I like Flame Sigil at most. Shade of Aran is kinda too similar to Swampqueen Hagatha, and Glubtok problem is that duplicates in deck aren't realy a problem, beside not being able to use with Reno. Also, I don't like Glubtok art.
@YoutThunder
Nice concept, but I'm not sure if three isn't to much.
Just a couple ideas I had off the bat, let me know what ya'll think, i'll try to leave reviews when I have time to look at cards! Im not sure if Tranquility works for this comp but my thought is it pushes beast druid because why include the card if you're not playing beasts but idk if that leap in logic works for this.
Nice idea, but Priest doesn't have the support for it. I'd make it a Rogue card.
@Wailor:
Thank you for the suggestion. I considered a Rogue version...."Minion Trafficking" but I kept it a Priest card because 1) I'm stubborn ;) , 2) because I feel support does exist for this concept, & 3) I wanted to also incorporate an auxiliary function for the card in the form of countering Rogue deck stacking.
Perhaps we wouldn't just drop this card into a Standard deck like this one that's been making the rounds but it illustrates the potential.
Lady Deathwhisper asks a lot but I would definitely build this deck. Witchwood Piper might guest star.
Soul Searcher is interesting to me (I enjoy seeing rarities given in-game utility) but the design will likely lead to a sketchy result that doesn't make the restriction feel worth it, even with the glimpse at some of their deck ... #thatfeelingwhen you play Thoughtsteal and pull weapon buffs. At least with Thoughtsteal it might buff your Spellstones.
Keeper Remulos is turned to 11. It is effectively Twinspell for free. The restriction is in line with the challenge but when compared against Odd & Even decks' hero power boost, they didn't gain this level of upside at the Start of Game.
Lady Deathwhisper is interesting and well-balanced, actually a really good idea.
Soul Researcher is strange...because most of the time, your opponent's spells have a lot of class synergy and will be pretty useless for priest, also, some classes' spells are bad on their own compared to priest spells. I wouldn't go with that one.
Keeper Remulos is cool too, i don't think it's too OP, because Remulos is useless himself and deck restriction is pretty heavy. I prefer Remulos among others.
I think that idea is good, but maybe Shatterstar have right about being similar to Rogue Quest. Even if that doesn't realy bother me, it can matter to some people. Maybe try to improve it somehow, but I think you should try with this idea, because its pretty good. Also, I'm not sure because there's not such card in game, but I think that 'Summon a 1/1 Imp" should be before Start of Game. (unless you want to summon it at the start of game, what's definetly OP, and also I don't like when card does literally nothing when played)
Lady Deathwhisper asks a lot but I would definitely build this deck. Witchwood Piper might guest star.
Soul Searcher is interesting to me (I enjoy seeing rarities given in-game utility) but the design will likely lead to a sketchy result that doesn't make the restriction feel worth it, even with the glimpse at some of their deck ... #thatfeelingwhen you play Thoughtsteal and pull weapon buffs. At least with Thoughtsteal it might buff your Spellstones.
Keeper Remulos is turned to 11. It is effectively Twinspell for free. The restriction is in line with the challenge but when compared against Odd & Even decks' hero power boost, they didn't gain this level of upside at the Start of Game.
Thanks for the feedback, even though it looks like you’ve already submitted for this comp. I’ll try to return the favor next week.
Lady Deathwhisper is interesting and well-balanced, actually a really good idea.
Soul Researcher is strange...because most of the time, your opponent's spells have a lot of class synergy and will be pretty useless for priest, also, some classes' spells are bad on their own compared to priest spells. I wouldn't go with that one.
Keeper Remulos is cool too, i don't think it's too OP, because Remulos is useless himself and deck restriction is pretty heavy. I prefer Remulos among others.
Reposting my card here for more feedback:
Mixed feelings about this one, but I lean toward intrigued. While I agree that the effect is a bit too much like quest rogue, I really like that it creates a brand-new archetype for warlock. I think I would upvote on that basis alone.
Feedbacking other cards on this page to see if I can get a little more feedback on my cards:
Just a couple ideas I had off the bat, let me know what ya'll think, i'll try to leave reviews when I have time to look at cards! Im not sure if Tranquility works for this comp but my thought is it pushes beast druid because why include the card if you're not playing beasts but idk if that leap in logic works for this.
Joy Ride, easily. I would however change the second half to “If your deck has only Mechs, cast this again.” Btw, did you mean for the deck restriction to be all cards, or just all minions? Otherwise I think it’s way too restrictive, even nullifying itself if you run two copies.
Reposting my previous idea, with an slight variation of it.
While I like The Wereloc's flavor better, I find it very idiotic that his battlecry would trigger every time you play him.
Btw, if I drop the Murloc-only condition, would these cards still be valid?
I guess I don’t see the upside to either of these cards. I suppose there’s some synergy with cards that tutor Murlocs into your hand, but otherwise you’re just putting a bunch of Pit Fighters in your deck. OK Royal Guards have slightly better stats, but it doesn’t seem worth the deckbuilding restrictions. What am I missing?
Hey all, I think this is qualifies. I like the theme and mechanic. It might work just to thin out a deck but mostly to go full aggro...I have a feeling we might miss that unloved step child 'full aggro'.
Thanks for all the feedback! I changed my card slighly to make less similar to the rogue quest (and work better with Call of the Void). Also changed wording as @MurderyUnicorn suggested.
"Ragnaros will be upset if he discovers that the EVIL league chose Nefarian over him."
Sorry if I'm posting too much, but as @GerVez0512 said (thanks for the feedback man!) I would like to know if this counts towards the theme. About making it a class card, I thought about it (Warrior), but as it upgrades Schemes I would like it to be Neutral. Didn't know Wrathion wasn't a Dragon BTW, thanks for the advice, I'll change it!
"Ragnaros will be upset if he discovers that the EVIL league chose Nefarian over him."
Sorry if I'm posting too much, but as @GerVez0512 said (thanks for the feedback man!) I would like to know if this counts towards the theme. About making it a class card, I thought about it (Warrior), but as it upgrades Schemes I would like it to be Neutral. Didn't know Wrathion wasn't a Dragon BTW, thanks for the advice, I'll change it!
I apologize for not saying something sooner, but I would say that it does not count toward the theme. This card does not require proper deck-building for the Battlecry to activate: you could generate/Discover one into your hand and still benefit. It's not a Prince Keleseth/Baku the Mooneater kind of card.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Behold, foolish interlopers! I am commanding this mortal to spread the will of the Scourge throughout the interwebs, encouraging you to seek out me, Archlich Kel'Thuzad! Now coming to you as the tenth class of Hearthstone!
I am a finalist in this Class Creation Competition, so if you could give it a look I would be greatly appreciative <3
"Ragnaros will be upset if he discovers that the EVIL league chose Nefarian over him."
Sorry if I'm posting too much, but as @GerVez0512 said (thanks for the feedback man!) I would like to know if this counts towards the theme. About making it a class card, I thought about it (Warrior), but as it upgrades Schemes I would like it to be Neutral. Didn't know Wrathion wasn't a Dragon BTW, thanks for the advice, I'll change it!
I apologize for not saying something sooner, but I would say that it does not count toward the theme. This card does not require proper deck-building for the Battlecry to activate: you could generate/Discover one into your hand and still benefit. It's not a Prince Keleseth/Baku the Mooneater kind of card.
Thanks for replying!
So if I say 'if a Scheme started in your deck' instead of 'if there's a Scheme in your hand or deck' would count?
"Ragnaros will be upset if he discovers that the EVIL league chose Nefarian over him."
Sorry if I'm posting too much, but as @GerVez0512 said (thanks for the feedback man!) I would like to know if this counts towards the theme. About making it a class card, I thought about it (Warrior), but as it upgrades Schemes I would like it to be Neutral. Didn't know Wrathion wasn't a Dragon BTW, thanks for the advice, I'll change it!
I apologize for not saying something sooner, but I would say that it does not count toward the theme. This card does not require proper deck-building for the Battlecry to activate: you could generate/Discover one into your hand and still benefit. It's not a Prince Keleseth/Baku the Mooneater kind of card.
Thanks for replying!
So if I say 'if a Scheme started in your deck' instead of 'if there's a Scheme in your hand or deck' would count?
I guess so? It's hard to to say where the line is between Yay and Nay, so in the interest of leniency it's better to say Yes.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Behold, foolish interlopers! I am commanding this mortal to spread the will of the Scourge throughout the interwebs, encouraging you to seek out me, Archlich Kel'Thuzad! Now coming to you as the tenth class of Hearthstone!
I am a finalist in this Class Creation Competition, so if you could give it a look I would be greatly appreciative <3
@mods, does my submission on page 4 count? It doesn't have an "if" like Reno Jackson and most other example cards, but neither does Blastmaster Boom. Here's the card:
@wailor hmm, I'm kinda in the same boat as you with my card. I was going on the basis that the soft cost of Corpsetaker. Without Blastmaster and the word 'if', as you point out, might have disqualified us both but since Blastmaster is an example, I can't see any issue: Both effects are non-functioning if the decks not built with specific cards (bombs/murlocs/1-Cost), then by degrees it's based of personal design.
Anyway: I was wondering about my card's art - should i change it, and importantly, can i change it? It's on page 4 for 2 days now. they all tell the story pretty well, but no2 is most hearthstoney. no3 is the current. Finding this 'martyr' art is tricky as not to be very Old Testament haha!
@wailor hmm, I'm kinda in the same boat as you with my card. I was going on the basis that the soft cost of Corpsetaker. Without Blastmaster and the word 'if', as you point out, might have disqualified us both but since Blastmaster is an example, I can't see any issue: Both effects are non-functioning if the decks not built with specific cards (bombs/murlocs/1-Cost), then by degrees it's based of personal design.
Anyway: I was wondering about my card's art - should i change it, and importantly, can i change it? It's on page 4 for 2 days now. they all tell the story pretty well, but no2 is most hearthstoney. no3 is the current. Finding this 'martyr' art is tricky as not to be very Old Testament haha!
I think you should change the art, and I'm pretty sure you can.
If you struggle to find one, just google "paladin wow artwork" and choose one which is being attacked or something like that.
Got it, thanks!
Just a couple ideas I had off the bat, let me know what ya'll think, i'll try to leave reviews when I have time to look at cards! Im not sure if Tranquility works for this comp but my thought is it pushes beast druid because why include the card if you're not playing beasts but idk if that leap in logic works for this.
Weekly Card Design Competition 10.15
Reposting my previous idea, with an slight variation of it.
While I like The Wereloc's flavor better, I find it very idiotic that his battlecry would trigger every time you play him.
Btw, if I drop the Murloc-only condition, would these cards still be valid?
@Wailor:
Thank you for the suggestion. I considered a Rogue version...."Minion Trafficking" but I kept it a Priest card because 1) I'm stubborn ;) , 2) because I feel support does exist for this concept, & 3) I wanted to also incorporate an auxiliary function for the card in the form of countering Rogue deck stacking.
Perhaps we wouldn't just drop this card into a Standard deck like this one that's been making the rounds but it illustrates the potential.
Standard Infinity Priest:
Wild Weasel Infinity Tunnel Priest
I am.
Some ideas. Trading feedback for feedback.
@Sillyraptor
Tranquility is incredibly weak, and kinda boring. I'd go with G'huun or Joy Ride. While I like G'huun more, I think that +5/+5 is too much.
@Wailor
I like The Wereloc more, just because of flavour. However, both cards feels a bit weak to me, however I'd need to see them in game to be more sure.
@kegstandgoldmedalist
Lady Deathwhisper asks a lot but I would definitely build this deck. Witchwood Piper might guest star.
Soul Searcher is interesting to me (I enjoy seeing rarities given in-game utility) but the design will likely lead to a sketchy result that doesn't make the restriction feel worth it, even with the glimpse at some of their deck ... #thatfeelingwhen you play Thoughtsteal and pull weapon buffs. At least with Thoughtsteal it might buff your Spellstones.
Keeper Remulos is turned to 11. It is effectively Twinspell for free. The restriction is in line with the challenge but when compared against Odd & Even decks' hero power boost, they didn't gain this level of upside at the Start of Game.
I am.
Lady Deathwhisper is interesting and well-balanced, actually a really good idea.
Soul Researcher is strange...because most of the time, your opponent's spells have a lot of class synergy and will be pretty useless for priest, also, some classes' spells are bad on their own compared to priest spells. I wouldn't go with that one.
Keeper Remulos is cool too, i don't think it's too OP, because Remulos is useless himself and deck restriction is pretty heavy. I prefer Remulos among others.
Reposting my card here for more feedback:
@GerVez0512
I think that idea is good, but maybe Shatterstar have right about being similar to Rogue Quest. Even if that doesn't realy bother me, it can matter to some people. Maybe try to improve it somehow, but I think you should try with this idea, because its pretty good. Also, I'm not sure because there's not such card in game, but I think that 'Summon a 1/1 Imp" should be before Start of Game. (unless you want to summon it at the start of game, what's definetly OP, and also I don't like when card does literally nothing when played)
Thanks for the feedback, even though it looks like you’ve already submitted for this comp. I’ll try to return the favor next week.
@GerVez0512
Mixed feelings about this one, but I lean toward intrigued. While I agree that the effect is a bit too much like quest rogue, I really like that it creates a brand-new archetype for warlock. I think I would upvote on that basis alone.
Feedbacking other cards on this page to see if I can get a little more feedback on my cards:
@Raptor:
Joy Ride, easily. I would however change the second half to “If your deck has only Mechs, cast this again.” Btw, did you mean for the deck restriction to be all cards, or just all minions? Otherwise I think it’s way too restrictive, even nullifying itself if you run two copies.
@Wailor
I guess I don’t see the upside to either of these cards. I suppose there’s some synergy with cards that tutor Murlocs into your hand, but otherwise you’re just putting a bunch of Pit Fighters in your deck. OK Royal Guards have slightly better stats, but it doesn’t seem worth the deckbuilding restrictions. What am I missing?
Hey all, I think this is qualifies. I like the theme and mechanic. It might work just to thin out a deck but mostly to go full aggro...I have a feeling we might miss that unloved step child 'full aggro'.
Thanks for all the feedback! I changed my card slighly to make less similar to the rogue quest (and work better with Call of the Void). Also changed wording as @MurderyUnicorn suggested.
Sorry if I'm posting too much, but as @GerVez0512 said (thanks for the feedback man!) I would like to know if this counts towards the theme. About making it a class card, I thought about it (Warrior), but as it upgrades Schemes I would like it to be Neutral. Didn't know Wrathion wasn't a Dragon BTW, thanks for the advice, I'll change it!
Click here to see my custom pirate adventure, The Treasures of VanCleef! https://www.hearthpwn.com/forums/hearthstone-general/fan-creations/240766-expansion-competition-the-treasures-of-vancleef
I apologize for not saying something sooner, but I would say that it does not count toward the theme. This card does not require proper deck-building for the Battlecry to activate: you could generate/Discover one into your hand and still benefit. It's not a Prince Keleseth/Baku the Mooneater kind of card.
Behold, foolish interlopers! I am commanding this mortal to spread the will of the Scourge throughout the interwebs, encouraging you to seek out me, Archlich Kel'Thuzad! Now coming to you as the tenth class of Hearthstone!
I am a finalist in this Class Creation Competition, so if you could give it a look I would be greatly appreciative <3
Thanks for replying!
So if I say 'if a Scheme started in your deck' instead of 'if there's a Scheme in your hand or deck' would count?
Click here to see my custom pirate adventure, The Treasures of VanCleef! https://www.hearthpwn.com/forums/hearthstone-general/fan-creations/240766-expansion-competition-the-treasures-of-vancleef
I guess so? It's hard to to say where the line is between Yay and Nay, so in the interest of leniency it's better to say Yes.
Behold, foolish interlopers! I am commanding this mortal to spread the will of the Scourge throughout the interwebs, encouraging you to seek out me, Archlich Kel'Thuzad! Now coming to you as the tenth class of Hearthstone!
I am a finalist in this Class Creation Competition, so if you could give it a look I would be greatly appreciative <3
@mods, does my submission on page 4 count? It doesn't have an "if" like Reno Jackson and most other example cards, but neither does Blastmaster Boom. Here's the card:
@wailor hmm, I'm kinda in the same boat as you with my card. I was going on the basis that the soft cost of Corpsetaker. Without Blastmaster and the word 'if', as you point out, might have disqualified us both but since Blastmaster is an example, I can't see any issue: Both effects are non-functioning if the decks not built with specific cards (bombs/murlocs/1-Cost), then by degrees it's based of personal design.
Anyway: I was wondering about my card's art - should i change it, and importantly, can i change it? It's on page 4 for 2 days now. they all tell the story pretty well, but no2 is most hearthstoney. no3 is the current. Finding this 'martyr' art is tricky as not to be very Old Testament haha!
I think you should change the art, and I'm pretty sure you can.
If you struggle to find one, just google "paladin wow artwork" and choose one which is being attacked or something like that.
thanks for the direction, I'll try, although it's also tough to find a paladin who looks like a 0/1 ;D, not many 'downtown' pallys, haha!