Hearthpwn

Mathias Shaw an 10 mana 1/1 that gains +1/+1 for each card played this game.

what do you you think of this card? Please leave an comment below.

As a rule of a thumb, no 10 mana card that doesn't do something turn it's played is any good.

At least compared to Tyrantus this one would automatically win you the game if it survived for one turn.

Quote from Essavias >>

As a rule of a thumb, no 10 mana card that doesn't do something turn it's played is any good.

Quote from Seagull0 >>

Quote from Essavias >>

As a rule of a thumb, no 10 mana card that doesn't do something turn it's played is any good.

 Not true. Played deathwing, dragonlord many times and won.

At least compared to this, Tyrantus can't be targeted.

How about with Aviana+Kun?

Quote from DoubleSummon >>

Quote from Seagull0 >>

Quote from Essavias >>

As a rule of a thumb, no 10 mana card that doesn't do something turn it's played is any good.

 Not true. Played deathwing, dragonlord many times and won.

 yeah, while your opponent is at 6 mana.

Well you could play that and then coin + Conceal to win more often (in wild)

So I read your comments and the main problem i see is that it doesn't do anything when it comes into play. So I thought maybe if we add another battlecry effect like for example:

-Deal damage randomly split across the board equal to this minions attack

-Choose one: Cant be silenced or Taunt and cant  be targeted by spells and hero powers.

Or maybe an deathrattle effect like:

-when this minion dies randomly split this minions health across  all other friendly minions.

-destroy 2 enemy minions that cost (5) or more. 

What do you guys think of these changes?

Quote from yessassin >>

So I read your comments and the main problem i see is that it doesn't do anything when it comes into play. So I thought maybe if we add another battlecry effect like for example:

-Deal damage randomly split across the board equal to this minions attack

-Choose one: Cant be silenced or Taunt and cant  be targeted by spells and hero powers.

Or maybe an deathrattle effect like:

-when this minion dies randomly split this minions health across  all other friendly minions.

-destroy 2 enemy minions that cost (5) or more. 

 

What do you guys think of these changes?

This thing is gonna be like 20/20 minimum when it drops on board, an additional effect would be massively OP. The fact that it can be silenced is a small price to pay considering Priest is the only class to often runs silence. It's basically OP as is, whether or not it would see play is another matter as the 10 mana spot is a tough one to fill.

Not playable. Tonnes of silenceable stats is way too weak. Generally, vanilla stat minions stop being good already on turn 5 (Bittertide Hydra), from turn 6, synergies, impact and additional effects is what matters.

and what do you think of the secondary effects that i posted? would that help the card in some way?

Quote from OldKeith >>

Quote from Essavias >>

As a rule of a thumb, no 10 mana card that doesn't do something turn it's played is any good.

 *cough* Deathwibg Dragonlord *cough*

Quote from OldKeith >>

Quote from Essavias >>

As a rule of a thumb, no 10 mana card that doesn't do something turn it's played is any good.

 *cough* Deathwibg Dragonlord *cough*

Quote from Essavias >>

Quote from OldKeith >>

Quote from Essavias >>

As a rule of a thumb, no 10 mana card that doesn't do something turn it's played is any good.

 *cough* Deathwibg Dragonlord *cough*

And there's a reason this card sees as much play as it does, innit? 

The minion as it is currently would not see play because it is a 10 mana card with no immediate effect. If you were so as to add the effects you mentioned the card would be too overpowered. Really, it just is not that great of an idea. Sorry! (No offence intended)