Hearthpwn

Quote from LarryMoments >>

Alrightie, second round of feedback, not much of new things, just cards.

Coward Warturtle: Pretty straightforward, a usefull 2-Drop for Priest, you've already seen it before so I don't think I have to explain it.

Fin Reaper: Between of those weakling that don't deserve to survive, the death comes to live, as taking the Murloc's that aren't worth to live, not good fighters, but anywhere, the souls come to you, as you gain power by summoning minions like Darkshire Librarian or Possessed Lackey to trigger their effect without any risks. Or gain tons of health with Forbidden Ritual or Murloc Tidehunter.

Feedback takey-take round!

@Entro9: I like it, however a Battlecry would be FAR better since of the Enrage effects and the other things, could probably cost (6), though not sure since it can be a double-edged sword.

@DarkArtisan: Sunseeker Drake seems like the most interesting one, I would make it a 5/4 though, as you can get random things or just gain 10 Armor for a Deathwing at most, which is actually pretty nice. Taru feels like a Krul the Unshackled reprint, it doesn't feels original.

 

Quote from LarryMoments >>

Alrightie, second round of feedback, not much of new things, just cards.

Coward Warturtle: Pretty straightforward, a usefull 2-Drop for Priest, you've already seen it before so I don't think I have to explain it.

Fin Reaper: Between of those weakling that don't deserve to survive, the death comes to live, as taking the Murloc's that aren't worth to live, not good fighters, but anywhere, the souls come to you, as you gain power by summoning minions like Darkshire Librarian or Possessed Lackey to trigger their effect without any risks. Or gain tons of health with Forbidden Ritual or Murloc Tidehunter.

Feedback takey-take round!

@Entro9: I like it, however a Battlecry would be FAR better since of the Enrage effects and the other things, could probably cost (6), though not sure since it can be a double-edged sword.

@DarkArtisan: Sunseeker Drake seems like the most interesting one, I would make it a 5/4 though, as you can get random things or just gain 10 Armor for a Deathwing at most, which is actually pretty nice. Taru feels like a Krul the Unshackled reprint, it doesn't feels original.

I just created a separate thread for my card(s) since I was commenting so much and had so many options. Go vote on my cards if you want to help me out!

I'll still offer my opinions here too, I'm just trying to keep the clutter down.

Quote from Likafoss >>

I just created a separate thread for my card(s) since I was commenting so much and had so many options. Go vote on my cards if you want to help me out!

I'll still offer my opinions here too, I'm just trying to keep the clutter down.

Ephemeral Assassin is beyond broken with kingsbane--it is a 2 mana minion that can be bounced or copied with Valeera the hollow and hit face. With a 7-attack kingsbane, this means that you can play the assassin, the copy of the assassin from valeera and shadowstep it for a third strike to deal 21 damage with 2 cards and 4 mana (not to mention that you can hit for a 4th strike with an attack, totaling 28 damage).

Kind of worried about the language on the token, you guys know of a better way to put that?

My cards \I/

I tried to keep this monster out of this discussion but here I am again. Open the massive spoiler and let me know what you like and any adjustments I could make, if any. Feedback for feedback!

Quote from LookingForOwls >>

Kind of worried about the language on the token, you guys know of a better way to put that?

Here are a couple ideas:

Crystal Ambusher: a great addition to the miracle and mill rogue archetypes that lets you not only draw without fear of burning key combo cards, but gives you the power to steal cards from your opponent while milling them. The drawback is that you don't know what you are going to get and can dilute your deck if you aren't careful, but the value of adding cards to your deck in a mill deck is clear. 

Archmage's Familiar: This card could let you replicate key spells equal to 5 mana (frost bolt + nova) or less on turn 10 by pinging it, or you can risk it surviving a turn on the board to get a full turn's worth of spells returned to your hand (e.g. 2 fireballs and a frost bolt). It could be REALLY powerful but must be played carefully because of the loss of tempo you suffer when playing it.

Quote from jsager99 >>

Here are a couple ideas:

Crystal Ambusher: a great addition to the miracle and mill rogue archetypes that lets you not only draw without fear of burning key combo cards, but gives you the power to steal cards from your opponent while milling them. The drawback is that you don't know what you are going to get and can dilute your deck if you aren't careful, but the value of adding cards to your deck in a mill deck is clear. 

Archmage's Familiar: This card could let you replicate key spells equal to 5 mana (frost bolt + nova) or less on turn 10 by pinging it, or you can risk it surviving a turn on the board to get a full turn's worth of spells returned to your hand (e.g. 2 fireballs and a frost bolt). It could be REALLY powerful but must be played carefully because of the loss of tempo you suffer when playing it.

I'm late to the party, but I come with three ideas - all Dragons, of course, for Dragons are the greatest tribe of them all! except Mechs

Sandstorm Dragon should say "If you're", but I can fix it later. The flavor behind the effect is that he hides in the sandstorm (the Stealth), while the sands bite at his enemies' flesh (the Battlecry). As for Terror Drake, his intimidating entrance frightens enemy minions, and they'll need an extra incentive if you want them to fight it. It's just like Loatheb, but for minions instead of spells.

Finally, I'd want Alexstrasza, Life-Giver to be the Reno Jackson of Armor Warrior and/or Control-orientated Dragon Warriors. It's a play on Alexstrasza's Classic effect, combined with the "If you have 12 or less Health" trigger found on Mortal Strike and Revenge. She has the same stats as her Classic self, not unlike Deathwing/Deathwing, Dragonlord.

I've got to go shovel some snow, but I'll return afterward to provide a feedback-dump.

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

 

Quote from SrVitor >>

 Any tips here guys? 

 The second "Stealth" has to be capitalized.

Since there is no way to give your opponent's minions Stealth, then the ability seem rather redunant. Streetwise Investigator didn't prove to be useful for a reason.

The card overall is allright. However i don't really get the flavor for it to Silence enemy minions.

 

Quote from Kovachut >>

So may I ask for some opinion? And mainly in terms of balance.

Token for the last card:

Inb4 I really wanted to find a pic, which resembles the murloc disguise, sadly I couldn't find one, where you see the face of the person underneath the costume. So I understand, that the art is a fail. If someone actually approves of those cards, I will try to add a patch or something like that.

Quote from Likafoss >>

My cards \I/

 

Spoiler (click to hide)

 

I tried to keep this monster out of this discussion but here I am again. Open the massive spoiler and let me know what you like and any adjustments I could make, if any. Feedback for feedback!

Quote from Likafoss >>

My cards \I/

 

Spoiler (click to hide)

 

I tried to keep this monster out of this discussion but here I am again. Open the massive spoiler and let me know what you like and any adjustments I could make, if any. Feedback for feedback!

Quote from linkblade91 >>

I'm late to the party, but I come with three ideas - all Dragons, of course, for Dragons are the greatest tribe of them all! except Mechs

When it comes to Dragon Rogue, I think such cards would focus on an oft-forgotten aspect of Dragons: they are extremely cunning, and for some, they display a ruthlessness and merciless attitude toward lesser species. In the minds of evil Dragons, the rest of us are just insects, or toys for their amusement. Hearthstone has shown us the physical might, mental fortitude and grandiose scale of Dragons, but hasn't really shown us how scary they can be.

Sandstorm Dragon should say "If you're", but I can fix it later. The flavor behind the effect is that he hides in the sandstorm (the Stealth), while the sands bite at his enemies' flesh (the Battlecry). As for Terror Drake, his intimidating entrance frightens enemy minions, and they'll need an extra incentive if you want them to fight it. It's just like Loatheb, but for minions instead of spells.

Finally, I'd want Alexstrasza, Life-Giver to be the Reno Jackson of Armor Warrior and/or Control-orientated Dragon Warriors. It's a play on Alexstrasza's Classic effect, combined with the "If you have 12 or less Health" trigger found on Mortal Strike and Revenge. She has the same stats as her Classic self, not unlike Deathwing/Deathwing, Dragonlord.

I've got to go shovel some snow, but I'll return afterward to provide a feedback-dump.

Quote from linkblade91 >>

I'm late to the party, but I come with three ideas - all Dragons, of course, for Dragons are the greatest tribe of them all! except Mechs

When it comes to Dragon Rogue, I think such cards would focus on an oft-forgotten aspect of Dragons: they are extremely cunning, and for some, they display a ruthlessness and merciless attitude toward lesser species. In the minds of evil Dragons, the rest of us are just insects, or toys for their amusement. Hearthstone has shown us the physical might, mental fortitude and grandiose scale of Dragons, but hasn't really shown us how scary they can be.

Sandstorm Dragon should say "If you're", but I can fix it later. The flavor behind the effect is that he hides in the sandstorm (the Stealth), while the sands bite at his enemies' flesh (the Battlecry). As for Terror Drake, his intimidating entrance frightens enemy minions, and they'll need an extra incentive if you want them to fight it. It's just like Loatheb, but for minions instead of spells.

Finally, I'd want Alexstrasza, Life-Giver to be the Reno Jackson of Armor Warrior and/or Control-orientated Dragon Warriors. It's a play on Alexstrasza's Classic effect, combined with the "If you have 12 or less Health" trigger found on Mortal Strike and Revenge. She has the same stats as her Classic self, not unlike Deathwing/Deathwing, Dragonlord.

I've got to go shovel some snow, but I'll return afterward to provide a feedback-dump.

 

@Kovachut: Thanks for your comments on my cards! You seem to misunderstand the Pirate's Greed token however. It works like the WIld card Curse of Rafaam that gives your opponent a Cursed! card. It's an ongoing effect that at the start of your opponent's turn, they take 2 damage and have to spend the 2 mana to stop the damage and rid themselves of the card.

My card is just the same, however, instead of direct damage it summons a 2/2 for you. It also gives them a Coin (to play along with the greed aspect) so either they pay the 3 mana to stop the 2/2's or are greedy and keep the Coins produced by the card.

I do see the balance Issue with my dragon though, thanks.

I've narrowed it down to two versions of the First Mate's Scout, I'll post an updated set once I tweak the cards.