Hearthpwn

Whew, that's a lot of posts. Here we go:

Quote from mdjgcks >>

As someone pointed out, this card does not have Reborn itself so would not qualify. There are a few other things, as well. You forgot to select a class. Is it Paladin? Shaman? And as for balance I'd probably give this a 3/2. You pretty much lock in your board *twice* at 3/2 with this card. That's already insane. It's like two better Soul of the Murlocs in one card, plus a 2.5 mana weapon. This might honestly be better at 6 mana, just for balance's sake.

Quote from FailURGamer >>

Ok, please review the posting tutorial in the opening post on how to put images in a post.

Second, I can only assume your card was meant to be a weapon so I recreated it for you. I didn't find the exact art so here is a replacement.

Quote from Kinggo >>

 

Yeah, like others have said, this won't work. At 0 mana, however, this card becomes very interesting. I wouldn't mind seeing this card at 0 mana honestly, gives a big incentive for Token/Totem Shaman, especially with the new EVIL Totem as a follow up on turn 2. While it's a 0 mana with a big upside, a 1/1 is honestly small enough of an impact that I think it could work. Now *that*, I think, would be interesting.

Quote from MrBurger >>

This is an excellent concept. It's smart and clean. But, yeah, someone pointed out it's paladin. In my opinion, I would also put this at 2/2. 3/1 is rather aggressive for a magnetic effect at 3 mana.

Quote from ArcyroX >>

Yeahhh it's perma-Reborn, haha. Back to the drawing board, unfortunately. It is also not a valid card. If you do a Neutral minion, it must cost 7 or more.

Quote from DarkArtisan >>

Deal 10, heal 10, summon 8/4 in stats, all at 8 mana. Hmmmm. I would like to see this at 4/4, so it's more in line with Walking Fountain. They would both damage and heal the same while your card has a lot of tokens while Walking Fountain can live for next turn.

Quote from Hoez >>

Don't forget to use postimages or another external site, unless you don't mind your card vanishing after a week or so. If you do not re-host using postimages, the hearthcards.net server purges all cards regularly to save space.

As for the card itself, it's weak. Definitely needs a lot more stats. I'd give it a 6/12 or something. 

Quote from Hoez >>

Hmmmm not bad. Could be a very powerful tool to refill your hand in Quest Druid. Would like to see better art (this looks like a generic fantasy character on a very bland background) and better formatting on the card. You have a random empty line and forgot the period.

Quote from Hoez >>

I think this is too similar to Colossus of the Moon with a lot less stats. Would have to be a 7/7 to even compete with Tirion. I think this card could be more interesting, though, instead of just 3 keywords, especially when another in-game legendary has two of those on it already.

It's also a Paladin card, and that does not qualify. Please double-check the rules in the opening post.

Quote from simonsald >>

Hmmmm I like this! It's perfectly balanced. Too bad Blizzard doesn't reuse Recruit. While this card is fine as-is, if you want to be more authentic, just simply replace "Recruit" with summon.

Well this is all going very nicely! Here’s a quick blanket announcement;

We do have a fan creation section of the Hearthpwn Discord as well!

That being said, gonna do some @‘s of my own...

@Lordinaryus I think technically a Reborn aura would mean they would regain the reborn once they died, effectively making all Wisps a psuedo-Dreadsteed. I’d recommend you either give wisps Reborn on summon, or have it lose health per summon like Imp Master.

@Hoez Per the rules we stick to the nine classes and neutrals for weeklies and tackle new classes in a seperate comp.

@Simonsaid The concept’s neat, the balance is maybe a bit too undercosted; However even with the addition of SN1P-SN4P we don’t see new keywords over past watermarks. SN1P-SN4P lacks a watermark, so in the vein of consistency I’d recommend dropping the witchwood tag.

@DarkArtisan I like it conceptually but it feels like an extremely overtuned boardswing. Compare it to Shirvallah the Tiger, which only upticks your health by 7, leaves a 7/5 lifesteal body and requires a decent amount of lead-up to play; some games you’re locked out of your loa entirely. This offers a potential 10 health swing AND leaves a 8/4 body (admittedly a split one) for 8m in neutral. I like both Lifesteal and Squashlings as a Horseman concept, I just they’re too much together. 

@ArcyroX I think Reborn with a Tar Creeper twist is really fun and great conceptually. Not sure it’d get me to play Wasteland Assassin though.

@MrBurger This busts Kangor’s Endless Army on paper but I like it, I’m pretty sure it’s fine. 

@Kinggo Imma say it, this would be fine at 1 mana. Since Reborn doesn’t stack, most you could do is gain like two charges in one turn it’s not pulling any Dreadsteed shenanigans and it’s probably safe, if a bit frustrating, as a turn one “semi-infinite” totem.

All this is looking great, keep up the good work!