Hearthpwn

Alright, I have to make a choice so I'll go with Doom Shredder if the thread is advertised on the front page. Even though the feedback I've received was conflicting, the ones for Doom Shredder have been more enthusiastic. I consider "X is awesome!" to be better than "I think X is the best of your cards" since the latter could mean "X is the best of your cards but they're still all mediocre".

However I'm still undecided on which art to use. Here are the ones I have:

I know 3 of them aren't actually Shredders, but there aren't that many shredder arts out there!

In case the front page post doesn't come up this time, it is safer for me to go with the non-meme card so I'll go with Venomfang Totem which received the most positive feedback. I still hesitate about making it 4mana 0/4 or 5mana 0/6. Some says the former is OP, other that it is fine.

I will start a new job this monday so I won't be on hearthpwn 24/7 like now.

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

I will start a new job this monday so I won't be on hearthpwn 24/7 like now.

 Wait. You can't be on Hearthpwn 24/7 with a job?

Someone should really have told me.

---

Also, your prayers have been heard, and Front Page Coverage has been delivered!

Quote from CheeseEtc >>

Alright, I have to make a choice so I'll go with Doom Shredder if the thread is advertised on the front page. Even though the feedback I've received was conflicting, the ones for Doom Shredder have been more enthusiastic. I consider "X is awesome!" to be better than "I think X is the best of your cards" since the latter could mean "X is the best of your cards but they're still all mediocre".

However I'm still undecided on which art to use. Here are the ones I have:

Do note that the last one has a different name more in line with Hallow's End.

I know 3 of them aren't actually Shredders, but there aren't that many shredder arts out there!

In case the front page post doesn't come up this time, it is safer for me to go with the non-meme card so I'll go with Venomfang Totem which received the most positive feedback. I still hesitate about making it 4mana 0/4 or 5mana 0/6. Some says the former is OP, other that it is fine.

I will start a new job this monday so I won't be on hearthpwn 24/7 like now.

Quote from linkblade91 >>

Quote from Broeck1 >>

That's.... interesting. Very interesting. I am not sure how it would work mechanically though. ...Personally I feel it's too complicated for HS standards. What about making it "Poisonous. Battlecry: The first card your opponent plays next turn must be a minion, if possible."? Something like that?

Quote from Ozymandias >>

@linkblade91 I like the card, but honestly i don't think it will recieve many upvotes, historically cards that odd are not very good received. Since has such a polarized effect, poisonous and is a beast, maybe could be a 1/1@ 

 Well this isn't going well :( Would any of these phrasing-variants sound more appealing? The original is on the left:

What's this?

Notes: Image Verification Process Run!
Last edited by Arthas on 6 mins ago

seems to be at everyone who've edited their posts (in the submission topic)?

Quote from linkblade91 >>

Quote from nurgling13 >>

 I don't think this is possible for Hearthstone. In a simple case, what if you had 5 mana, with a 4 mana spell and a 2 mana minion in your hand. Does the game calculate that playing the 4 mana spell would make it impossible to play the 2 mana minion and not let you do it? Now for a really complex case: you have a Darnassus Aspirant and a minion with 3 attack, and your opponent has a Hunter Secret out. You have exactly enough mana to play your only minion. Are you not allowed to attack the with the Aspirant, because the Secret might be Misdirection which might also make the Aspirant attack your 3-attack minion, killing it and making you lose the Mana Crystal, and so you can't play a minion, although you could have before?

 I'm not sure why such a scenario would play out, with the Darnassus Aspirant. If you don't have enough mana to play the minion, then you are not "able" and thus can ignore the Battlecry. Hell, you could do this on purpose to get around it. As for the other example, if the phrasing demanded they play a minion first, it would only highlight minions as playable until they fulfilled the obligation.

*shrugs* Guess it doesn't matter. On to the next idea...

Quote from Lathy >>

What's this?

Notes: Image Verification Process Run!
Last edited by Arthas on 6 mins ago

seems to be at everyone who've edited their posts (in the submission topic)?

Quote from nurgling13 >>

Quote from Lathy >>

What's this?

Notes: Image Verification Process Run!
Last edited by Arthas on 6 mins ago

seems to be at everyone who've edited their posts (in the submission topic)?

There's a bot that checks that images aren't from Hearthcards now. 

Quote from TheProgenitor >>

Thanks to all who gave feedback! It looks like I'm going with a modified Lord Stal, though I have two different versions I'm debating between.

One is just bigger with the same Cost while the other is cheaper to allow for Brann shenanigans. Which one is better? I like the potential for big Trolden moments with the Brann combo, but that might be too degenerate and undermine making it only copy twice, inconsistency or no.

Quote from TheProgenitor >>

Quote from TheProgenitor >>

Thanks to all who gave feedback! It looks like I'm going with a modified Lord Stal, though I have two different versions I'm debating between.

One is just bigger with the same Cost while the other is cheaper to allow for Brann shenanigans. Which one is better? I like the potential for big Trolden moments with the Brann combo, but that might be too degenerate and undermine making it only copy twice, inconsistency or no.

 Bump

Quote from ThisOtherGuyTox >>

Quote from Lathy >>

What's this?

Notes: Image Verification Process Run!
Last edited by Arthas on 6 mins ago

seems to be at everyone who've edited their posts (in the submission topic)?

 Basically Skynet has taken over Hearthpwn, and all mods have been replaced with robotic versions of themselves.

Next step is replacing all the competitors with bots, so we can be assured that no card has any sort of mistakes in them.