapon, so you would be "locked" out of it, if you wanted to keep that minion, in WL its just 4 mana mindcontrol rly :/

It's Rogue, isn't it?

Ah, ok .. in that case it is fine :)

Why do i have "predetermined" votes already? what is this lol? i didnt vote for some cards and my vote is already there, da fuq ?:D not that it rly matters, it just seems super wierd :D

Aw yeaz. Of course United Front is  the lead for the most popular one. Of course the most uninspired card gets to win this competition. UGH!

Yay my idea made it! Vote Soulburn (if you want) :D A lot of nice ideas here.

In regards to Soulburn, yes it puts you a mana crystal behind but it is intended to be run in a very slow deck and you get 4 random spells which is a HUGE benefit. Also if you draw this card late game it has no effect at all (you wouldn't play this early on anyway, it's intended to be played later on like Pyroblast/mind control). play it turn 10, you go down to 9, turn 10 comes again, no difference. It's certainly a card you would probably only run one of but the potential I feel is really good. 

I think i like only Backstabers Bluf and Consuming Fel Axe ... (rest is mostly wierd, totaly and utterly unbalanced or very inconsistent), with these two u know what u get and how to play it and around it and so on, good straightforward cards and reasonably balanced.

My thoughts

Soulburn - I think I'd rather shuffle 4 random spells into my opponents deck.  1/5

Rite of Summoning - Pretty good card.  huge combo'd with Malygos.  4/5

Polymorph Demon - I don't see the point.  Was this really the best card on the page?  1/5

Forbidden Knowledge - Seems like this could be a real card.  5/5

Pick Pocket - Modest hand destruction.  I like it.  Great anti-combo tech.  Imaginative.  5/5

Bribe - OP.  2/5  Should cost more like 7 or 8.

Graphite Rod - I can never tell what class weapons are.  Is this a WArlock weapon?    I guess it's ok, no matter the class.  3/5

Monkey's Paw - Pretty strong effect, but, somewhat hard to get going.  I think it not being a copy of a card from your opponent's deck probably kills any chance it had.  1/5

Forest Vigilance - It's like a weaker Mind Vision.  I don't think it's good enough.  2/5

Bandit's Guile - Not sure we need another Vanish.  Probably just too many vanish effects like this would make mill rogue too strong.  2/5

Consuming Fel Axe - Seems like I saw this weapon 15 times.  I'm not sure on the balance would need to playtest, but, I'm leaning towards OP. 3/5

United Front - Wow.  I like that it's epic so that it doens't dominate Arena.  I don't know Im' worried that it's a little too good for fatigue pally, but, maybe fatigue pally needs some help.  I'll say 4/5.

Hellreaver - I hate to nitpick, but I don't think this qualifies by the rules.  If you are playing warlock, this card is in capable of giving a player a class card that it cannot normally cast.  0/5

Arsenal - I think the combo part just makes this OP.  2/5

Arcane Knowledge - Interesting take on Gang up.  Looks like it could be a real card, but It's hard to judge potential abuse off the top of my head.  4/5

Dalaran Assistance - Kinda silly, I doubt that you could even play this in secret paladin.  Just too costly for such a situational effect IMHO.  3/5

Elemental Call - I find this one kinda booring, and I think I've seen it before.  Surprised that folks voted it in.  3/5

Enchant Weapon - I think this is too good.  You're probably going to get at least 3 instant damage and probably at least 6 more over time.  and that's on the low end.  You get Doomhammer and you have 27 points of damage on the board on turn 5.  2/5

Power Word Vision - I wish there was a more verbose way to word this, but, I'm not sure that there is.  Just the priest version of Blessing of Wisdom, seems like a real card to me.  4/5

Visitors of the DReamer - Nice all around card.  4/5

Drakewood Summoning - I'm not sure why this should cost less than the one that turns them into 2/2s.  3/5

Backstabber's Bluff - Fun card, very imaginative.  Love the flavor.  Seems a bit undercosted to me though.  If you grab an opposing Ragnaros who cares if it can't attack, and with all the taunt and inspire cards you can quite easily not worry about the can't attack drawback.  I'd either up the cost quite a bit or have them be removed from play while this is in play.  4/5

My vote goes to Forbidden Knowledge.  It just seems like it was lifted from the brains of Hearthstone card makers.

Some really interesting finalists this time. I don't know if it's just me, but I can't tell what class Graphite Rod and Monkey's Paw are for. Are they Warlock weapons or Rogue weapons? The actual cards themselves aren't really helping me figure it out.

In response to critique of my own card, the RNG element of it is very controlled, as most mana slots have few dragons you can obtain, and the purpose of it isn't to have a war with the opponent to see who gets better dragons, but to control the board to force your opponent to get either no dragons (and you get a heal on your guys) or the 3 mana 3/3 dragon. The reason it costs less than Poison Seeds is to account for the situations where you have to give your opponent a large dragon, instead of the 2/2 they would have gotten otherwise.

As it stands, I really like Backstabber's Bluff, Forbidden Knowledge and Bribe the most - Bribe and Backstabber's Bluff especially seem to fit into their classes very well, and are named fantastically.