Hearthpwn

I thought of photoshoping it myself, but i have no idea who the artist is. On this topic though....how can i submit my own border if i find the time to make one myself?

Quote from Noah_McGrath >>

I thought of photoshoping it myself, but i have no idea who the artist is. On this topic though....how can i submit my own border if i find the time to make one myself?

 Apparently the person in charge of Hearthcards is dnikko, but I tried to et in contact with them and they didn't answer.

Quote from Shatterstar1998 >>

So, I have an idea for the Witchwood that I really want to include but I feel it would be too broken with the Quest. Should I nerf the Quest Reward back to 1 damage and 1 heal? Should I just limit the Echo card to minions? Or is it fine because you have to complete a Quest to get it? Should I just leave the Quest Reward as it is and then nerf it in the next round per Blizzard's tradition?

+ 

You could go for a 3 mana deal 2 damage effect. 2 mana echo effects are very strong and with your current quest it could be a little broken. I wouldn't change the quest because the card in cause is op but the other way around. 

@Shatterstar1998

As that's a quest reward, I'm not sure if the combo is so much broken. You can always change Endless Curiosity to target only minions, what still would be pretty strong with quest, but won't give you uncontroled burst.

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Have some time left, here's a review for everyone who hasn't submitted yet

@IceKing16

Un'goro

I can withstand the fact that you used the Quest I wanted to use, but ALL other cards in this are waaay too close to my Alchemist. You have both multi-tribe synergy and 1-Cost minion synergy. I can't get behind that.

KFT

• Permafrost Drake could be a 4/5
• Melting Barrage's image is dead
• Ah Puch is complicated, and the base effect is better than the Favor one most of the time.
• The Lich King card's effect looks too trivial

@Turkeybag

Un'goro

• Same comment as last phase: Your cards are waay too complicated!
• Your Training Dummy synergies have the same problem as Jade stuff back in MSoG: You are required to play ALL the Training Dummy synergy if you want this to be effective. Your Quest should be broad enough to be completed with a variety of cards

KFT

• Cards are complicated, again
•  Solidify weapon can pretty much be "Give your Weapon +2 Durability". You're always gonna attack before playing this.
• Animated Wookwaker could just be "Summon two 0/3 Training Dummys" since Dummys are generic minions
• "your hero's attack" on Searlus
• The DK seems super weak and not very interesting

@NiRast

Un'goro

•  Tortollan Cannoneer looks too powerful
• Extinction Event is too confusing
• I got a very similar idea to your Territorial Firehound for my set lul

Overall I like the set, in particular the minion merging stuff. I might draw inspiration for that, lel

KFT

•  Nothing in particular to say, except that I don't really like the art

@Noah_McGrath

Un'goro

•  Sanguing Spring heals your hero whenever a minion dies, not whenever "anything" dies.
• Skull-Feather Amuler -> "loses"
• The Moon's Chosen is a strict powercreep on Polymorph, which is already very strong

KFT

 No KFT set yet?

@Wailor

Un'goro

• Exotic Fragrances wouldn't work imo
• Paleochemist Nydia should cost more.

KFT

•  Twisted Geneticist
• The rest of the set looks alright

Overall both of your sets lack synergy with your Transmute keyword.

@thepowrofcheese

Un'goro

•  It's a personal thing, but I don't like "this game" effect that aren't trackable (one of the many reasons why Crystal Core is bad)
• Exploit Un'goro could cost (2).

KFT

• Plaguemaster Bork is OP as fuck for this cost. It should cost 9 or even 10.
• Spark of Madness could cost less given its random nature.
• Festergut is too confusing. Dealing damage to minions that aren't on the board is impossible.
• Blightmare is best.

 Overall I like your sets. Cool ideas. Guaranteed future finalist and maybe winner.

@Piricival

Un'goro

Crap, I had almost the same idea for my quest

•  I don't understand Dino-Might. Is it supposed to affect future copies of the card?
• Evergreen Grower is waaay too good on turn 2. It's even worse than Mole into Razormaw.

KFT

•  Magic Forcefield sucks, it could cost less.
• First Izzy.

@krowski_nall

Your images are dead bro

@SunnoxPL

Un'goro

•  The Quest is waaaay too hard to complete, especially since your set only has ONE support card for the archetype!
• The rest of your cards are too simple and lack originality. Besides the Adapt one, all could have been in the classic set.

KFT

•  Void Touch is bad because it can give permastealth

(also, my last post didn't receive feedback)

 

 

 @CheeseEtc

I'm sorry you feel that way.I  I wanted to do the Tribe synergy quest since I started the competition and I printed Tribal minions in both the Basic and Classic set to give it a push. I didn't mean to copy your ideas in any way. I will change the elemental so it won't be 1-Cost related. The interaction between tribes is a cool mechanic and it seemed quite appealing. Again, sorry for the incovenience, I will play with the tribes as individuals in future sets and not between-tribes synergies so you can further explore your theme. 

I have some adjustments to make to the Knights set but I will try to do it these days. I replaced the missing image card with another one because I didn't find it fitting in the set. The Ah Puch effect is a bit tricky. The battlecry resummons all dragons that died, which won't be so much of a threat because they will mostly be low-stated minions, while the favor one will summon the big ones from your hand, but will leave you vulnerable to a powerful board clear and with no cards in your hand. It really depends on the situation. I will look into the Death Knight effect, trying to come with something more unique.

Thanks for the feedback and good luck.

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Have some time left, here's a review for everyone who hasn't submitted yet.

@NiRast

Un'goro

•  Tortollan Cannoneer looks too powerful
• Extinction Event is too confusing
• I got a very similar idea to your Territorial Firehound for my set lul

Overall I like the set, in particular the minion merging stuff. I might draw inspiration for that, lel

KFT

•  Nothing in particular to say, except that I don't really like the art

 

 I could reduce the Canonneer's health and/or damage by one. I still mentain it's weaker than Ship's Cannon.

Well, I needed to scrap an epic anyway. Might as well be this one.

Territorial Firehound was scraped a while back.

Anything in particular you don't like about the art?

Just a reminder that everyone has until next Saturday to submit their entries; that's six days from now. We've made it to the final week....of this Phase lel.

Sorry for not posting any feedback for ages, but I have huge exams in 2 weeks. I also kinda lost interest in the comp for a while, but I decided not to give up. Is it too late to give feedback ? 

My Ungoro set:

 Full KotFT:

 Feedback very appreciated ! :)

Edit: Replaced one card with Dream Shield.

Edit2: Added Lick King boss fight card.

Quote from SunnoxPL >>

Sorry for not posting any feedback for ages, but I have huge exams in 2 weeks. I also kinda lost interest in the comp for a while, but I decided not to give up. Is it too late to give feedback ? 

My Ungoro set:

 Full KotFT:

 Feedback very appreciated ! :)

Edit: Replaced one card with Dream Shield.

Edit2: Added Lick King boss fight card.

 

 One of your rare Un'Goro cards isn't showing.

Ogirm is super weak. A 6 mana 4/5 has no chance of surviving until next turn, so unless you plan of having an effect similar to Houndmaster Shaw later down the line, I'd make this a 5 mana 4/4 or 3/5.

Dream shield could probably be a 2/3.

Infected Husk could be 3 mana

The rest of the cards seem fine. If you want to give me feedback, I suggest you wait a bit. I'm thinking of giving my Un'Goro set an overhaul.

Lol just realized that I posted my old Un'Goro cards :/ I'll repost tomorrow (i have to sleep) , so don't waste time on giving feedback to my Un'Goro set above.

The Knight, Pure Void should have 'until your next turn' (sorry for those mistakes but I'm in a rush)

Reposting, now with correct cards and some minior changes

Ungoro:

KotFT;

 Feedback very appreciated ! :)

Question: Is the token limit per expansion or overall? Can i have 9 tokens in Un'Goro and 3 in Frozen Throne for example?

Quote from teknician >>

Could I change the cards I'm showcasing?

I don't see why not.