Hearthpwn

Okay, seems that the most promising entries still got here, that's good! Now to vote for the challenges.

• The 1st one seems okay-ish, I mean, it's artwork. it CAN be easy, though there isn't too much Tortollian Artwork, going to pass this one
• 2nd one. Could be cool. Going for it. Not too much to talk about honestly.
• I mean, we fought through the Cult Following, I bet people are going to hate this and not going to vote for it.
• Huh. I mean, huh. Could be interesting to work with. Voting for it.
• OH MAN WE NEED TO MAKE A MINION SINCE IT PUTS ITSELF ONTO THE BATTLEFIELD. In all seriousness, I don't know.
• This one is a traditional one, yes, people WILL make cards to help the quest 100%.

I'm going with 2, 4 and 6. Though all the other's seem interesting, except the 3rd challenge.

But for the love of god, people are definetively be against challenge #3. It restricts WAY too much the gang thing.

I'll miss Cogito beign mod T_T

Excited to see how this pans out! As usual, I love to see you guys work, and you guys never fail to astound me! Good luck everyone!

(I made the challenges as the last thing I did before I quit being a mod, so you're still at the mercy at me. :P)

Heck yeah. So I thought about making Time Traveler a Kabal class, but now I'm thinking of maybe making my own crime family. I could use thepowrofcheese's Chronomancer class and something else. On to the challenges though:

• What the Shell is simple. It doesn't fit my class, but it's not that bad. I wouldn't want this to win, but I can bear it if it does.
• A Dish Best Served Cold may be hated by some, but it's fine for me. In addition to being worthless if your class already follows an existing family, I could use Hailey's Keeper class and the Chronomancer class and make a time faction if I choose to and if I find a mechanic. Or I could just make it a Kabal class.
• This Town Ain't Big Enough is my least favorite of the challenges, but at least it's not Cult Following again. *shrgus* Don't make me go down that path again.
• One of my class cards actually already follows Prehistoric Table, so I'm set.
• Patch Clusterfuck is fine by me if copying counts. Can it put a copy in (like Barnes), or is it supposed to be like Recruit. A bit ambiguous.
• Raid Party Rave Party is good for me and my Quest.

Speaking of my Quest, I can't wait for you guys to see my Quest. Some will love it, some others will probably hate it, but I LOVE it.

Voting 1, 4, 5 and 6, just to hope 2 and 3 don't win. I don't really like restricting the gangs like that honestly... I barely even know what 3 REALLY means as well. Other than that, glad to make it through and enraged that thepowerofcheese didn't and excited to continue working.

Isn't challenge #2 kind of unfair for people who have a new crime family and have already fluff for it that doesn't fit with any eliminated class? And a challenge that doesn't include everyone is kind of dumb, no? Like it's already more work to make a new crime family and then you also get 'punished' for it. Feels actually unfair to me.

Quote from Schlauchneid >>

Isn't challenge #2 kind of unfair for people who have a new crime family and have already fluff for it that doesn't fit with any eliminated class? And a challenge that doesn't include everyone is kind of dumb, no? Like it's already more work to make a new crime family and then you also get 'punished' for it. Feels pretty stupid to me this challenge.

Quote from Demonxz95 >>

 

Quote from Schlauchneid >>

Isn't challenge #2 kind of unfair for people who have a new crime family and have already fluff for it that doesn't fit with any eliminated class? And a challenge that doesn't include everyone is kind of dumb, no? Like it's already more work to make a new crime family and then you also get 'punished' for it. Feels pretty stupid to me this challenge.

Unfortunately sometimes a lot of these challenges are specifically made to be unfair and bend your set a lot. Need I bring up Cult Following? I believe the previous Class competition had a challenge where one of your cards needed to be a Pokemon.

I made Shadow proud by only voting for #1.

 Voted 1, 4, 5, and 6.

Challenge 2 is cool, but since it only applies to some competitors and not to others, it feels a little unfair, especially by restricting only those who did go into the extra effort to make their own gang.

I feel like Challenge 3 could be interesting, but it'd have to be a really vague counter with lots of other uses in order for it to make sense as  a class card, like 'Disable the next Battlecry' or something, which kinda defeats the point.

Sad that it's over before it properly came together but at least I can spend my time more productively now.  Good luck to all and thanks to te few of you who did like my class.

Oh I made it

The into says "8 people who made it to the next round" but there are 9 people listed. Am I missing something?

1. Please no, I understand you like turtles Shadows but there must be something like 1 or 2 tortollan artworks that aren't used in un'goro (we could get some turtleman artwork from other games but it wouldn't be as good).
2. Zanywoop and I already started thinking about a common gang so I like this one. It would the occasion to use that awesome Chef Kargath art that I HAVE TO use at some point.
3. So you can counter the Kabal by shuffling duplicates in the opponent's deck but then? Not sure how cards that counter the Grimy Goons or the larger and larger men would be interesting. I don't like this one.
4. Ok. Not original but at least it doesn't fuck over our classes.
5. This one is interesting.
6. I guess most people will do quest synergy anyway, so this is a non-challenge.

Voted for 2,4,5,6.